Read The Collected Stories Online
Authors: Grace Paley
No one knew how to deal with them; they were stubborn and maintained a humorless determination. The authorities took away their shortwave and antennae, their stereo screen TV and their temple videotapes. (People were not incarcerated at that time for such social intransigence. Therefore, neither were they rehabilitated.)
Soon this foolish remnant had nothing left. They had to visit one another or wander from town to town in order to say the most ordinary thing to a friend or relative. They had only their shawls and phylacteries, which were used by women too, for women (by that time) had made their great natural advances and were ministers, seers, rabbis, yogis, priests, etc., in well-known as well as esoteric religions.
In their gossipy communications, they whispered the hidden or omitted fact (which some folks had already noticed): The Child
WAS A
Girl, and since word of mouth is sound made in the echo of God (in the beginning there was the Word and it was without form but wide), ear to mouth and mouth to ear it soon became the people's knowledge, outwitting the computerized devices to which most sensible people had not said a private word for decades anyway.
Then: “O.K.!” said Dr. Heiliger. “It's perfectly true, but I didn't want to make waves in any water as viscous as the seas of mythology. Yes, it is a girl. A virgin born of a virgin.”
Throughout the world, people smiled. By that time, sexism and racism had no public life, though they were still sometimes practiced by adults at home. They were as gladdened by one birth as another. And plans were made to symbolically sew the generations of the daughters one to another by using the holy infant's umbilicus. This was luckily flesh
and
symbol. Therefore beside the cross to which people were accustomed there hung the circle of the navel and the wiggly line of the umbilical cord.
But those particular discontented Jews said again, “Wonderful! So? Another tendency heard from! So it's a girl! Praise to the most Highess! But the fact is, we need another virgin birth like our blessed dead want cupping by ancient holistic practitioners.”
And so they continued as female and male, descending and undescending, workers in the muddy basement of history, to which, this very day, the poor return when requiring a cheap but stunning garment for a wedding, birth, or funeral.
The young fathers are waiting outside the school. What curly heads! Such graceful brown mustaches. They're sitting on their haunches eating pizza and exchanging information. They're waiting for the 3 p.m. bell. It's springtime, the season of first looking out the window. I have a window box of greenhouse marigolds. The young fathers can be seen through the ferny leaves.
The bell rings. The children fall out of school, tumbling through the open door. One of the fathers sees his child. A small girl. Is she Chinese? A little. Up u-u-p, he says, and hoists her to his shoulders. U-u-p, says the second father, and hoists his little boy. The little boy sits on top of his father's head for a couple of seconds before sliding to his shoulders. Very funny, says the father.
They start off down the street, right under and past my window. The two children are still laughing. They try to whisper a secret. The fathers haven't finished their conversation. The frailer father is uncomfortable; his little girl wiggles too much.
Stop it this minute, he says.
Oink oink, says the little girl.
What'd you say?
Oink oink, she says.
The young father says What! three times. Then he seizes the child, raises her high above his head, and sets her hard on her feet.
What'd I do so bad, she says, rubbing her ankle.
Just hold my hand, screams the frail and angry father.
I lean far out the window. Stop! Stop! I cry.
The young father turns, shading his eyes, but sees. What? he says. His friend says, Hey? Who's that? He probably thinks I'm a family friend, a teacher maybe.
Who're you? he says.
I move the pots of marigold aside. Then I'm able to lean on my elbow way out into unshadowed visibility. Once, not too long ago, the tenements were speckled with women like me in every third window up to the fifth story, calling the children from play to receive orders and instruction. This memory enables me to say strictly, Young man, I am an older person who feels free because of that to ask questions and give advice.
Oh? he says, laughs with a little embarrassment, says to his friend, Shoot if you will that old gray head. But he's joking, I know, because he has established himself, legs apart, hands behind his back, his neck arched to see and hear me out.
How old are you? I call. About thirty or so?
Thirty-three.
First I want to say you're about a generation ahead of your father in your attitude and behavior toward your child.
Really? Well? Anything else, ma'am.
