My Wife's Little Sister (10 page)

Kelsey giggled. "Nope. The party's right here."

I set the vodka on a pile of books on her desk. "Well, have a good time then, ladies." I started to go towards the door.

The blonde giggled. "You didn't tell me he was so shy, Kelsey."

I turned back to the girls. Kelsey spoke up. "Tom, meet my roommate, Caitlin. Caitlin, meet Tom, my special friend."

I walked over to Caitlin and took her hand, shaking it softly. She looked up at me shyly. "Pleased to meet you, Caitlin. Have a nice night," I said.

"Wait!" Kelsey said. She grabbed a trio of shot glasses out from her cupboard. "You have to join us for at least one drink!"

I sighed. "One drink."

She smiled and poured three shots. I grabbed two of them and handed one to Caitlin, who thanked me softly. Kelsey held her shot glass in the air, then made eye contact with me.

"To making your dreams come true," she said, clinking her glass against mine, then Caitlin's.
Was she talking about her dreams, or mine?
I thought back to the conversation that Kelsey and Lynn had had this afternoon. I looked back at Caitlin, who was still looking at me shyly, before clinking glasses with her and downing the vodka. It had been a while since I had a shot, but luckily I liked this stuff.

As soon as I was done taking the shot, I put the shot glass down. "It's been fun, ladies, a real throwback to my own college days. I'm going to go now," I said. I grabbed my backpack and walked towards the door.

Caitlin, apparently losing some of her shyness, jumped up and grabbed my hand. "But you just got here! I can make a pretty good Fresca and vodka if you'll stay a little longer."

My heart started to beat out of my chest. No way this was happening. I looked over at Kelsey. It might have been my imagination, but I could almost see her nod slowly. I looked back at Caitlin, and she bit her lip, as if she hoped I would stay. Her yoga pants were riding low on her hips, and I could see her little belly underneath her tank top.

My dick began to take over all my actions. I smiled, keeping my cool. "A drink with two ingredients? Well, I guess you can't mess that up." She opened a soda can, took a drink out of it, then poured some vodka in it.
Yep, she was a real bartender with those skills
, I thought as she handed it to me.

Kelsey seemed to relax and poured herself another drink. I sat on her bed, and within moments each girl was sitting on a different side of me. By now, I had so little blood left in my brain that I didn't stand a chance.

"Well, what do you think?" Kelsey asked.

"About what?" I asked.

"About Caitlin. Do you think she's cute?"

I looked over at Caitlin. She was blushing and looking shy again, and she looked absolutely gorgeous. "Yes, she's cute," I agreed. Caitlin smiled and looked down.

Kelsey continued. "All the boys at the parties we go to think she's cute. They love it when the two of us put on a show for them. Of course, we never let those boys join in," she said, trailing off. There was an unsaid
Until now...

Kelsey's hand went to my pants. My cock was already rock hard and she knew it. "I bet you'd like to see us put on a show for you," she said.

I was beyond words at this point, so I just nodded. Caitlin took another drink of her vodka, then leaned in over me. Kelsey leaned in over the other side of me, and the two began to kiss in front of me. Their tits were so close to touching, and all I would have had to do was lift my hands to be cupping a perfect, full breast in each hand.

The two kissed for a few seconds, then broke off, smiling at each other. As if on cue, both looked me in the eye at the same time.

Kelsey jumped off the bed. "I think it's time for another shot," she said. Caitlin leaned back up, still keeping eye contact with me. Her hand went to my back, scratching it gently. My hand touched her gently, feeling her back through her shirt. Now that she was acting less shy, I was definitely getting more and more turned on by her.

Kelsey came back with the three shots, and we each took one. "To all of our dreams coming true," Kelsey said. We all threw back the shot. As I finished, Kelsey came in for a kiss. Her lips tasted of the harsh alcohol, but I drank her in eagerly. She pulled away, and my eyes went to Caitlin. The young girl was biting her lip again, obviously too shy to initiate contact. My cock was in full command of my body at this point, and I leaned in, kissing the young blonde. She kissed back, her hands going to the sides of my face.

Kelsey took off that cute little camisole, exposing her tits immediately. She moved to the other side of where Caitlin was sitting and began lifting at the bottom of her shirt. Caitlin broke from the kiss and lifted her hands in the air, letting Kelsey take the tank top off.

