Authors: Philip Roth
only two of the candidates from the Professor's list,
may I ask if we can each add two names of our own,
should we think we have more that warrant
suspicion?
TRICKY:,
Well, let me ask you a question.
Is this a deal you want to make?
LEGAL COACH:
Well, if you want to think of it
that way, that's okay with me.
TRICKY:
I'd prefer to. Otherwise it might seem that I
was changing my mind because I'm indecisive. But
if it's just a matter of a payoff for something or
other you'll deliver in the future, I think everybody
here will understand.
LEGAL COACH:
Suits Me.
TRICKY:
There we are then. Two from the Professor's
list and two of your own choice.
HIGHBROW COACH:
To the list then, gentlemen.
is
Hanoi. z: The
Berrigans. 3: The Black Panthers. 4 : Jane Fonda. 5:
Curt Flood.
ALL:
Curt Flood?
HIGHBROW COACH:
Curt ... Flood.
SPIRITUAL COACH:
But-isn't he a baseball player?
TRICKY:
Was a baseball player. Any questions about
baseball players, just ask me, Reverend.
58
OUR GANG
Was the center fielder for the Washington Senators.
But then he up and ran away. Skipped the
country.
HIGHBROW COACH:
He did indeed, Mr. Pres
ident. Curt Flood, born January 18, 1938, in
Houston, Texas, bats right, throws right, entered big
league baseball in 1956 with Cincinnati, played from
'58 to '69 with the St. Louis Cardinals, presently
under contract at a salary of $110,000 a year to the
Washington Senators, on the morning of April 27,
1971, with the baseball season not even a month
old, boarded a Pan Am flight bound from New
York to Barcelona, giving no explanation for his
hasty departure other than "personal problems."
Though Flood is known to have purchased a ticket
for Barcelona, he apparently disembarked in
Lisbonwearing a brown leather jacket, bellbottomed
trousers and sunglasses-there to make
connections with a flight for his final European
destination ... The question, gentlemen, is obvious:
why, a week to the day before the uprising of the
Boy Scouts in Washington, D.C., why did Mr. Curt
Flood of the Washington baseball team find it
necessary to leave the country in so precipitous and
dramatic a fashion?
TRICKY:
Oh, I think I can answer
that one, Professor, knowing sports as I do inside
and out. Poor Flood was in a slump, and a bad one.
In his first twenty times at bat this year, he'd had
TRICKY HAS ANOTHER CRISIS
59
only three hits, and two of those were bunts. Fact is,
Williams had benched him. He'd sat out six starts in
a
row against right-handed pitching. Now I may be
the highest elected official in the land, but I still
don't think I'm going to second-guess Ted Williams
when he benches a hitter. No, sirree. On the other
hand, you can well imagine the effect being benched
had upon a one-hundred-thousand-dollar-a-year star
player like Flood.
HIGHBROW COACH:
With all due respect, sir, for
your knowledge of the game, which far exceeds my
own, this "slump,"as you call it, might it not have
been just the right "cover" for a baseball player
planning to leave the country in a hurry, just the
right alibi?
LEGAL COACH:
If I get your drift, Professor, are
you suggesting that Ted Williams, the manager of
the Senators, is implicated in this as well? That
benching Flood was part of some overall plan?
POLITICAL COACH:
Now hold- on. Before we
carry this any further, I want to say that I think we
are skating on very thin ice here, when we are
dealing with a baseball figure of Ted Williams'
stature. Despised as he was by many sportswriters in
his time-and I'm sure we could call upon these
people for assistance, if we should want them-my
gut reaction is that it is in the best interests of this
administration to
6o
OUR GANG
maintain a hands-off policy on all Hall of Famers.
TRICKY:
And what a Hall of Famer! I wonder how
many of you know Ted Williams' record. It certainly
is a record for all Americans to be proud of, and I'd
like to share it with you. Just listen and tell me if you
don't agree. Lifetime batting average, .344
.
That
makes him
fifth in
the history of the game. Lifetime
slugging average, .634.