Son, I said, leaning another two, three dangerous inches toward him. Son, I must tell you that madmen intend to destroy this beautifully made planet. That the murder of our children by these men has got to become a terror and a sorrow to you, and starting now, it had better interfere with any daily pleasure.
Speech speech, he called.
I waited a minute, but he continued to look up. So, I said, I can tell by your general appearance and loping walk that you agree with me.
I do, he said, winking at his friend; but turning a serious face to mine, he said again, Yes, yes, I do.
Well then, why did you become so angry at that little girl whose future is like a film which suddenly cuts to white. Why did you nearly slam this little doomed person to the ground in your uncontrollable anger.
Let's not go too far, said the young father. She
was
jumping around on my poor back and hollering oink oink.
When were you angriestâwhen she wiggled and jumped or when she said oink?
He scratched his wonderful head of dark well-cut hair. I guess when she said oink.
Have you ever said oink oink? Think carefully. Years ago, perhaps?
No. Well maybe. Maybe.
Whom did you refer to in this way?
He laughed. He called to his friend, Hey Ken, this old person's got something. The cops. In a demonstration. Oink oink, he said, remembering, laughing.
The little girl smiled and said, Oink oink.
Shut up, he said.
What do you deduce from this?
That I was angry at Rosie because she was dealing with me as though I was a figure of authority, and it's not my thing, never has been, never will be.
I could see his happiness, his nice grin, as he remembered this.
So, I continued, since those children are such lovely examples of what may well be the last generation of humankind, why don't you start all over again, right from the school door, as though none of this had ever happened.
Thank you, said the young father. Thank you. It would be nice to be a horse, he said, grabbing little Rosie's hand. Come on Rosie, let's go. I don't have all day.
U-up, says the first father. U-up, says the second.
Giddap, shout the children, and the fathers yell neigh neigh, as horses do. The children kick their fathers' horsechests, screaming giddap giddap, and they gallop wildly westward.
I lean way out to cry once more, Be careful! Stop! But they've gone too far. Oh, anyone would love to be a fierce fast horse carrying a beloved beautiful rider, but they are galloping toward one of the most dangerous street corners in the world. And they may live beyond that trisection across other dangerous avenues.
So I must shut the window after patting the April-cooled marigolds with their rusty smell of summer. Then I sit in the nice light and wonder how to make sure that they gallop safely home through the airy scary dreams of scientists and the bulky dreams of automakers. I wish I could see just how they sit down at their kitchen tables for a healthy snack (orange juice or milk and cookies) before going out into the new spring afternoon to play.
My grandmother sat in her chair. She said, When I lie down at night I can't rest, my bones push each other. When I wake up in the morning I say to myself, What? Did I sleep? My God, I'm still here. I'll be in this world forever.
My aunt was making the bed. Look, your grandmother, she doesn't sweat. Nothing has to be washedâher stockings, her underwear, the sheets. From this you wouldn't believe what a life she had. It wasn't life. It was torture.
Doesn't she love us? I asked.
Love you? my aunt said. What else is worth it? You children. Your cousin in Connecticut.
So. Doesn't that make her happy?
My aunt said, Ach, what she saw!
What? I asked. What did she see?
Someday I'll tell you. One thing I'll tell you right now. Don't carry the main flag. When you're bigger, you'll be in a demonstration or a strike or something. It doesn't have to be you, let someone else.
Because Russya carried the flag, that's why? I asked.
Because he was a wonderful boy, only seventeen. All by herself, your grandmother picked him up from the streetâhe was deadâshe took him home in the wagon.
What else? I asked.
My father walked into the room. He said, At least
she
lived.
Didn't you live too? I asked my aunt.
Then my grandmother took her hand. Sonia. One reason I don't close my eyes at night is I think about you. You know it. What will be? You have no life.
Grandmother, I asked, what about us?
My aunt sighed. Little girl. Darling, let's take a nice walk.
At the supper table nobody spoke. So I asked her once more: Sonia, tell me no or yes. Do you have a life?
Ha! she said. If you really want to know, read Dostoevsky. Then they all laughed and laughed.
My mother brought tea and preserves.
My grandmother said to all our faces, Why do you laugh?
But my aunt said, Laugh!