Authors: Iris Murdoch
Reflecting upon it afterwards, Laura's behaviour was in fact tiresome to the point of oddness. She was uneasy, excited, drinking and laughing more than usual, and seemed almost to be anxious to make a fool of me in front of her guests. She certainly went out of her way to present me as a man with a long-established mistress. âOh we know all about your quarrels with Tommy and how long they last!' This was particularly exasperating and cruel as there was nothing which I could say in reply. Laura was in a positively malicious mood which I could not interpret. Perhaps after all she was a bit in love with me? A possessive woman will warn another woman off her territory, however unlikely it is that the other may prove a rival. The process may be almost mechanical. It was in any case impossible that Laura should not see Kitty as a richly endowed competitor for Laura's little world. Was Kitty being informed that, contrary to appearances, I was not a lonely accessible bachelor, and that in so far as I belonged to anybody other than Tommy I belonged to Laura? Or did Laura's weird state of mind conceivably arise out of some knowledge of my former relations with Gunnar? The notion that Kitty might become friendly with Laura came to me suddenly during the
bauf Stroganoff
and made me choke. Supposing Kitty were, at least, to take Laura into her confidence? Why not? The idea of Kitty receiving Laura's picture of me made me feel very ill indeed. Not that Laura, in reality, disliked or despised me; but she would inevitably make me appear absurd.
It was Kitty who (seeing my pain?) rescued the pantomime conversation by making it more general. Gunnar, who had either become pompous through being grand, or was so now out of nervousness, made a speech to Freddie to the effect that of course
Peter Pan
was about parents and being unwilling to grow up, but what made it sinister was that childishness had been invested with spirituality. âThe fragmentation of spirit is the problem of our age,' Gunnar informed Freddie. âPeter personifies a spirituality which is irrevocably caught in childhood and which yet cannot surrender its pretensions. Peter is essentially a being from elsewhere, the apotheosis of an immature spirituality.' Gunnar addressed himself to Freddie, sometimes to Laura. So far as possible he ignored me. I was sitting between Laura and Kitty. I did not know what to do with my eyes or my hands or my feet. My head ached with not looking at Gunnar. Laura, making jokes, more than once laid her hand on my knee. The green silk was inches away.
And now I was sitting on Paddington platform one, watching the departure of the nine-five for Birmingham New Street, and thinking, as it was about time to do, about Gunnar; and as I thought about him I felt my racing mind becoming quiet, as someone who after appeals and hopes contemplates as a reality his irrevocable sentence at last. I could have no dealings here with dreams. In this sterner context my âfeelings' about Kitty were indeed the
merest
feelings and I knew that I could be harsh with them. They existed as something beautiful but totally irrelevant, like a flower one might notice on the way to the gallows. Nor must I even tell myself that my task here was one which Kitty suggested and imposed. This flattery too must be denied me. Life, or truth, something deep and hard which could not be evaded, suggested and imposed this task. And the only hope which existed for me at all was one which I could not pursue, should not perhaps even conceive, and which must be merely a by-product of my striving, the hope, which I had mentioned in such melodramatic terms to Kitty, that I might be able by helping Gunnar to help myself.
Yet could I help Gunnar? How was it to be done? Was the fundamental problem one that concerned him or one that concerned me? The origin of it all was that I had done something. But what had I done? Had I punished myself simply because I had been so terribly punished by fate? I had been extremely unlucky. If Anne had got out of the car on that evening and gone home to her husband ⦠What might now seem in retrospect a small sin had become a monumental sin by what seemed in the strictest sense to be an accident. A death is the most terrible of
facts.
This fact lay between me and Gunnar, poisoning my life with guilt, his with hate. And nothing could take that fact away. Time could not do it. Had time done anything, changed me so that I was a different person? Was I still and forever the person who ⦠? Even a law court lets you off at last.
That I should never forget the fact was something for which I must almost pray. Had I begun to forget it? In the years that had passed I had not forgotten Anne. Her face even now, her moist lips, her radiant eyes, hung before me upon the foggy curtain of the sulphurous air. Oh Anne, oh my darling, I have not forgotten you, my heart at this moment beats for you, my hands tremble and move as if to embrace you. But the fact â have I forgotten that I killed her, have I changed
that
into something huge and dark, wrapping it round as the years went by with my misery and my guilt: the burden which I had told Kitty that I could not name? Was this the thing which, for Gunnar, I must unwrap? The thing which he too had wrapped about, with misery and hate and empty dreams of revenge.
