What Hath God Wrought (148 page)
Read What Hath God Wrought Online
Authors: Daniel Walker Howe
Tags: #History, #United States, #19th Century, #Americas (North; Central; South; West Indies), #Modern, #General, #Religion
61. Dickens’s term: Charles Dickens,
American Notes
(1842; Boston, 1867), 211.
American Notes
(1842; Boston, 1867), 211.
62. Tocqueville to Abbé Lesueur, May 28, 1831, quoted in George Pierson,
Tocqueville and Beaumont in America
(New York, 1938), 90.
Tocqueville and Beaumont in America
(New York, 1938), 90.
63. Harriet Martineau,
Retrospect of Western Travel
, ed. Daniel Feller (London, 2000), 24; Trollope,
Domestic Manners
, 16, 18, 58, 421–23.
Retrospect of Western Travel
, ed. Daniel Feller (London, 2000), 24; Trollope,
Domestic Manners
, 16, 18, 58, 421–23.
64. Marcus Cunliffe, “Frances Trollope,” in
Abroad in America
, ed. Marc Pachter (Reading, Mass., 1976), 40.
Abroad in America
, ed. Marc Pachter (Reading, Mass., 1976), 40.
65. Trollope,
Domestic Manners
, 108, 81.
Domestic Manners
, 108, 81.
66.
Fanny Kemble’s Journals
, ed. Catherine Clinton (Cambridge, Mass., 2000), quotation from 111.
Fanny Kemble’s Journals
, ed. Catherine Clinton (Cambridge, Mass., 2000), quotation from 111.
67. Somkin,
Unquiet Eagle
, 170–72.
Unquiet Eagle
, 170–72.
68.
The Papers of Joseph Smith
, ed. Dean Jessee (Salt Lake City, 1989), I, 7. This record dates from 1832; the vision allegedly occurred in 1820, when Joseph was fifteen years old.
The Papers of Joseph Smith
, ed. Dean Jessee (Salt Lake City, 1989), I, 7. This record dates from 1832; the vision allegedly occurred in 1820, when Joseph was fifteen years old.
69. See Grant Underwood,
The Millenarian World of Early Mormonism
(Urbana, Ill., 1993).
The Millenarian World of Early Mormonism
(Urbana, Ill., 1993).
70. See John Brooke,
The Refiner’s Fire: The Making of Mormon Cosmology
(Cambridge, Eng., 1994), esp. 152–53.
The Refiner’s Fire: The Making of Mormon Cosmology
(Cambridge, Eng., 1994), esp. 152–53.
71.
Niles’ Register
33 (Dec. 1, 1827): 218.
Niles’ Register
33 (Dec. 1, 1827): 218.
72. For Mormon accounts of this, see Richard Bushman,
Joseph Smith and the Beginnings of Mormonism
(Urbana, Ill., 1984), 43–114; Tyrrel Givens,
By the Hand of Mormon
(New York, 2002), 19–42. Urim and Thummim are mentioned in the Bible, e.g., Exodus 28:30.
Joseph Smith and the Beginnings of Mormonism
(Urbana, Ill., 1984), 43–114; Tyrrel Givens,
By the Hand of Mormon
(New York, 2002), 19–42. Urim and Thummim are mentioned in the Bible, e.g., Exodus 28:30.
73. The leading Mormon historian Richard Bushman, if I understand him correctly, credits the prophet’s literary skills as well as his divine inspiration; see his
Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling
(New York, 2005), 71–74, 291–92.
Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling
(New York, 2005), 71–74, 291–92.
74. Alexander Campbell,
Delusions: An Analysis of the Book of Mormon
(Boston, 1832), with a preface by Joshua Himes, William Miller’s future promoter. Another influential early critique was Eber D. Howe,
Mormonism Unvailed
[
sic
] (Painesville, Ohio, 1834).
Delusions: An Analysis of the Book of Mormon
(Boston, 1832), with a preface by Joshua Himes, William Miller’s future promoter. Another influential early critique was Eber D. Howe,
Mormonism Unvailed
[
sic
] (Painesville, Ohio, 1834).
75. Bushman,
Joseph Smith and the Beginnings of Mormonism
, 184; see also Brooke,
Refiner’s Fire
, and Michael Quinn,
Early Mormonism and the Magic World View
(Salt Lake City, 1987).
