The Shut Mouth Society (25 page)

“
If I remember correctly, the assassination of Lincoln included a simultaneous attempt against the secretary of state and the vice president. And after the authorities finally cornered Booth in a barn, he ended up dead.”

“
What’re you driving at?”

“
That Lincoln’s assassination was a big conspiracy, big, with roots that went back to the Confederate States of America and Jefferson Davis. Booth may have been killed to keep the organizers’ identities secret. Perhaps these Lincoln papers expose other villains. If Johnson knew something, they might have impeached him to shut him up. Whatever happened back then, someone may have squirreled away a bunch of documents so posterity could eventually learn the truth.”

Baldwin took off her glasses and rubbed her eyes. “Where did you get this stuff?”

“
From the web, back in Santa Barbara when I did some research on secret societies.” Evarts felt embarrassed. “I’m not saying I know, I’m just saying maybe.”

“
One question.” When she lowered her hand to give Evarts a direct look, he again noticed her striking emerald eyes. “Why would anyone care so much about the exposure of people long dead that they would traipse around the country killing people today?”

Evarts collapsed against the back of his chair. “Shit.”

“
Shit?”

“
I mean, you’re right. Why would anyone go to such extreme measures to protect an ancestor’s reputation? Something more has got to be at stake.”

“
Agreed.” She slid her glasses back onto her face, using two fingers to hold the bridge.

“
Money or power,” Evarts mumbled.

“
What?”

“
Sorry. I said, money or power. We don’t prosecute descendants for the crimes of a forebear. My bet is that these documents threaten some currently active organization’s power base or financial resources.”

“
The Republican Party? They controlled the government at the time.”

“
Democrats were around as well, but the problem is that neither qualifies as a secret society.”

“
Perhaps the Shut Mouth Society provides hidden funding.”

“
Not likely, with modern campaign finance laws. No … I think they hide their power as well as their identity. It won’t be anything so obvious as a political party.”

“
Then I’m at a loss.”

“
Who, what, when, where, and why.” Evarts got up and paced again. “We know when: right after the Civil War; and we think we have a handle on who: the Sherman bunch. I think we should concentrate on where. Where did they hide the documents?”

“
Washington or Springfield seem obvious choices.” She gave Evarts an irritated look and waved her two fingers to indicate he should sit. “You’re making me nervous.”

“
Let’s walk outside. I can’t stay in this tiny room any longer.”

“
All right, I want to show you something anyway.”

With that they gathered up their possessions and each picked a couple books to check out overnight. After leaving the library, Evarts followed Baldwin’s lead, and they walked the long way around Beacon Hill. In a few minutes she stopped and said, “That’s the Lewis and Harriet Hayden house.”

Evarts saw a four-story brick townhouse that looked no different from the rest of the houses on the block. “The name doesn’t mean anything to me. What’s the significance of that house?”

“
Lewis Hayden was an escaped slave, and he and his wife harbored runaways on their way to Canada. That house is a famous Underground Railroad station. Come on. I’ll show you where Abe Douglass’s ancestor preached.”

After a few minutes she stopped in front of another large brick structure. “This is the African Meeting House, the oldest black church in America. Frederick Douglass spoke here many times.”

Evarts stared at the building. “Why did you bring me here?”

“
I’m not sure, but Abe Douglass visited here many times and helped finance the restoration.” Baldwin turned and looked at Evarts. “You keep saying that the three big events at the time of the formation of the Shut Mouth Society were the end of the war, the assassination, and the impeachment. You forgot the Thirteenth Amendment.”

“
The amendment that abolished slavery?”

“
Yes. In 1865 … after Lincoln’s assassination.”

“
Damn, you’re right. Abe Douglass may have misled us. The Shut Mouth Society might be black.”

“
Or a secret society that works against blacks. Like the Ku Klux Klan.”

“
My mind’s reeling. Let’s drop these books off at the apartment and get some dinner.”

They brought in pizza again and continued their research. They worked until they both felt exhausted. Evarts went over to the couch and fell fast asleep before eleven o’clock.

Buzz!

At first Evarts felt disoriented, but in a flash he realized that someone had breached the outer door and had tried to turn off the staircase lights. He threw off the blanket and scrambled to the laptop on the small table near the entry. What he saw on the camera display made him gasp. Two men stood at the bottom of the stairs. Each held a gun.

Chapter 27

Baldwin rushed into the front room. “What was that god-awful noise?”

Evarts put his finger over his lips to signal Baldwin to hush. Damn. He should’ve spent more money on the damn buzzer. It was so shrill and loud, they must have heard it. He glanced back at the screen, and what he saw indicated they had. The men single-filed carefully up the stairs, staying to the side with guns aimed at the door at the top of the narrow confine. How secure was the top door? How much time did he have to prepare for their entry? From the cameras, he could see no threat out the back in the alley, but he couldn’t believe they would leave it unguarded.

Looking over his shoulder, Baldwin saw the screen and struggled for breath. Evarts turned and grabbed her by the shoulders. “Go throw some things in a bag. Hurry,” he whispered.

She bolted for the bedroom and Evarts went to the rear window. When he threw it open, he felt a sharp pain above his left eye. Jerking his head back, he swiped his face and saw blood on his fingers. Silencer. He had heard nothing. He made another quick inspection of his face and decided that only a wood splinter had nicked him. Damn. How had they found them?

By the time he had gotten back to the computer screen, the first man had reached the upper door. When they had moved their stuff into the loft, he had staged his shotgun against the front doorframe. Now he reached for it while keeping an eye on the computer screen. By the time he swung the shotgun into his arms, the first man had reached up and used the barrel of his automatic pistol to break the camera. They had lost their view of the outside world. Damn. Damn. Damn.