Shyly, she covered her tits for a moment, blushing as she looked at me. Then, she slowly pulled her hands away from her tits. She broke eye contact for a moment to grab her Fresca and vodka. As she brought the can to her mouth, I watched her tits lift and move, her soft skin enticing me. They were about the same size as Kelsey's, maybe a little smaller but every bit as pleasant looking. As she drank, she saw me watching her, but there was no point in hiding it at this point.

When she put the can down, she leaned over and kissed me. Her leg lifted up and she straddled me, and my hands went to her sides, enjoying the feel of her sexy body. Her fingers went to the bottom of my shirt, and I allowed her to take it off. As we broke from our kiss, I looked behind Caitlin to Kelsey. She was running her nails up and down Caitlin's back, looking at me like she wanted it to be her turn.

When my shirt was away from my face, I eagerly moved my mouth to Caitlin's tits. My hands went to her back, bringing her in closer. Her hands rubbed through my hair, and I could hear breath start to quicken as she became more and more turned on. I devoured those pink, puffy nipples as she writhed in my grasp.

Suddenly, a pair of hands wrapped around her. I broke away as the two hands grabbed her tits tightly. Caitlin turned back and kissed Kelsey, still writhing against her crotch against mine. The two kissed deeply, and I could tell that they had done this before.

Kelsey lifted up and Caitlin followed. Within a moment, Kelsey was on her knees, pulling Caitlin's yoga pants down. "Kelsey!" Caitlin cried, looking at me shyly. She made no move to pull her pants back up.

Kelsey looked over at me. "Can you believe that Caitlin's never been with a man before? I keep telling her that she should, but she's been too shy. It's like we're back in high school or something!"

I thought about how Kelsey had almost left high school a virgin, but that I had taken that from her just a few days before graduation. It looked like I'd get to take another girl's virginity tonight, and the thought just made me hornier.

Caitlin had on a white thong under her yoga pants, and as soon as she had stepped out of her pants, Kelsey kissed up towards her panties. Caitlin caught her face just as she was about to kiss her pussy, and brought her up to kiss her. The two girls in front of me embraced, their tits pressed together, their hands all over each others' bodies. It was one of the hottest things I had ever seen.

Kelsey gestured towards me, and Caitlin bit her lip and smiled. Caitlin waited while Kelsey unbuttoned her jean shorts, revealing a pair of black panties.

"Oooh, naughty!" Caitlin said. Kelsey stuck out her ass a little, and Caitlin gave her a little smack.
That was nothing compared to the smacks I was going to give her
, I thought. Within a moment, she pulled down those panties too, leaving her completely naked. I saw that her pussy was bare, freshly waxed or shaved, and I liked it.

She winked at Caitlin, then got down on her knees. Caitlin followed her, and Kelsey unbuttoned my pants. They both tugged on them, pulling them down past my knees. Caitlin worked on getting my shoes off while Kelsey tugged on my underwear, freeing my rock hard cock. As soon as my pants and underwear were completely off, both girls knelt next to each other, eying my rod. Their tits pressed against each other still.

"You first," Kelsey said.

"He's
your
special friend," Caitlin said. The two giggled back and forth, then Caitlin stuck her tongue out, licking my shaft from bottom to top. Kelsey grabbed Caitlin's long, blonde hair and began to stroke it gently, while Caitlin took the head of my cock in her mouth. I leaned back and enjoyed as Caitlin showed me that this certainly wasn't the first time she had given head.

Kelsey leaned in and began to lick the side of my shaft while Caitlin continued to concentrate on the head. I put one hand in each of their hair, guiding them as they pleasured me. Caitlin moved her mouth to the other side of my shaft. The two giggled at each other as they moved on opposite sides of my cock, getting me super wet for what was to come. A drop of precum leaked from the head of my cock and Caitlin licked it up before going back to the side of my shaft. It was the most beautiful sight I had ever seen.

Suddenly, Kelsey broke away from my cock and kissed Caitlin deeply. The two made out next to my dick before Kelsey broke away and winked at her. Caitlin kept sucking on me while Kelsey moved behind her. Her hand reached down under Caitlin, and I could feel her begin to rub at the front of Caitlin's panties. Caitlin eyes closed and she began to writhe as she sucked, her moans sending fantastic shivers of pleasure through my body.