Joseph Smith and the Beginnings of Mormonism
, 184; see also Brooke,
Refiner’s Fire
, and Michael Quinn,
Early Mormonism and the Magic World View
(Salt Lake City, 1987).
76. See Marvin Hill, “The Rise of Mormonism in the Burned-Over District,”
New York History
61 (1980): 411–30, esp. 426–27.
New York History
61 (1980): 411–30, esp. 426–27.
77. St. John Stott, “New Jerusalem Abandoned: The Failure to Carry Mormonism to the Delaware,”
Journal of American Studies
21 (1987): 71–85.
Journal of American Studies
21 (1987): 71–85.
78. “The Book of Mormon is a record of the forefathers of our western Tribes of Indians,” he declared in a letter to N. C. Saxton, Jan. 4, 1833. Dean Jessee, ed.,
Personal Writings of Joseph Smith
, rev. ed. (Salt Lake City, 2002), 297.
Personal Writings of Joseph Smith
, rev. ed. (Salt Lake City, 2002), 297.
79. A Methodist Pequot espoused the theory in his 1829 autobiography rpt. as William Apess,
On Our Own Ground
, ed. Barry Connell (Amherst, Mass., 1992), 53, 74–94. Joseph Smith may have been familiar with
Views of the Hebrews; or, The Ten Tribes of Israel in America
(Poultney, Vt., 1823), by Ethan Smith (no relation).
On Our Own Ground
, ed. Barry Connell (Amherst, Mass., 1992), 53, 74–94. Joseph Smith may have been familiar with
Views of the Hebrews; or, The Ten Tribes of Israel in America
(Poultney, Vt., 1823), by Ethan Smith (no relation).
80. 2 Nephi 30:6, to employ the Mormon method of citing their scriptures. In 1981, the LDS Church declared that the phrase “white and delightsome” should read “pure and delightsome,” and subsequent editions of the Book of Mormon show it thus.
81.
Doctrine and Covenants
, sect. 89, verses 18–21. Cf. Proverbs 3:8.
Doctrine and Covenants
, sect. 89, verses 18–21. Cf. Proverbs 3:8.
82. Quoted in Stephen LeSueur,
The 1838 Mormon War in Missouri
(Columbia, Mo., 1987), 152. Several days later Governor Boggs reaffirmed the order, again using the word “exterminate” (ibid., 230).
The 1838 Mormon War in Missouri
(Columbia, Mo., 1987), 152. Several days later Governor Boggs reaffirmed the order, again using the word “exterminate” (ibid., 230).
83. Ibid., 238–39.
84. J. P. Kiersch, “Millennium and Millennialism,”
The Catholic Encyclopedia
(New York, 1907–1914), X, 307–10; R. Kuchner, “Millenarianism,”
The New Catholic Encyclopedia
(Washington, 2003), IX, 633–37.
The Catholic Encyclopedia
(New York, 1907–1914), X, 307–10; R. Kuchner, “Millenarianism,”
The New Catholic Encyclopedia
(Washington, 2003), IX, 633–37.
85. For more on the contrast between Catholicism and Protestantism in nineteenth-century America, see John McGreevy,
Catholicism and American Freedom
(New York, 2003).
Catholicism and American Freedom
(New York, 2003).
86. Bernard McGinn, “Revelation,”
The Literary Guide to the Bible
, ed. Robert Alter and Frank Kermode (Cambridge, Mass., 1987), 523–41; Bloch,
Visionary Republic
(cited in n. 2), esp. 5–10.
The Literary Guide to the Bible
, ed. Robert Alter and Frank Kermode (Cambridge, Mass., 1987), 523–41; Bloch,
Visionary Republic
(cited in n. 2), esp. 5–10.
87. Brooks Holifield, “Oral Debate in American Religion,”
Church History
67 (1998), 499–520; Jay Dolan,
In Search of American Catholicism
(Oxford, 2002), 61.
Church History
67 (1998), 499–520; Jay Dolan,
In Search of American Catholicism
(Oxford, 2002), 61.
88. Lyman Beecher, “A Plea for the West” (1835), rpt. in
The American Whigs
, ed. Daniel Howe (New York, 1973), 144.
The American Whigs
, ed. Daniel Howe (New York, 1973), 144.
89. Benjamin Blied,
Austrian Aid to American Catholics, 1830–1860
(Milwaukee, 1944); Kenneth Silverman,
Lightning Man
(New York, 2003), 139–42; Samuel F. B. Morse,
Imminent Dangers to the Free Institutions of the United States Through Foreign Immigration
(1835; New York, 1969), quotation from 23.
