Suspicion (16 page)

Maisie hesitates. When she speaks again, her voice is tentative.

“My mother and Oscar keep an assortment of hostess gifts on hand. In fact, there’s a beautiful statuette that Mother has been saving for such an occasion. It would look lovely on a desk or mantelpiece. Should I wrap it for you?”

I breathe a sigh of relief.

“Maisie, you’re a lifesaver. That sounds perfect.”

An hour later I sit in the backseat of the Aston Martin as Alfie drives through the nearby town of Great Milton, toward Stanhope Abbey. I’ve been there before, on long-ago playdates with Sebastian and Theo, but my recollections of their house are hazier than those of my early years at Rockford Manor.

I draw in my breath as we pull through the gates and continue up the winding road to an Elizabethan mansion, set against a backdrop of rising hills and lush green parkland.

“Here we are,” Alfie says. “Stanhope Abbey.”

“Is it strange to be back?” I ask timidly. “You must have driven Lucia here all the time.”

“When she was younger, yes. But after your grandfather bought her a car for her seventeenth birthday, she was thrilled to be rid of me.” Alfie smiles sadly.

“I’m sure that’s not true,” I tell him.

Alfie’s expression changes.

“The car made Lucia so independent, I think she forgot I was there for her. And I often wonder … Well, if she had only entrusted me to do my job that night and take care of her, if she wanted to go out so badly, I would have driven her anywhere she wished to go. She didn’t have to walk out into that storm, when the pouring rain and winds made it impossible to see where you—” He breaks off midsentence. “My apologies, Your Grace. I have forgotten myself. You shouldn’t be burdened with an old man’s regrets.”

“No. You can’t blame yourself,” I say gently, realizing I’m repeating the words that have been said to me so many times about my parents’ deaths. “There’s no way you could have known she was planning to go out in that storm. And if she was determined to walk to the Maze alone … well, I don’t see how you or anyone could have stopped her.”

“Thank you, Your Grace.” He pauses. “If you don’t mind my saying so, you’re … very different from Lady Lucia.”

“From what I’ve seen, I don’t think anyone could compare to her,” I agree. “She was unbelievably gorgeous, and if her personality was anything like what I remember, then she was a real force to be reckoned with.”

“Please don’t misunderstand me,” Alfie says hurriedly. “I wasn’t making an unfavorable comparison. On the contrary, actually. I loved Lady Lucia, we all did, but—well, she never would have cared to speak to me the way you just did.”

I don’t doubt him. Even as a little girl Lucia had an imperious streak, treating the staff as her underlings. But it throws me to hear any criticism of my cousin, who up until now loomed in my mind as the Perfect Predecessor, with shoes too large to fill.

“I’m sure she did care. But I know what you’re getting at, and … thank you.”

“Have a wonderful night, Your Grace,” he says as the Stanhopes’ footman opens the car door.

“Welcome to Stanhope Abbey, Duchess,” he greets me, dropping into a bow. “The family is expecting you in the drawing room.”

He leads me up the front steps and into the house, which is smaller than Rockford Manor but just as lavish, complete with frescoed walls, painted ceilings, and halls lined with awe-inspiring sculptures and family portraits. I’m beginning to realize that for English aristocrats, the home is the place to show off all their precious assets, with no corner left unadorned.

“The Duchess of Wickersham,” the footman announces as we approach the drawing room door.

I watch from the doorway as the Stanhopes and four other guests rise to their feet. My eyes instantly meet Sebastian’s. He is a vision in his dark suit, and I feel a familiar swooping in my stomach as we look at each other. His gaze is friendly, like the Sebastian I remember from before, and I wonder if we’ve moved past the awkwardness of my return—if we’ve reached some unspoken understanding since meeting in the cemetery.

Lord and Lady Stanhope step forward to greet me, followed by their guests: Viscount Warren and his daughter, Lady Cecily Warren, who looks around my age, and a Mr. and Mrs. Blythe from London. Once the formalities are out of the way, Theo comes up to me with a big grin.

“Imogen, you look cracking,” he says, draping an arm over my shoulder.

“Cracking?” I repeat dubiously.

“He means you look good,” Sebastian says with a brief smile.

His words set off a flock of butterflies in my stomach, but then I remind myself that he’s only relaying what his brother said. If anyone here is flirting with me—and that’s still very much an
if
—it’s Theo, not Sebastian.

“Thanks, Theo. You look cracking yourself,” I say, my nerves beginning to settle. And as I study him, I realize Theo
is
pretty darn cute. Anyone in this room would be overshadowed by Sebastian’s movie-star looks, but Theo is adorable, the kind of guy I can picture Zoey going nuts over.

I suddenly remember the gift in my hands, wrapped to perfection by Maisie.

“I have something for you all. Let me give this to your mom.”

The three of us approach Lady Stanhope, who is chatting with the viscount and his daughter.

“Lady Imogen, you must get to know Cecily here,” she says as we join them. “I think you two will be fast friends. Cecily is starting Oxford this fall.”

“Oh, cool. I’m about to start a summer class there, at Christ Church college,” I tell Cecily.

