“That may be so,” Lewis said. “All the same, I'm like Cholly. I ain't no fahmer.”
“You ain't tried it, though.”
All at once Lewis grinned like one of those jack-o-lanterns the boys had carved, for just that instant Ed Thomas looked exactly like the man that had sold him that Chevy. “I ain't tried cyanide either, yet,” he said.
The Welshman laughed. He seemed persuaded at last that Lewis meant it. He turned away in the direction of the stairs. “Well, think about it though. You could just about name your terms, I can tell you.” He took two steps down, his left hand spread over the top of the newel post. The bedroom and bathroom doors rumbled, catching a sudden draftâthe storm outside was getting fiercer by the minuteâand abruptly, as if the rumble of the doors had told him something, Ed Thomas stopped and looked up and said, “Truth of the matter is, I could use you, Lewis. I got to get off that fahm or I'm a dead man.” His face was serious, redder than usual. He pointed at his chest with the cellophane-wrapped cigar. “It's my ticker,” he said. “Doc Phelps'll tell ye.” He smiled as if absentmindedly and shook his head. “I work half an hour and by tunkit I got to go in and lie down again. Chores every mornin and nightâwrastlin bales, cleanin out guttersâI can't do it anymore, that's the long and the short of it. Doctor asked me, âYou feel pain in your chest, Ed?' âNo sir,' I says, âjust a little discomfit.' âWell now,' he says âhow
much
discomfit?' âWell, I wouldn't call it pain,' I says. Well, Doc Phelps looks at me and says, âPeople have different ideas about what's pain, Ed.' I says to him, âWhat
I
call pain is when you jump right out of your chair.' âI'd call what you've got pain, then,' says he. âBut I'll tell you this,' he says, âonce winter comes, you might's well just throw that chair away.' By golly it was the truth, too. Here it's only October and the damn thing won't let me sit down. If I work that dairy I'm a dead man sure as I'm standin here.” He grinned as if, more than anything else, it was an embarrassment.
Lewis bit his lips together, his cheeks and eyelids tense. “What about your hired men, Ed?”
He shook his head. “Worthless. You know the kind of help a man gets.”
Neither of them was looking at the other now. “Maybe you could sell it,” Lewis said.
The old man looked down the stairwell. “Ay-uh, I could do that.” He began to nod his head slowly, and Lewis sucked in his upper lip and hurriedly looked away. After a moment he touched the old man's forearm. “Ed, we'll talk about it,” he said.
Ed Thomas flicked his eyes up, met those strange blue and brown eyes, looked down again, and nodded. He waved the cigar, then grinned mechanically, leaning on the railing, and started down the stairs.
12
“Nothing's perfect,” Ruth Thomas was declaiming in the kitchen. On the kitchen table there were two big, saw-toothed jack-o-lanterns, slanted eyes grotesquely staring, black inside. She pointed a long finger ferociously at Dickey, who grinned and shrank back toward his friend Roger and giggled. “You ever hear the poem about the 'possom?” she demanded. Her face was merry, the eye-bags dark. Both boys shook their heads, though Roger, her grandson, had heard it a thousand times.
“Oh yes, Ruth,” Estelle cried, eyes twinkling, “do that one!” Ruth drew herself up to her full height, DeWitt grinning with embarrassment behind her, and in something faintly suggestive of the style of a nineteenth-century orator, she recited for the assembled companyâ
The Opossum
One day, having nothing much to do, God
Created the Opossum. It was a kind of experiment:
How stupid, ugly, and downright odd
A creature (he wondered) could he possibly invent?
When the 'Possum was created, God shook his head
And grinned. “That's not very good,” he said.
But for no real reason he loved the fool thing
And kept the thing functioning age after age.
The dinosaurs died out, or began to sing,
Transformed into birds; apes became the rage;
But the 'Possum trudged onâwith some other antiques:
Spiders, sand-crabs, various old freaks.
“Father,” said the Son, “that Opossum's a killer
â
Murders baby chicks for no reason. He's got to go!
Times have changed, and changed for the better.
He's an anachronism, if I may say so.”
God sighed. “Peace and Justice are right,” he said,
And whispered to the 'Possum, “Lie down. Play dead.”