Austrian Aid to American Catholics, 1830–1860
(Milwaukee, 1944); Kenneth Silverman,
Lightning Man
(New York, 2003), 139–42; Samuel F. B. Morse,
Imminent Dangers to the Free Institutions of the United States Through Foreign Immigration
(1835; New York, 1969), quotation from 23.
90. Charles Frothingham,
The Convent’s Doom
, quoted in Jenny Franchot,
Roads to Rome
(Berkeley, 1994), 142.
The Convent’s Doom
, quoted in Jenny Franchot,
Roads to Rome
(Berkeley, 1994), 142.
91. See Nancy Schultz,
Fire and Roses: The Burning of the Charlestown Convent
(New York, 2000); and three articles by Daniel Cohen: “The Respectability of Rebecca Reed,”
JER
16 (1996), 419–62; “Alvah Kelley’s Cow,”
New England Quarterly
74 (2001): 531–79; and “Passing the Torch,”
JER
24 (2004): 527–86.
Fire and Roses: The Burning of the Charlestown Convent
(New York, 2000); and three articles by Daniel Cohen: “The Respectability of Rebecca Reed,”
JER
16 (1996), 419–62; “Alvah Kelley’s Cow,”
New England Quarterly
74 (2001): 531–79; and “Passing the Torch,”
JER
24 (2004): 527–86.
92. Census of 1830,
United States Historical Census Data Browser
http://fisher.lib.virginia.edu/census (viewed May 11, 2007).
United States Historical Census Data Browser
http://fisher.lib.virginia.edu/census (viewed May 11, 2007).
93.
Confessions of Nat Turner…fully and voluntarily made to Thos. C. Gray
(1831; Petersburg, Va., 1881), 6, 10, 11.
Confessions of Nat Turner…fully and voluntarily made to Thos. C. Gray
(1831; Petersburg, Va., 1881), 6, 10, 11.
94. See Herbert Aptheker,
Nat Turner’s Slave Rebellion
(New York, 1966); and Stephen Oates,
The Fires of Jubilee
(New York, 1975).
Nat Turner’s Slave Rebellion
(New York, 1966); and Stephen Oates,
The Fires of Jubilee
(New York, 1975).
95. Quotation from Vincent Harding,
There Is a River
(New York, 1981), 95. Estimates of the total number of white victims range from fifty-five to sixty-three.
There Is a River
(New York, 1981), 95. Estimates of the total number of white victims range from fifty-five to sixty-three.
96. John Hampden Pleasants, quoted in Eric Foner,
Nat Turner
(Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1971), 16.
Nat Turner
(Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1971), 16.
97. Casualties on both sides of this race war can only be estimated. Many of the sources relating to the uprising have disappeared from the archives. See Mary Kemp Davis,
Nat Turner Before the Bar of Judgment
(Baton Rouge, 1999), 55–61.
Nat Turner Before the Bar of Judgment
(Baton Rouge, 1999), 55–61.
98.
Confessions of Nat Turner
, 11.
Confessions of Nat Turner
, 11.
99. Oates,
Fires of Jubilee
, 136–38.
Fires of Jubilee
, 136–38.
100. See Alison Freehling,
Drift Toward Dissolution: The Virginia Slavery Debate of 1831–32
(Baton Rouge, 1982); and W. Freehling,
Secessionists at Bay
, 178–96.
Drift Toward Dissolution: The Virginia Slavery Debate of 1831–32
(Baton Rouge, 1982); and W. Freehling,
Secessionists at Bay
, 178–96.
1. Andrew Jackson, Dec. 24, 1828, quoted in Remini,
Jackson
, II, 154.
Jackson
, II, 154.
2. Donald Cole,
The Presidency of Andrew Jackson
(Lawrence, Kans., 1993), 33.
The Presidency of Andrew Jackson
(Lawrence, Kans., 1993), 33.
3. See Bertram Wyatt-Brown, “Andrew Jackson’s Honor,”
JER
17 (1997): 1–36. Psychological interpretations of Jackson’s irascible temperament are offered in Andrew Burstein,
The Passions of Andrew Jackson
(New York, 2003) and James C. Curtis,
Andrew Jackson and the Search for Vindication
(Boston, 1976).