Anne had never really been a part of my life. Gunnar's life had been ripped apart, and I had done it, entering from outside as a cruel ruthless invader. If God had existed and we could have stood together in His presence and looked together without falsity at what had been done, and then looked at each other, might not some miracle have occurred? âThis is what I did.' âI know.' But there was no such scene, only two sodden semi-conscious psyches wrestling with each other in the dark. Could anything ever be clarified, could anything be really
done
here? Had not my feelings, whatever they were, for Kitty simply misled me with a momentary vision of a new heaven and a new earth? I had wrecked my life and Crystal's by a guilt which was itself a kind of sin. Could that be cut away? The idea of forgiveness, pardon, reconciliation, seemed here too fuzzy, too soft for what was needed. If Gunnar and I could be even for a moment simple, sincere, together ⦠But that was the way of hope, and there must be no hope, only a task, only the truth itself if one could but discern it and hang on.
I took the Inner Circle to Westminster and went to the office.
âI
THINK it was perfectly bloody of you,' said Christopher. It was Saturday morning, about nine o'clock. The weather had changed. It was a clear frosty day with the sun shining. I was shaving. I had spent Friday night at the same hotel, returning home only on Saturday so as to be in position for Biscuit. I could not have endured a meeting with Tommy. Or rather, in my present state of mind Tommy simply did not exist, a tornado was blowing through my life which had swept poor Tommy right away. I reckoned that she would not turn up at the office, nor did she. She rang up once, but I put the 'phone down. I returned to an unexpected barrage of moral criticism from Christopher.
âShe stayed here on Thursday evening from nine-thirty until one in the morning, and last night she was here at six and stayed till two. She sat on your bed and cried. I've never seen a woman cry so.'
âTough on you,' I said, scraping away.
âHow can you treat a poor bird like that? And you were in bed with her last week.'
âHow do you know?'
âYou made such a bloody row, the place was rocking.'
âHave you never left anybody? Tears must flow.'
âTears must flow, but you might at least do it honestly, not just fail to turn up when you know she is waiting.'
âI have done it honestly. I've told her a hundred times over that it's no good. I wrote her a long letter about it. Is it my fault if she hangs around and gets in a frenzy?'
âYes, it is your fault. You ought to have seen those tears and not just run away from them. Her tears are a fact. And you caused them.'
Another fact. Only I was not interested. I had no intention of feeling guilt about Tommy. âWe're all sinners. We all hurt each other just by existing.'
âThat's right, blame God or the cosmos or something. You said you'd marry her.'
âShe dreamed it. Losing me is something a girl should be congratulated on.'
âSure losing you is something a girl should be congratulated on. But somehow all that crying, it just bugged me. It suddenly seemed like the rotten way it all is, people homeless or hungry or half mad, or lying on the pavement outside Charing Cross Station â '
âLook, Tommy isn't lying on the pavement outside Charing Cross Station â '
âOK, we're all sinners and we cause it all the time, but we can avoid being bloody cynical and bloody cruel. She expected you, she couldn't
believe
you wouldn't come â '
âMore fool she.'
âShe sat waiting for you like a little child and when you didn't come she thought you'd been run over. Jesus!'
âNo such luck.'
âYou're bloody lucky to be loved by that nice girl, you don't deserve love.'
âYou're telling me.'
âNo one does, I mean. Of course there are muddles but it was so cruel just to let her wait, you knew she was there â '
âI didn't â '
âWell, you didn't bloody think then. The trouble with you is you're a snob, it's all that rat race competition, all you can think of is getting away from your working-class background, you hate yourself so you can't love anyone else â '
âOh shut up, will you.'
âThat poor girl â '
âWell, why didn't you console her yourself? Or do you only like scraggy boys in tight jeans?'
âThat's a lousy thing to say.'
âIf you want to stay in this house you can bloody well hold your tongue. I'm fed up with being lectured by a yapping little drop-out who can't do anything but smoke pot.'
âAt least I haven't given up. I try to be kind. You've just given up. You simply tread on people. You're a destroyer, a murderer â '
I had put the razor down. Christopher, still in pyjamas, was standing in the door of the bathroom, his golden hair in a frizzy globular tangle, his light blue eyes screwed up with passion. I clenched my right fist and grasped Christopher's shoulder with my left hand, digging my fingers violently into the flesh. He remained perfectly still. His face relaxed into a sudden mildness. I let go of him and took the tumbler from the bathroom shelf and hurled it past him into the hall where it broke into fragments. Christopher continued to look at me mildly for a moment; then he turned and began to pick up the pieces of glass and drop them into a waste-paper basket.