“So am I,” Sebastian says, eyeing me in surprise. “Which class are you taking?”

“Classical Literature and Mythology. What about you?” I hold my breath as I wait for his reply.

He smiles slightly, but his voice has an edge to it when he speaks.

“The same. I needed an extra few credits for my degree. What made you choose the subject?”

For a moment I’m speechless, thrilled at the idea of us in the same class, but I regain my composure just in time.

“English is my best subject, and my guardian back in New York insisted that I give Oxford a try this summer. If I can manage to do well, then I’ll apply for next fall’s term.”

“Well, this is too lovely!” Lady Stanhope says, smiling brightly. “All three of you at Oxford! Theo, you’re next.”

“We’ll see.” Theo laughs.

I hand Lady Stanhope the gift.

“This is for you.”

“Oh, you
shouldn’t
have,” she demurs as she begins unwrapping the package. I watch in anticipation, hoping she and the Stanhopes will love it as much as Maisie seemed to think they would.

Lady Stanhope holds up the unwrapped gift, an antique porcelain statuette of a stinking woman. Theo’s eyes dart nervously toward Sebastian, who stares at the statuette in shock.

“Um, it’s a decorative piece,” I explain awkwardly, bewildered by the reactions to my gift. “It’s for a desktop, or a mantelpiece. …” My voice trails off, as I notice how pale Sebastian’s face has become, making his green eyes look darker than I’ve ever seen them. He advances toward me, his hands clenching and unclenching repeatedly.

“What are you playing at?” he snaps, his voice so sharp it nearly makes me jump. “How could you take that out of her room? Why would you bring it here?”

“What?” I stare at him uncomprehendingly. “Out of whose room? What do you mean? It’s just a present!”

“A present?” He lets out a short, mirthless laugh. “I should have known.”

And with that, he knocks the statuette out of his mother’s grasp. The figurine shatters on the hardwood floor, sending porcelain shards flying across the room. For one terrible second, we all freeze in place. Then Lady Stanhope yelps in alarm, as Sebastian storms out of the room and Theo rushes to my side.

W
hat just happened?” I cry out. “What’s
wrong
with him?”

“I’m sorry,” Lady Stanhope murmurs, first to me and then to each of her guests. “I’m so sorry—I don’t know what’s gotten into him.”

“I’ll be back,” Lord Stanhope says grimly, following Sebastian out the door.

Lady Stanhope nervously smoothes her hair and takes a few shallow breaths.

“Why don’t we move into the library and let the maid clean this up?”

She leads the way into the corridor, but I hang back, unable to tear my eyes away from the shattered figurine. I don’t know what disturbs me more—the fact that my gift provoked such a reaction, or that my sweet childhood friend has turned into someone capable of flying into such a rage.

I feel a hand on my shoulder, and I turn around, looking into Theo’s kind eyes.

“I … I don’t understand,” I say falteringly.

“Of course you don’t. My brother is a prat for assuming the worst of you,” Theo says, shaking his head. “You didn’t know what you brought, did you?”

“What do you mean? It was just a silly gift!” I feel tears pricking at my eyes, and I force them back.

Theo takes a deep breath.

“It was a statuette of Lady Beatrice, the fifth Duchess of Wickersham, from the early 1800s.”

The name is familiar.

“I think I’ve heard of her. My etiquette coach mentioned a Lady Beatrice as the person who supposedly tamed the Rockford land. But why would Sebastian be so mad about her statue?”

“Because he bought it for Lucia two years ago. I’m not sure where you got it, but it was hers. I remember Sebastian saying it was an original.”

I can’t believe it. Nausea washes over me as I realize what Maisie has done.

“I—I had no idea,” I manage to choke out, staring at Theo in horror. “Maisie said it was a brand-new gift that Mrs. Mulgrave and Oscar had saved for a special occasion. She set me up! But
why?
”

Theo doesn’t look surprised.

“Isn’t it obvious? Lucia wasn’t just Maisie’s boss. She was her only friend and her whole life, really. I’m sure she has some resentment toward you for taking her place.”

I sink into a chair, resting my head in my hands.

“I didn’t ask for any of this. I didn’t
want
to come back—it just seemed like the right thing to do. I made a big mistake, didn’t I?” I give him a sidelong glance. “My maid is out to get me, and the friend I couldn’t wait to reconnect with hates me.”

Theo pulls up a chair beside me, placing a gentle hand on my shoulder.

“Sebastian doesn’t hate you. I’m sure he’s going to feel like a right arse when he finds out none of this was your fault. And why don’t you just sack Maisie?”

I groan.

“I wish, but I can’t do that. I have a co-regent who runs the estate with me until I turn twenty-one, and I highly doubt he’d be willing to fire Maisie over a gift gone wrong when her mom is the housekeeper and they’ve both been at Rockford a whole lot longer than me.”

“I guess you’re right,” Theo concedes. He reaches for my hand, and I feel a flicker of surprise—both at his actions and the way I warm to them. “Look, I’m not stupid. I know I’m not the brother you were excited to see tonight. But let me be the friend you need. I want to be here for you.”