The company all laughed, as they always did when Ruth Thomas recited poetry. And as always, they wouldn't let her off with just one. She was an artist of a sort almost vanished from the earthâthe “country reciter,” as William Lyon Phelps, Estelle Parks' teacher, had called it in his book. “The verse equivalent of the folk-singer.” They got their poems from everywhere, these country recitersâfrom calendars, feed-store account books and almanacs, small-town newspapers, verse-writing aunts, occasionally old school-books or the
Saturday Evening Post.
No doubt now and then a reciter wrote some of his verses himself, but there was, in the heyday of the country reciter, no great honor in that, and he tended to make not too much of it. Certain poems were, for all reciters, classic, of course, written by known poets like Eugene Field and Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, names “now universally scorned by the literate,” as Professor Phelps said, “though one might hesitate to scorn them after hearing them presented by a reciter.”
Ruth Thomas, at least in Estelle's opinion, was as good a reciter as any to be found in these degenerate days, though not pure in technique. The faces she madeâbugged eyes, pursed lipsâand her tendency to insist on the different voices when a poem used dialogueâall these showed she'd been just a touch corrupted by dramatic monologue and the Broadway stage. Be that as it may, she was the best you could hope for, and the effect on the company was not much worse than in former times, “the true and proper effect of all art,” Professor Phelps had written, “when it is taken for granted, when no fine distinctions between bad and good are thought necessary, so that the more-or-less good has a way of prevailing, unthreatened by the overreaching snatch at âthe Great' which creates failed masterworks and devalues the merely excellent, leaving all the world rubble and a babble of mixed-up languages.” It was a passage Estelle had often quoted to students and had even used once at a School Board meeting, in defense of she forgot just what. Even now, after all these years, it was impossible for Estelle to hear Ruth recite without thinking of William Lyon Phelps. She was glad of that, perhaps even forced the recollection a little. It heightened her pleasure in listening.
“Say another one,” Virginia said. “Say the one about the cat and dog.”
“That's a good one,” Ruth's grandson DeWitt said, then blushed.
“The Cat and the Dog,” Ruth Thomas began.
Lane Walker poked his Mexican friend in the arm. “Listen to this,” he said.
“Listen closely to this one,” Dr. Phelps broke in, the same moment, “this is a toughie!”
She drew herself up, then broke character to say: “I recited this once at the McCullough Mansion. John McCullough had heard me reciting somewhereâI forget where it wasâand invited me to do a kind of poetry concert.” She smiled, devilish. “He told me afterward, âThat's the kind of poem I can only follow with a pencil.'”
They all laughed. Dr. Phelps' granddaughter smiled at Estelle's grand-nephew, who stood beside her, and both of them blushed.
(Ah ha!
thought Estelle.)
Again Ruth drew herself up and took a breath, like an anthem singer.
The Cat and the Dog
Though he purrs, the Cat's only partly here,
Poised 'tween the hearth and the street outside.
Half-tame, half-wild, he's a walking riddle,
Playing both ends against the middle.
And so Man hangs between Truths he must fear
And the murderous animal under his hide.
The Dog's by nature the best of his friends,
Playing the middle against both ends.
There was a silence when she finished. Then Ed Thomas said, half-joking, face red: “It's true. I need a pencil!”
“Mrs. Thomas,” little Margie Phelps said almost inaudibly, “do the one about the bear.”
“The bear!” everyone shouted happily. “The bear! The bear!”
For no reason, tears began to stream down Ruth Thomas's cheeks but she said, “The Bear,” and drew herself up, more grand than ever.
Estelle whispered, watching her old friend's face in alarm, “Listen to this one, Lewis. This is wonderful.”
Ruth Thomas declaimed:
The Bear
If someone offers you a Bear, bow low,
And say “No!”
It was suddenly late. They'd all been aware of it before, which was why they were standing in the kitchen with their coats on, but now they all became conscious at once that the time had come. Virginia Hicks realized that she was frightened. Her father was still not home! But there was nothing she could do, or nothing but light one more cigaretteâher throat and lungs on fireâand throw a glance at Lewis, who could give her no help, though she knew he felt it too. If her father had been hurt, the police would call, or the hospitalâif they found him, that is. She imagined accidents that would make no sound, rouse no neighborâthe truck slipping softly off the road into the creek, or quietly tipping over on an embankment, vanishing from sight.