That
makes him second only
to Babe Ruth himself! In doubles, fourteenth with
5
2
5; in home runs fifth with 521; in extra base hits
seventh with
1,117;
and in all-important RBI's, and I
really can't say enough about RBI's and how
important they are to the national pastime, in RBI's,
also seventh with 1,839. And that isn't all. Led the
league in hitting in 1941 with an average of-just
listen to this-.4o6! In
'42
again, with .356; in '47 with
.343;
in '48 with -369-(Suddenly angry) And they said
Jack Charisma was the one who had the memory for
facts! They said
Charisma
was the one who had the
grasp of the issues. Oh, how they loved to
downgrade Dixon! No wonder I had a crisis in that
campaign! They were always picking on me! My
beard! My nose! My tactics! Well, just let me say one
thing as regards my so-called "tactics": if in any of
the averages I have just quoted to you, I have
altered Ted Williams' record by so much as one
hundredth of one per
TRICKY HAS ANOTHER CRISIS 61
centage point, I will submit my resignation to
Congress tomorrow. Now that would be an unprecedented
act in American history, but I would
do it, if I had dared to play party politics with the
American public on a matter as serious as this one.
(All applaud)'
POLITICAL COACH:
Mr. President, that was a
most impressive recitation of the facts and has only
served to strengthen my conviction that it would be
utterly foolhardy to bring a slugger like Williams
under federal indictment.
TRICKY:
Good thinking.
Good sharp political thinking. Of course, with
Flood himself, we have a very different situation. To
be sure, he batted over .300 for the Cards in '61, '63,
'64, '65, '67 and '68, but never once did he lead the
league in hitting or home runs, as Williams did, and
his slugging average is almost half what Williams'
was at the end of his career.
Of course,
in
1964, Flood
did
lead the National
League in base hits with 211, and something like
that could stir up a certain amount of sympathy.
Now let me make one thing perfectly clear: I am
not saying that he is anywhere near the all-time
leader in that department, George Sisler, who got
257 hits in the year
1920,
but a fact is a fact, and we
are going to have to confront it. Those 211 base
hits could mean trouble.
6z
OUR GANG
HIGHBROW COACH:
Mr. President, under ordi
nary circumstances I too might be leery of bringing
a charge as drastic as whichever one we come up
with, against a man who, as you so wisely remind us,
led the National League in total base hits with 2
1I.
But Curt Flood is something more than your runof-
the-mill hitting star of yesteryear: he is a bona
fide troublemaker, and was in hot water right up to
his neck even before I put him on my list. That is
why I put him on my list: for not only has he
jumped a hundred-thousand-dollar contract and
skipped the country only a month into the season,
but he of course is the man who in
1970
refused to
be traded by the St. Louis Cardinals to the Philadelphia
Phillies, claiming that the trade denied him his
basic rights to negotiate a contract for his services
on the open market. Subsequently, he hired as his
attorney none other than Lyin' B. Johnson's
appointee to the Supreme Court .. .
POLITICAL COACH
(hopefully) : Abe Fortas!
HIGHBROW
COACH:
No, no, but almost as good.
Arthur Goldberg. G-o-l-d-b-e-r-g. And these two
instituted a suit against baseball on constitutional
grounds, asserting that organized baseball was in
violation of the Antitrust Laws, and that the
owners, by trading players from one team to
another without their permission, treated them like
pieces of property, which was both illegal and
immoral.
TRICKY HAS ANOTHER CRISES
63
Now, impugning the sacred name of baseball in
this way did not go over very well with a good many
loyal Americans, including the Commissioner of
Baseball himself, and in the eyes of many,
sportswriters and fellow players, as well as fans
throughout the country, Flood, and his mouthpiece
Goldberg, appeared to be out to destroy the game
beloved by millions. Flood, in a book he has written
on the subject, even quotes himself as saying in
conversation, `Somebody needs to go up against the
system. I'm ready." And, gentlemen, that is only one
of the selfincriminating statements that is scattered
throughout that manifesto. Of course, as if all that
he has said and done isn't compromising enoughincluding
hiring a Mr. Goldberg to represent him in
this attack upon the most American of American
sports-Flood is a black man.
LEGAL COACH:
Where is he now, Algeria? That
would sew it up for us, if he was in Algeria.
HIGHBROW COACH:
To the contrary, had he fled
to Algeria-which he has not-they would already be
selling posters of him at bat in a beret, and ads to
"Free Flood" would be appearing daily in The New
York Times, signed by movie stars and Jean-Paul
Sartre. There'd be marches and pickets and probably
one of those mule trains camping on the White
House Lawn.
TRICKY:
Oh, those mule trains! Those
marches!
64
OUR GANG
Really, I can't
stand
those things. It never failsevery
time they start marching on Washington, I'm the