I leaned over the basin closing my eyes. I was so frightened. I was frightened in case Biscuit should not come, I was frightened in case she should bring a message which would terminate my quest, I was frightened of myself and of the impossibility of what I wanted to do and of the horrors which awaited me if in the tiniest way I failed or slipped. There was no clarity now, no exhilaration, no hope, only dread. And Christopher's words, presenting facts, accusing me of murder. And my violent desire to hit him, to hurt him, to trample him under foot. And Gunnar breaking the sherry glass. And women's tears.
âSorry, Hilary â I'm sorry â I shouldn't have â I'm sorry.'
âI'm sorry too,' I said. âBetter use a brush to sweep that stuff up, you'll cut yourself.'
I went into the bedroom and put my tie on and looked at myself in the glass. I was glaring like a madman. I lay down on the bed, and I thought about Kitty's green silken thigh inches away at the dinner table. My mind surged and boiled and I lay there rigid and clenched my fists with the force of blind inner violence. Time passed. The bell rang.
I was with Biscuit in the park. When she arrived I came out to her at once. I said, âWait till we're in the park.' We entered near the Broadwalk and I turned to the left, striking out across the grass in the direction of Speke. The sun shone from a brilliantly blue sky and the thick crystalline tufty hoar frost was piled high upon the motionless boughs of the bare trees. Smoke from a bonfire of leaves rose straight upward in an unswaying column. There was not a breath of wind. It was very cold.
I led Biscuit across the grass into the middle of nowhere, a space between huge trees, then turned and faced her. I feared that her message would be in some way fatal, in some way good-bye. I touched in my overcoat pocket the long letter which I had written to Kitty and for which now there might be no place.
âWell, Biscuit?'
Biscuit was wearing blue tweedy trousers and black lace-up boots and the shabby blue duffle coat with her plait tucked in behind. The cold air made her sallow-golden cheeks glow with a strangely darkish red, making her cheek bones stand out as blobs of colour. For a moment her huge dark eyes gazed up at me with an unsmiling intensity which was almost hostile. Then she drew an envelope out of her pocket and held it to me in silence with a gloved hand.
I could not conceal my emotion. I had no gloves, and my hands, red and moist, bitten to the bone by the cold air and trembling into the bargain, fumbled clumsily to open the slim missive. I got it open at last. There was a very short note.
Hold fast and don't worry. Could you see me at Cheyne Walk at six this evening? I shall be alone. K.J.
This was so unexpected and so perfect, so wonderful, so beyond my dreams, so filling the future with joy, that for a moment I simply did not know what to do with myself. I wanted to shout or caper or spin like a top. I did not want Biscuit to see my face, so I turned abruptly and began to walk in the direction of the Serpentine. The grass was thickly encrusted with frost, laid out in an elaborate flattened crisscross pattern of spidery glassy fibres which took our footsteps with a crisp dry sound. The distant traffic was a quiet murmur. Beneath the cloudless sky and the almost translucent frosty plumage of the trees a great winter silence possessed the scene, in which I could hear Biscuit's light footsteps as she followed after me.
I stopped and let her catch up and we faced each other again. âBiscuit â '
âYes?'
âTell Lady Kitty that I will come this evening.'
âYes.'
âAnd â will you â give her this.' I took my plump letter to Kitty out of my pocket and handed it over. Gazing up at me expressionlessly Biscuit put it away.
âBiscottina.'
âYes?'
âLook at our footprints in the frost.'
We looked back at our two tracks, absurdly wavering, stretching away behind us across the frost-lacquered grass, my large feet and Biscuit's little feet.
âBiscottinetta.'
âYes?'
âCan you play leap-frog?'
âYes!' She loosened her duffle coat.
I moved a few paces farther on and leaned over to make a âback'. A moment later I heard the crunch crunch of her running steps and with the lightest possible tap of her fingers upon my spine she soared lightly over me and bounded onwards, her toes dabbing the frosted grass in a line of little round holes. She leaned over for me. I ran and went over her with a light spring, touching the stuff of her coat with the gentlest flying caress of one hand. There seemed to be no gravity in the park that morning. I ran on and leaned again for her. I pumped in hope and happiness with the cold air. Kitty's note had released me into a carefree world.