Evarts snapped the lid of the computer shut and jerked out the USB cables that connected the cameras. He took a quick look at the door handle and made a decision. He raced to the bedroom doorway and stage-whispered, “Dress. Fast.” When he saw acknowledgment of what he had said in her eyes, he whipped around and threw on his own clothes, all the while keeping an eye on the doorknob for any movement that would indicate they had succeeded in picking the lock. After he pulled up his pants and buckled his belt, he tucked his SIG in his back waistband and dropped some extra shotgun shells into his pocket.

Evarts had just switched from tying his left shoe to his right, when Baldwin came bounding out from the bedroom fully dressed, carrying her purse and the same Tumi overnight bag she had brought with her from Westwood. He started to ask if she had any of his things but decided that was ridiculously inconsequential.

This time he laid a gentle hand on her shoulder and leaned into her ear. “Trish, I’m sorry, but we’re going to have to shoot our way out.”

She gave him a worried look. “Greg, you’re bleeding.”

“
Just a nick. It’s how I found out they’re covering the fire escape.”

She wiped the blood away from his eye and seemed satisfied that the wound wouldn’t kill him. “I want my computer,” she whispered. Without waiting for his reply, she grabbed the laptop and power cord and jammed it into her matching Tumi computer case. With bag straps slung over both shoulders, she reached into her purse and pulled out the .45. She pointed the automatic straight up and extended her finger along the barrel. With more composure than he felt, he heard her ask, “How do we do it?”

“
Put the gun away a sec. I need you to help me push this chest against the door.” He pointed at a low chest that sat against the opposite wall.

She gave him a brief questioning look, but she put the .45 back in her purse. They raced over to the chest and carried it over to the entrance. Evarts was surprised how heavy it was, but then he remembered that he had inspected it on arrival and found it full of books.

Whoever picked this apartment knew the closed-in staircase provided a good defensive obstacle. It was so narrow, assailants would need to climb single file, and the tiny landing in front of the door had enough space for only one person.

Evarts explained in a low voice, “They’ll have the door lock picked soon, and they know we’re ready. If they’re as professional as I think, they’ll snap the door open and throw in a percussion grenade.”

“
Shit.”

“
Exactly. We want the door to open, but only an inch or two. Enough for this.” Evarts held up the shotgun by the barrel. After Baldwin nodded, she helped him position the chest close, but not tight, against the door.

“
What do I do?” Her voice broke a little, and Evarts actually felt relieved to see her show a little anxiety.

Evarts whispered even lower. “Sit with your back against the chest. That will add additional resistance.”

She took out her gun and pointed it straight up in both hands.

“
And don’t shoot me,” he added.

“
Where will you be?”

“
Right here.” He lay on his back along the baseboard and pointed the shotgun over his shoulder so it was positioned to shove through the crack in the door when it opened. He wanted to be low and out of the first line of sight.

She sat behind the chest and looked around its edge to catch his eye. “This’ll never hold the door.”

He whispered, “I don’t want the door jammed tight. I want it to give an inch or so, with just enough resistance that the bastard’s instinct will be to throw his shoulder against it. I need that split second before he tosses in a flash grenade or starts shooting.”

She suddenly looked scared. “This might not work.”

Evarts put his finger in front of his mouth to signal quiet.

“
Greg, I’m scared.”

“
Me too. Just don’t panic.” He made another quiet gesture with his finger and then whispered low, “We’ll get through this.”

In another thirty seconds, Evarts saw the doorknob move ever so slightly. He pointed the shotgun almost straight up over his right shoulder. The door banged open against the chest, and Evarts instantly shoved the shotgun through the crack pointed at about where the assailant’s chest ought to be if he threw his shoulder against the door.

He pulled the trigger. Bang!

He cycled the pump action, adjusted the aim, and fired again. Bang!

He rolled over onto his knees against the wall and blindly pointed the shotgun around the now open door and pulled the trigger again. Bang!

After he cycled the gun, he peered around the corner and saw both men tumbling down the stairs. He jumped up and ran after them. When the one toward the bottom bounced clear of his partner, Evarts pulled the trigger with the barrel aimed at the middle of his chest.

Bang! That one was no longer a concern.

Evarts raised the shotgun to his shoulder and aimed at the second tumbling body. He almost shot again, but in the last instant he saw that the man’s face had been blasted into a bloody mash. He continued down the stairs, making high steps like a football player running through tires until he got past the bodies. When he got to the lower door, he dropped to one knee and threw it open, swinging the shotgun left to right.

He heard a shot slam into something close by, but he couldn’t see where it came from. Reflexively, he snapped back into the stairwell with his back against the wall. Reaching into his pocket, he pulled out two 00 buckshot shells and rammed them into the gun. Suddenly he became aware of Baldwin beside him. No time to waste. The stairwell was a trap. It had been a trap for the two men he shot and now it trapped them. He had to get out, and the only chance for escape depended on a startling and savage attack. He leaped out the door.

Evarts bounced his shoulder against a parked car and whipped his head left and right. Where were they? Then he heard someone on the other side of the very car he had taken shelter behind. He stepped back, keeping low, and holding the shotgun at his waist. He pulled the trigger, shooting through the front side windows, spraying glass everywhere. Someone yelled and he dropped to a knee just in time to see a head appear briefly above the doorframe on the other side of the car. Bang! The way the head recoiled told Evarts that he no longer had to worry about that particular threat.