Read The Assassins' Gate Online
Authors: George Packer
And these flowers grow because of the blood
Of those who gave their lives for Iraq.
God is great!
It's the day for the Shia to give their voice!
Allawi, in turn, was flooding the Arabic television channels with slick campaign ads paid out of official coffers, and his government had recently promised raises to civil servants and police officers. His ticket was gaining ground in the minority Sunni and Christian areas of Basra, as well as among professionals. In the days leading up to the elections, a number of Basrawin told me that they sensed a surge toward Allawi.
The day before the elections was a feast day called Ghadir al-Khumm. In 632, as Mohamed made his way back to Medina from his last pilgrimage to Mecca, he is believed to have stopped by a pool of stagnant water, or
ghadir,
in the desert and held up the hand of his cousin and son-in-law, Ali. “For whomever I am his
mawla,
” the Prophet told the world, “Ali is his
mawla.
” Those Muslims who took
mawla
to mean “master” and believed Ali to be the Prophet's chosen successor as caliph became the Shia, or the “partisans” of Ali and his son, Hussein, and all of the imams who descended from them, down to the twelfth and last, the hidden Mahdi, whose reappearance would usher in the apocalypse. Those who took
mawla
to mean “friend,” and who believed in an entirely different account of who succeeded Mohamed, became the Sunnis. So Ghadir al-Khumm marked the beginning of the great fracture among Muslims, and the Arab Shia were its historical losers, living down the centuries under the religious authority of the Sunni caliphate, and, more recently, under the temporal power of Sunni politiciansâeven in Iraq, where the Shia were the majority. Shia had failed to join the first Iraqi government, under British occupation in the 1920s, because of a fatwa, and during Saddam's regime their leaders had been systematically murdered. For secular Iraqis, the country's first truly democratic elections meant that they could at last escape the nightmare of the Saddam years and join the civilized world. For religious Shia, after the martyrdom of Ali and of Hussein, after the centuries of penitence, quietism, and suffering, the elections would grant them their rightful share of power and correct a historic wrong going back more than a thousand years.
On the Friday before the elections, at the Hakemiya mosque, off a busy commercial street near the bombed intelligence building, Imam Mohamed al-Basry delivered prayers to the men packed into his small shrine. A loudspeaker blared his words to the surrounding neighborhood. He was just thirty-one, a former biologist with square-framed glasses, a missing front tooth, and an ill-at-ease manner. He made sure that his flock understood the significance of the fact that election day was the day after Ghadir al-Khumm. Ordinarily, Shia would travel to Najaf on Ghadir al-Khumm to visit the shrine of Ali, but this year, as part of the election security effort, there would be a nationwide ban on car travel beginning at dusk on the eve of the elections. The imam said, “There is something we can do that's maybe more important than this visit. We will make our rights clear. And that is much more important than visiting Najaf on the right day.”
The imam's voice rose as he tried to galvanize the men kneeling before him. “The day after tomorrow is election day,” he said. “It will be a great day, and we should prepare ourselves for this day as we prepare ourselves for any other Islamic feast, because this day will bring victory to the people who suffered from injustice. It will be the day when there will be no more suffering for the people. It will be the day when the victim will get rid of the person who abused him.” On election day, the imam declared, Shia should follow their
marjayia,
their religious scholars, who were heirs to Ali and his familyâthe true heirs to the Prophet. The word of a
marja
was like the word of the Prophet, and following the
marjayia
meant accepting Ali as caliph: This was the doctrinal connection between Ghadir al-Khumm and election day. The imam had arrived at the point of the sermon. “The
marjayia
composed and support a list, the United Iraqi Alliance, which carries the number 169, which carries the candle symbol,” he said. “Did anyone not hear me? I want this word to reach even to the outside loudspeakers, so no one will be able to say it is a lie. And I don't want to hear that the
marjayia
didn't support this list.”