Suddenly, Caitlin's eyes shot back open. Kelsey had started to work her panties off but Caitlin stopped her. She reached back and pulled her panties back up. Kelsey just shrugged, then continued to play with Caitlin's clit through her panties. Caitlin went back to sucking, now beginning to massage her breast with her hand while she sucked.

Suddenly Kelsey got up and walked over to where I was on the bed. Caitlin got up and knelt over me on the bed, letting go of my cock as Kelsey lowered herself down. I gasped as Kelsey's slick pussy slid over my cock, enveloping me in its warm embrace. Kelsey gasped too, and immediately began to writhe on me.

"Oh that's so fucking hot," Caitlin said. She stood next to Kelsey and wrapped her hands around her body, cupping both of Kelsey's tits in her hands. She leaned down and gave Kelsey a kiss, and the two kissed deeply. I ran my fingers up and down Kelsey's tight body before leaning forward and rubbing them up Caitlin's body, grabbing her tits. She seemed to like that, as she moaned into Kelsey's mouth.

I leaned back to drink in the sight, my hands going to Kelsey's hips. She broke from the kiss and bent down at me, her chest rubbing against mine. She locked eyes with me, completely lost in her own lust. I could feel her obsession burning in those eyes, and it turned me on.

I grabbed her hair and yanked her back, and she moaned. I put my other hand on her back and began to rail into her, penetrating her deeply. Kelsey's moans grew even louder, almost certainly traveling through the thin walls of the dorm room just as they had the last time. Caitlin's mouth went agape, though whether it was surprise at how rough I was fucking Kelsey or how the young girl was loving it, I didn't know.

I stood up, and Kelsey continued to bounce on my dick for a moment before putting her feet down. I looked at Caitlin hungrily, anxious to fuck her as well, to deflower her. She looked a little scared, as though she wasn't ready. Kelsey walked over to her, wrapping her arms around her and kissing her softly, tenderly. She smiled and I heard her whisper softly, "That was hot."

Kelsey smiled and grabbed her hand, leading her to sit down on the bed. She gestured me over, and I got down on my knees in front of Caitlin. Caitlin bit her lip as I slowly spread her legs open, kissing up her leg. As I reached her panties, I traced all around them with my tongue, exploring her skin. She laid back, and Kelsey said softly, "That's it. Enjoy it."

I heard Caitlin giggle nervously. I wrapped my fingers around the outside of her panties and started to pull downwards. Suddenly, her hands shot down, grabbing her panties. "I'm not sure," I heard her say.

"You're going to lose your virginity at some point. It might as well be to Tom," she said.

I heard Caitlin say, "But..."

I didn't wait to hear the rest. I put my fingers in the little white panties and pulled them apart. The fabric came off easily in my hands. Caitlin cried out, then moved her hands to stop me. Kelsey silenced her with a kiss, deeply tonguing her mouth. Her hands stopped trying to push me away.

I marveled at her bare pussy, also neatly shaven. A light layer of moisture was on the outside of it, showing how turned on she was already. I got some spit on my finger and rubbed it up and down her labia before moving it down to her opening. She moaned again, the sound turning me on even more, making my cock even more rock hard. I spread her open as much as I could on the outside before getting up and positioning myself between her legs.

Kelsey stopped kissing Caitlin and looked down at where my cock was about to deflower her friend. She held onto Caitlin's hand tightly, and Caitlin looked me in the eye and bit her lip again. As my cock lightly pressed against her pussy, I watched as she closed her eyes.

I was much gentler with her than I had been with Kelsey. I slowly rocked back and forth and I watched her hand grip Kelsey's hand even tighter. When I pressed up against her hymen, I heard her hiss. Kelsey brushed her hair with her other hand and softly said "Shhh."

I pulled all the way out, and then pushed all the way in, tearing through her hymen and continuing all the way in. I heard her moan and felt her pussy tighten on me, and as I went deeper, I expected to feel the prick of an IUD, just like when I fucked my wife. As I buried myself to the hilt, I realized that, like Kelsey, this girl hadn't been sexually active.
Not until she met me
, I thought.

I rocked back and forth, slowly getting her used to the feeling of being fucked. Her moans were shaky, but within moments she seemed to be enjoying herself. I watched as her body bounced with every thrust I made into her petite frame, her tits jiggling around in just the right way. My eyes fixated on the pale skin of her breasts, the way her pink, puffy nipples moved. It was a fantastic sight.