Authors: Philip Roth
Number 4: Jane Fonda, the movie actress and
antiwar activist. Number 5: Curt Flood, the
baseball player. Any questions, before we proceed
to the vote. Reverend?
SPIRITUAL COACH:
Jane Fonda. Has she ever
appeared nude in a film?
HIGHBROW COACH:
I can't honestly say I
remember seeing her pudenda on the screen,
Reverend, but I think I can vouch for her breasts.
SPIRITUAL COACH:
With aureole or without?
HIGHBROW COACH:
I believe with.
SPIRITUAL
COACH:
And her buttocks?
HIGHBROW COACH:
Yes, I believe we've seen
her buttocks. Indeed, they constitute a large part
of her appeal.
SPIRITUAL COACH:
Thank you.
HIGHBROW COACH:
Any other questions?
POLITICAL
COACH:
Well, about the Black Panthers-do you
really think that the American
i
72 OUR GANG
people will believe that the Black Panthers are
behind the Boy Scouts? That really does require
quite a bit of imagination.
TRICKY:
Now I take exception there. I don't want to
influence the voting, but I do want to say this: let's
not underestimate the imagination of the American
people. This may seem like old-fashioned
patriotism such as isn't in fashion any more, but I
have the highest regard for their imagination and I
always have. Why, I actually think the American
people can be made to believe anything. These
people, after all, have their fantasies and fears and
superstitions, just like anybody else, and you are
not going to put anything over on them by simply
addressing yourself to the real problems and
pretending that the others don't exist just because
they are imaginary.
HIGHBROW COACH:
I agree wholeheartedly, Mr.
President. May we proceed to the voting?
TRICKY:
By all means ... Of course, gentlemen, these
are
going to be free elections. I want it to be perfectly
clear beforehand that I wouldn't have it otherwise,
unless there were some reason to believe that the
vote might go the wrong way. And I am proud to
say I don't think that's possible here in this locker
room with men of your caliber. You may vote for
any two candidates on the list, and you may, in the
interest of justice, add any two names of your own
choosing. I will write down the votes cast for
TRICKY HAS ANOTHER CRISIS
73
each candidate and tabulate them on this sheet of
paper.
Now you'll see that this is an ordinary sheet of
lined yellow paper such as you might find on any
legal pad. I was a lawyer, you know, before I became
President, so you can be pretty sure that I know the
correct manner in which to use this kind of paper.
In fact, I should like you now to examine the paper
to be sure nothing has been written on it and that it
contains no code markings or secret notations other
than the usual watermark.
HIGHBROW COACH:
I'm sure we all can trust
your description of the piece of paper, Mr.
President.
TRICKY:
I appreciate your confidence, Professor, but
I would still prefer that the four of you examine the
paper thoroughly beforehand, so that afterwards
there cannot be any doubt as to the one hundred
percent honesty of this electoral procedure. (He
hands the paper
around
to each) Good! Now for a
free election! Suppose we begin with you, Reverend.
SPIRITUAL COACH:
Well, really, I'm in a tizzy. I
mean, I know for sure that I want to vote for Jane
Fonda-but after her I just can't make up my mind.
Curt Flood is so tempting.
HIGHBROW COACH:
Vote for both then.
TRICKY:
Or suppose you think it through a little
longer and we'll come back to you. General?
74
MILITARY COACH
(belligerently): Hanoi and
Haiphong!
TRICKY:
In other words, that's your write-in vote,
Haiphong.
MILITARY COACH:
Mine, and every loyal American's,
Mr. President!
TRICKY:
Fair enough. (Records vote) Next.
POLITICAL COACH:
I'll take Hanoi, too.
TRICKY:
With or without Haiphong?
POLITICAL COACH:
I think I like it just by
itself.
TRICKY:
And, anything else?
POLITICAL COACH:
No, thank you, Mr. President-I
stick.
TRICKY:
Okay, time to hear the voice of Justice.
LEGAL COACH:
The Berrigans, the Panthers, Curt
Flood.
TRICKY:
Slowly, please, slowly. I want to be sure to
get it right. The Berrigans . . . The Panthers .. . Curt
Flood ... But that's three. You're allowed only two.
LEGAL COACH:
I understand that, Mr. President.
But in that my predecessors have each used only
one from the Professor's list of five, it did not seem
to me a violation of the spirit of the law, if I took
up some of the slack. I am a great believer, as I
think you are, sir, in the spirit of the law, if not the
letter.