JER
17 (1997): 1–36. Psychological interpretations of Jackson’s irascible temperament are offered in Andrew Burstein,
The Passions of Andrew Jackson
(New York, 2003) and James C. Curtis,
Andrew Jackson and the Search for Vindication
(Boston, 1976).
4. Curtis,
Andrew Jackson and the Search for Vindication
, 136; Robert Gudmestad,
A Troublesome Commerce
(Baton Rouge, 2003), 147–52.
Andrew Jackson and the Search for Vindication
, 136; Robert Gudmestad,
A Troublesome Commerce
(Baton Rouge, 2003), 147–52.
5. Andrew Jackson to Rachel Jackson, Dec. 29, 1813,
Papers of Andrew Jackson
, ed. Harold Moser et al. (Nashville, Tenn., 1984), II, 516. The boy was named Lyncoya.
Papers of Andrew Jackson
, ed. Harold Moser et al. (Nashville, Tenn., 1984), II, 516. The boy was named Lyncoya.
6. Nashville
Tennessee Gazette
, Sept. 26, 1804, rpt. in
Plantation and Frontier
, ed. Ulrich Phillips (New York, 1910), II, 86–87.
Tennessee Gazette
, Sept. 26, 1804, rpt. in
Plantation and Frontier
, ed. Ulrich Phillips (New York, 1910), II, 86–87.
7. Remini,
Jackson
, I, 408.
Jackson
, I, 408.
8. Related in Peter Cartwright,
Autobiography
, ed. Charles Wallis (1856; New York, 1956), 134.
Autobiography
, ed. Charles Wallis (1856; New York, 1956), 134.
9. Remini,
Jackson
, II, 7, 346.
Jackson
, II, 7, 346.
10. Charles Sellers,
The Market Revolution
(New York, 1991), 174–81, provides a sympathetic statement of how and why Jackson’s life appealed to many rural Americans. But see also Michael O’Brien,
Conjectures of Order: Intellectual Life and the American South, 1810–1860
(Chapel Hill, 2004), II, 836–49.
The Market Revolution
(New York, 1991), 174–81, provides a sympathetic statement of how and why Jackson’s life appealed to many rural Americans. But see also Michael O’Brien,
Conjectures of Order: Intellectual Life and the American South, 1810–1860
(Chapel Hill, 2004), II, 836–49.
11.
Presidential Messages
, II, 438. Italics in the original.
Presidential Messages
, II, 438. Italics in the original.
12. Green’s slogan is quoted and analyzed in Richard R. John,
Spreading the News: The American Postal System from Franklin to Morse
(Cambridge, Mass., 1995), 210–11.
Spreading the News: The American Postal System from Franklin to Morse
(Cambridge, Mass., 1995), 210–11.
13. Kendall to Francis P. Blair, Feb. 14, 1829, quoted ibid., 212.
14. Henry Orne (1829), quoted in Robert Forbes, “Slavery and the Meaning of America” (Ph.D. diss., Yale University, 1994), 522.
15. See Richard John, “Affairs of Office: The Executive Departments, the Election of 1828, and the Making of the Democratic Party,” in
Democracy in America: New Directions in American Political History
, ed. Julian Zelizer et al. (Princeton, 2003), 51–84. Jeffrey Pasley,
Printers, Editors, and Publishers of Political Journals Elected to the U.S. Congress, 1789–1861
, found at http://www.pasleybrothers.com/newspols/images. Editors_in_Congress.pdf (viewed May 2, 2007), shows how often journalists went into electoral politics themselves.
Democracy in America: New Directions in American Political History
, ed. Julian Zelizer et al. (Princeton, 2003), 51–84. Jeffrey Pasley,
Printers, Editors, and Publishers of Political Journals Elected to the U.S. Congress, 1789–1861
, found at http://www.pasleybrothers.com/newspols/images. Editors_in_Congress.pdf (viewed May 2, 2007), shows how often journalists went into electoral politics themselves.
Other books
Up by Five by Erin Nicholas
Fletch Won by Gregory Mcdonald
The Professional by Rhonda Nelson
Welcome to Hell by Colin Martin
A Mother to Embarrass Me by Carol Lynch Williams
Naked Choke (A Stepbrother MMA Romance) by Loren, Celia
Magic Kiss (Hope Falls Book 11) by Melanie Shawn
What Belongs to Her (Harlequin Superromance) by Rachel Brimble
War Of The Wildlands by Lana Axe
Death Under the Venice Moon by Maria Grazia Swan