The imam was venturing onto controversial ground (and when I met with him afterward, he refused to discuss any of it). The other parties claimed that Sistani, who no one doubted had helped to compose No. 169, had blessed
all
the lists, and they cried foul when his picture started appearing on No. 169 campaign signs. Sistani himself said nothing to resolve the dispute. The clergy had previously kept out of it. Now Imam Basry wasn't content merely to clear up the doubt about Sistani's support for No. 169; he went on to imply that the Allawi government, by raising salaries, was trying to bribe voters. “I remind you that death is close to every person,” the imam said. “No one knows when he will dieâhe might die at any moment. What will he say to our God? âI voted for a certain list because they gave me money'? How can he face God with this answer?”
The imam then told his flock what time the polls would open and close, how many pieces of ID to bring, how to find List 169 on the ballot, and how to check the right square. Apparently satisfied that his instructions were clear, he offered his valediction: “God will be with you that day, so you should not fear anything, you should have no fear of terrorists. The Shia of Hussein should remember this saying: We refuse humiliation, and we should go to vote.”
*Â Â Â *Â Â Â *
SUNDAY MORNING
was strange and beautiful. The streets of Basra were so quiet that people later said it was like a feast day. Families, including small children and grandparents, were walking together along the wide avenues, everyone dressed in fine clothes. Many Basrawin I spoke with had discussed with their families what to do on election dayâwhether it would be safer to go out in the morning or afternoon, whether it would be better to lose only one or two members of the family or to die together. Policemen and National Guardsmen stood at intersections every couple of hundred yards, and snipers perched on the roof of the provincial government building. People on their way to vote were amazed to see men in uniform actually doing their jobs. By seven-thirty, at the schools that had been designated polling places, voters were already lining up; the queues were orderly and the faces a little solemn. People submitted without complaint to the frisks, and they seemed to keep their voices down out of respect. Election workersâschoolteachers, housewives, unemployed college graduatesâwore badges on their shirts. They handed out ballots with the slightly exaggerated seriousness of people performing a small but important ritual, like professors distributing final exams. They guided each voters' right index finger down into the little glass half full of violet ink. Ordinary Iraqis on any other day, the election workers were thanked as if they were the heroes of 1991. The ballots themselvesâbeige for the national elections, blue for the provincialâwere large and crowded with a bewildering array of party symbols. They looked cleaner and newer than anything else I'd ever seen in Iraq.
At the Republican School, just off Independence Street, Shadha Mohamed Ali, a fifty-year-old housewife in a stylish red-and-black scarf, cast the day's first vote. “I spent thirty-five years of my life going from war to war,” she said. “Now my hopes are for my children. We lost our future. We're looking for the future of our children.” Mehsin Richem Hashem, a teacher of Arabic at the school and the manager of the polling station, said, “I've lived over fifty years, and I've never had such a feeling. My skin had a strange feeling, like goose bumps. We've had a great culture for six thousand years, and now I think our humanity is proved. We hope this democratic experiment brings this result, that the people are the real owners of the decisions in this country.” He wore a slightly tattered jacket and a floral tie, and his face was taut, with a carefully clipped mustache. “There's a rumor they poisoned the water supply in as-Zubair this morning,” he said, referring to a Sunni suburb south of Basra. (The rumor proved false.) “We don't care what the terrorists do. They have tried everything but they can't do anything. Poisoning the waters shows they're desperate.”
Around 8:20, the school shook slightly when a mortar round landed a few hundred yards away.
“Yalla,”
someone muttered. “No problem, no problem,” Laith Mahmood Shaker, a thirty-two-year-old traffic policeman who had brought his children, said. “What we are doing now is a big thing against terrorism. It's like a challenge to them: We're votingâwhat can you do?”
A number of voters recalled the only elections they had known, the farces that had certified Saddam's popularity. They had been offered a choice between one box marked yes and one marked no; sometimes, the election workers simply cast their votes for them. This time, many people exercised their newfound right to keep their choices to themselves. Feisal Jassim, a retired oil-company employeeâhe had been among the worshippers who listened to Imam Basry's instructionsâwouldn't reveal his choice. For him, the experience of voting freely for the first time, at age seventy, was what mattered. “Most Iraqis don't know what democracy means,” he said. “Is it sweet, is it bitter? Does it have a taste or a smell? We don't know. After the elections, we'll find out.”