Her words could scarcely have been more reassuring and had the wonderful effect of creating another
interim.
I seemed to live in these days by interims. Until this evening I had nothing to fear, no decisions to make, nothing to do but enjoy myself. The prospect of seeing Kitty at six turned the universe into a glorious mish-mash of sheer joy. No wonder I could fly like a bird. Moreover this was not just a private selfish delight at the thought of being with Kitty, it was a sort of spiritual bliss, an explosion of confidence. Somehow the whole plan would work. I would do what Kitty wanted, I would help Gunnar, I would help myself, there would be reconciliation and tears of relief. I would be able to change my life after all and live like an ordinary man. I would educate Crystal and take her to Venice and make her laugh with happiness. I would at last be able to do all the things which had seemed impossible. All would be well and all would be well and all manner of thing would be well. More strangely still, this great hope of good coexisted, without losing a tittle of its power, with all the old realistic terrors, the fears of a false step, the fears of Gunnar's anger and Gunnar's revenge; it even coexisted, strangest of all, with my perfectly commonsensical awareness that Kitty was not really a saint or a prophetess, but an ordinary and possibly rather silly woman who liked a mystery and the exercise of power. Such are the remarkable faculties of the human mind, such was my mind that morning in the park as it expanded and rejoiced.
By now our leap-frogging had brought us near to the Serpentine and we stopped breathless and laughing. I took Biscuit in my arms and hugged her as one child hugs another, feeling the frailty of her thin body inside her bulky coat.
The frost, which had so mysteriously appeared during the night, had balanced itself inches high upon the branches of trees, upon the iron railings and the backs of seats. It seemed indeed organically connected with these terrestrial surfaces, as if the world had begun, during the hours of darkness, to exude a minutely complicated crystalline plumage which, precariously still, rising high upon the thinnest topmost twigs of the immobile trees, appeared a silvery grey against a sky by contrast so blue as to seem indigo, to seem almost brilliantly leaden.
We had come out into the open beside the water. Not at Peter Pan, my carefree running steps had had the awareness to avoid that; we were in the next bay, the nearest one to the bridge. The Serpentine was frozen along its edges and the thick dust of the frost upon the ice was crisscrossed already with the footprints of waterbirds. Some ducks, in single file, were walking on the ice as if for a wager and finding it quite hard to keep their feet. We came to a seat and I dusted the frost off with my sleeve and we sat down and I put my arm along the back of the seat, knocking off a solid little wall of frost, and drew Biscuit up close against me till I could feel her warmth through the surfaces of two very damp overcoats.
âWell, Lady Alexandra Bissett, and how are we today, Lady Alexandra?'
âAll right, Hilary. It's such a lovely day.'
âIt's one of the great days. Tell me something, Alexandra. Was your father really a British colonel?'
Biscuit pushed me a little away so that she could look up into my face. I contemplated her reddish-black eyes, the refinement of her long thin wary mouth.
âNo.'
âA private?'
âNo.'
âWas your mother a Brahmin?'
âNo.'
âWere you born in Benares?'
âNo.'
âWere you born in India?'
âNo.'
âAre you a dreadful little liar?'
âYes.'
âI shall be jolly sorry if it turns out that your name isn't even Alexandra Bissett.'
âOh it is, it is!' she said eagerly. âMy name is Alexandra Bissett. I was called after Princess Alexandra.'
âSo even if you aren't a princess you were called after one. I thought you couldn't possibly really come from India.'
âWhy?'
âBecause of your voice. You're a little Cockney girl, aren't you? You were born in, let me see â Stepney?'
âEast India Dock Road.'
âNot Benares.'
âNot Benares.'
âMy dearest little London Biscuitula.' I kissed the thin intelligent mouth. It gave a little responsive motion but did not try to detain my lips. It was very cold. I thought, here I am kissing Lady Kitty's maid, and not for the first time either. That seemed all right. As I would never kiss Lady Kitty I might as well kiss her maid. After all I too belonged to the servants' hall. It did not even make me feel sad. In the pure interim of today nothing could make me feel sad.
âWas your mother English?'
âYes.'
âBut you had an Indian father? Who was he?'
âI don't know.'
âMy father was a mystery man too.'