TRICKY:
Well, okay, if that's the reason: Do you want
now to add any names of your own?
TRICKY HAS ANOTHER CRISIS
75
LEGAL COACH:
As a matter of fact, Mr. President, I
do.
TRICKY:
One or two?
LEGAL COACH:
As a matter of fact, Mr. President,
five.
TRICKY:Five? But you were the one who made
up
the rule about only two.
LEGAL COACH:
And I stand by it, Mr. President
or would, under the circumstances such as existed at
the time I suggested it. But I am dealing at this
moment with what I can only call "a clear and
present danger." I am afraid, Mr. President, that if I
were to submit only two of these
five
names that I
have just this minute come up with, this
administration would be in the most serious clear
and present danger you can imagine of appearing to
be out of its mind. If, on the other hand, the five
names are submitted together, thus suggesting some
kind of plot,
a
charge that might otherwise have
appeared, at best, to be an opportunistic and vicious
attack on two individuals we don't happen to like,
will take on an air of the plausible in the mind of the
nation, such as it is.
Surely, Mr. President, you will permit me at least
to read the names of the five. This is, after all, a free
country where even the man in the street can say
what's on his mind, provided it isn't so provocative
that it might lead somebody in another state, who
doesn't even hear it, to riot. It would be a sad irony
indeed, if the man who is this nation's bulwark
against those very riots that such freedom of speech
tends to
in
spire, was to be denied his rights under
the First Amendment.
TRICKY:
It would, it would. And you can rest assured
that so long as I am President that particular sad
irony-if I understand it correctly-is not going to
happen.
LEGAL COACH:
Thank you, Mr. President. Now
try not to think of the five individually, but rather as
a kind of secret gang, protected, as much as
anything, by the seeming disparateness of individual
personality and profession.
I:
the folk singer, Joan
Baez: the Mayor of New York, John Lancelot. 3: the
dead rock musician, Jimi Hendrix. 4: the TV star,
Johnny Carson ...
ALL:
Johnny Carson?
LEGAL COACH
(smiling) : Who better to be acquitted?
It's always best, you see, to have one acquitted,
especially if he appears to have been unjustly
accused in the first place. It provides the jury with a
means of funneling all their uncertainty in one
direction, makes them feel they've been fair about
the whole thing. Makes the convictions themselves
look better all around. And, of course, freeing
Johnny Carson, you'll be freeing the most popular
man in America (besides yourself, Mr. President).
Why,' we can even, midway through the trial, have
the Pres
TRICKY HAS ANOTHER CRISIS
77
ident step in and make a statement in Carson's
behalf. Exactly as he did about Manson, only the
other way around this time. Imagine, the whole
country crying "Free Johnny!" and the President
going on TV and casting serious doubt on the
charges raised against this great entertainer.
TRICKY:
And then when he's free, I could have a press
conference! Wouldn't that be something? I could
say, "H-e-e-e-re's Johnny," and he could come out
from behind the curtain and do his cute little golf
stroke! He could make jokes about being in jail
with the other conspirators. Maybe he could even
wear a ball and chain and a striped suit!
POLITICAL COACH:
Fantastic! And we could do
it on prime time the night before the election.
While Musty is boring their pants off about how
honest the pine trees are in Maine, we'll be on TV
with Johnny Carson!
LEGAL COACH:
And that's not all, gentlemen.
You have not yet heard the name of the fifth
conspirator.
POLITICAL COACH:
Merv Griffin!
LEGAL COACH:
No, not Merv Griffin . . . Jacqueline
Charisma Colossus.
(Stunned silence)
Daring, yes. Absurd? I think not. Consider first,
gentlemen, that like the other four conspirators, her
Christian name too begins with a "J". Now you
cannot imagine the mileage we can get
78
OUR GANG
out of a seemingly nonsensical fact like that.
Overnight the newspapers and the TV commentators
are going to begin calling them "The Five
J's," thereby linking them together in the public
mind as though they were the Dionne quintuplets,
or the New York Knicks. Just by that ruse alone,
we will have moved halfway toward a conviction.
Inevitably there will be speculation we'll see to thatabout
the relationship between Mrs. Colossus and
Mayor Lancelot. Isn't it about time that we turned
those looks of his to our advantage instead of his?