In one polling place, I met Abdul-Khadem Hussein Abood, a uniformed National Guard colonel with a fragile physique, a hollow face, and piercing black eyes. Fifty-six years old, he had been a prisoner of war in Iran for seventeen years, during the prime of his life; he was released and came back to Basra two days before the start of the war in 2003 and was overjoyed to find that his small children had grown up to become engineers and a doctor. Colonel Abood held up four fingers, one for each child: His index finger was stained.
My translator in Basra was an overweight, pleasantly melancholy young doctor from Baghdad named Omar. After the first bombs fell on the city in March of 2003, Omar stayed at his hospital for three weeks to treat the wounded and then, when order collapsed, to stave off the looters; by the end he was one of only five doctors still on duty. He was easily bored, even during the occupation, when the endless explosions and high body counts meant that every young doctor became a hardened trauma specialist. Election day, said Omar, a secular Sunni without strong political views, was “just another day.” So he feltâuntil, as we were about to leave a polling station after talking with a dozen voters, he suddenly exclaimed, “Please wait!” He went back inside and begged the election workers to let him vote, even though he was registered in Baghdad. Phlegmatic Omar came out beaming. “I feel great!”
His family lived in Amariya, a western Baghdad neighborhood off the dangerous airport highway that was a notorious hotbed of the insurgency. No one in the family knew that Omar worked with Westerners for a living. All morning, he kept calling home to see whether his family had voted, and around noon he was stunned to hear that his mother and brothers, having looked out the front door to find their neighbors trickling into the street, had made a dash to the polls themselves. They returned home safely, and before nightfall even his father, a retired army officer who was becoming a Sunni extremist in his later years, was envious enough of their purple fingertips, of the tremendous excitement spreading through Baghdad and most of Iraq, to go down and vote as well. Omar's best friend, Ali, who also lived in Amariya, made three attempts to vote. On the first try, Ali got halfway down the street when a friend known to be a sympathizer with the insurgency greeted him suspiciously. “Where are you going?” he asked. “To get some bread,” Ali said. “I'll go with you,” the friend said, and Ali proceeded to the bakery for a loaf of bread he didn't need. A few hours later he tried again, and some men coming out of the mosque cornered him. “Where are you going?” they asked. “To the pharmacy, for my aunt's prescription,” Ali said. “We'll go with you,” the men said, and when they reached the pharmacy Ali had to pretend that he'd forgotten the prescription at home. As the afternoon grew late and the polls prepared to close, Ali, who had been watching scenes of people lining up to vote on television all day, panicked and called Omar in Basra. Patiently, Omar talked Ali through a two-mile detour around the back streets of Amariya. Ali reached the polling station only to find out that it wasn't his: He was supposed to vote in the school just behind his house. And so Ali did, and as soon as he made it home his mother frantically scrubbed the purple dye off his finger with chlorine.
I returned to the Republican School in Basra just before the polls closed, at dusk. The last person in line was Abid Hamid, a policeman who had been so busy all day that he'd almost forgotten to vote. “It's not important whom I choose,” he said. “I just want to participate.” The outer gate was locked, and I was allowed to stay and watch the count. The ballots were collected in bundles of twenty-five, and then laid out, one after another, on a wooden table in the middle of a sixth-grade math classroom. The right hand of the counter, a math teacher named Salih Younis Mahdi, was deformed; he had only the three middle fingers, and they were webbed together. He ran his hand rapidly down the ballots like a ruler, slapping the paper when he came to the checked box, then calling out the number. Ahmad Salih Mahdi, an elderly first-grade teacher, stood silently at the chalkboard and recorded the votes in groups of five. Monitors from the parties and the election commission stood by, and when, predictably, the power failed, hurricane lamps were produced, and the classroom became a chiaroscuro study of long shadows and illuminated faces.