“Well, I've had a wonderful time,” Dr. Phelps sang heartily, “and so has my Margie, if I mistake not.” He winked at her and she blushed. “Come come, my birdy,” he said, reaching toward her from across the room. With his red face, his long green scarf wrapped around and around and trailing past his shoulder, he looked like a greetingcard caricature of Christmas. Whispering somethingâperhaps just “Goodnight”âMargie detached herself from Terence.
“Well, boys?” Ed Thomas said, turning to his grandsons. They shifted slightly to show that they were ready. He turned back to Ruth and slipped his arm around her, preparing to help her walk. “Lewis, my boy,” he called out as if casually, “let's don't forget, eh?”
“Yessir,” Lewis said, helping Estelle to her feet from the chair by the table.
“Don't call us, we'll call you,” Ed Thomas sang out, and laughed.
When Dr. Phelps opened the door it pushed him back a step and wind came bounding into the room like a horse. “Great Christ!” he exclaimed. Whether it was the wind or something darker, a chill went through them, as if the old doctor's cry had in fact been a prayer.
“Wintah's just around the cohner,” Lewis Hicks said. No one else spoke.
“Get outta here, you guys!” Ruth Thomas said, addressing the wind, “you think it's Halloween
already?”
No one laughed. She stood tall as a Druid, her head thrown back.
With the door still blown open, the kitchen nearly hushed, there came from somewhere below them on the mountain, surely not more than a half mile away, a sound like the explosion of a bomb.
“What was that?” Estelle whispered.
Virginia put her hand on Dickey's shoulder, her eyes very still.
“Sounds like he didn't make the cohner,” Lewis mentioned to the night.
The minister and priest were out the door now, running toward their car.
Sally Abbott, in her room, did not hear the explosion, or if she heard, did not register. She knew only that the house had become quiet, there were just a few people in the kitchen, talking. She couldn't make out what they were saying or even who was there. She listened at the door and then, when she heard cars starting up, went over to look out the window. “They're certainly in a hurry to get away,” she said aloud. She went back to the bedroom door to listen, but the voices were quieter than ever now. She went to the edge of the bed and sat down, trembling, feeling strangely alarmedâit was the howling wind, perhapsâand looked at the clock. Past midnight!
She should try to sleep, she knew; but it was out of the question. She glanced at the paperback book and, after a moment's thought, picked it up and found her place. Staring at the page, she saw, as clearly as she had at the time, the ghostly intruder by the mailbox. She leaned back, pulling her feet up into bed with her, and reached clumsily behind her for the pillow. When it was adjusted, no easy matter, she rested her head against it and, with the book still open to her page, closed her eyes. Again she saw the ghost, but mixed with that image, overwhelming it, was the sound of Lane Walker's voice, her sense of the hallway filled with people, above all her embarrassment at having seemed a racist to the Mexican. She opened her eyes and the room was abruptly linear and solid, everything in place. She glanced at the book. Without quite meaning to, she began, once again, to read.
11
ART AND FREEDOM
Eighteen miles off the Mexican coast, Lost Souls' Rock rose sharply from the Pacific like a black, partly fallen natural castle or dark-towered factory from an abandoned civilization. A nautical mile out, a single greenish spire like a stalagmite rose from the sea, a welcoming emblem, a Statue of Liberty without features or torch. It was an island strangely hairy, yet bare in patches, like an animal with mange. Its vegetation was all drab brown or gray, fruitless and namelessâhere and there an unsightly, twisted cactus, elsewhere low thickets of wiry brush hiding dangerous crevasses, reptile bones, old beer cans.
“An unsightly place,” Santisillia observed, “but a good place for thinking. Nothing to lay demands on you, providing you're well provisioned. Nothing to confuse you in the way Spinoza mentioned.”
“Spinoza?” Jane said politely, looking over her glasses.
Santisillia moved his hand as if to touch her, then thought better of it. “Spinoza speaks of how a hungry man or an angry man is not free to think clearly. Only the free man is in a position to be wise.”