I flush with embarrassment. Have I really been so obvious?

“I— It’s not that I
wasn’t
excited to see you. I was, honestly. But when we were younger, I spent more time with Sebastian. I knew him better—”

“You don’t have to explain,” Theo interrupts. “I get it. I’m just … stating my intentions, I guess.” He grins, his cute dimple reappearing.

I squeeze his hand, touched.

“Your English directness is
very
refreshing. I don’t think I’ve ever heard an American guy our age say anything so eloquent … or sweet.”

“That’s good to hear,” Theo says with a wink. “Well, we’d better join the others before my mum gets even more bent out of shape.”

We walk together into the library, our hands brushing against each other. And I wonder—could I have feelings for Theo? I’ve never thought of him like that, but I have to admit he’s surprising me … in a good way.

Just before we reach the rest of our group, I ask the question that has been nagging at the back of my mind since Theo told me about the statuette.

“Why Lady Beatrice? What made Sebastian choose that as a gift for Lucia?”

“Lucia had this … obsession with Lady Beatrice,” Theo reveals. “It started out as an essay she and Sebastian had to write for university, but then she became fixated on her, especially on the myths surrounding her life.”

“What myths?” I ask, my heart rate picking up speed.

But I’m too late. Lady Stanhope spots us outside the library door and gestures for us to join the others. My questions will have to wait.

Despite Lady Stanhope’s best efforts, the dinner is pretty much a disaster. Lord Stanhope arrives in the dining room with the news that Sebastian is nowhere to be found, and his empty place at the table serves as the elephant in the room, resulting in stilted conversation and awkward pauses throughout the meal. When the after-dinner tea service wraps up and the Blythes, the viscount, and his daughter all stand to leave, I finally have my exit opportunity.

“Thank you so much for a lovely dinner,” I say, forcing a smile for the Stanhopes.

“We’re so sorry about what happened earlier,” Lord Stanhope says in a low voice. “My son hasn’t been at all himself since Lucia died.”

“I understand,” I say quickly.

After a sweet goodbye hug from Theo, I hurry into the night, where the Aston Martin is waiting. I can barely carry a conversation with Alfie when he asks about the dinner, my mind racing a hundred miles a minute as I wonder how I will confront Maisie.

Anger floods my veins as I throw open the front doors of Rockford Manor. Where is she?

I search through the numerous rooms of the first floor until I’m out of breath, but she is nowhere to be found. I run back to the Marble Hall, stopping short at the sight of Mrs. Mulgrave slinking down the staircase.

“Where’s your daughter?” I hear myself shout.

Mrs. Mulgrave flinches.

“She set me up!” I fume. “Where is she?”

“What do you mean, she set you up?” Mrs. Mulgrave asks. Her face is illumined by a silver candelabra on the wall, casting her in a ghostly glow.

“She gave me a
gift
for the Stanhopes that turned out to be one of Lucia’s belongings—a present from Sebastian. She made me look like a total bitch, trying to hurt him by reminding him of Lucia. What kind of person does that?” I shake my head in disgust.

Mrs. Mulgrave’s eyes sharpen.

“I don’t believe Maisie meant any harm. I’m quite sure she will have an explanation. And besides, when a man loves the way Sebastian loved Lucia, anything can and will remind him of her. There’s no use hoping he will forget.” Mrs. Mulgrave’s voice takes on the soft, worshipful tone she uses whenever she speaks of Lucia, and tonight it gives me the creeps.

“The only thing I’m
hoping
is that the people I live with won’t stab me in the back. And if that kind of betrayal ever happens again, I’m going to have a serious talk with Oscar,” I warn.

Mrs. Mulgrave doesn’t look the least bit worried on her daughter’s behalf. She simply raises her eyes to the top of the stairs.

“Why don’t you speak to Maisie yourself? The last I saw her, she was going to make up your room.”

“Thanks,” I mutter, before thundering up the stairs.

I fling my bedroom door open, finding Maisie looking like the picture of innocence as she turns down my bed.

“How could you?” I burst out, resisting the urge to throttle her. “How could you do that to me? I trusted you!”

Maisie stands perfectly still, looking at me with doe eyes.

“And don’t play dumb. You said yourself that Lucia told you everything. You knew that stupid figurine was hers. Your plan was obviously to make me look completely evil and ruin the whole night.” I fold my arms across my chest. “So why don’t you tell me to my face why you hate me enough to do that?”

“I don’t hate you,” Maisie says simply. “I did that because I had to. You needed to know.”

“Needed to know what? That Sebastian is still heartbroken over losing Lucia? I figured as much. You didn’t have to hammer the point home and hurt him like that!”

“Not just about that. I needed you to know about Lady Beatrice.”

I throw up my hands in exasperation. “You caused an awful scene just to give me a history lesson about an ancestor from the 1830s? Yeah, right.”

“Listen to me!” Maisie’s voice rises, and I am shocked into silence as she drops her usual deferential manner. “Why do you think Lucia was so obsessed with the legend of Lady Beatrice? What do you think her legend
was
?” Maisie leans in closer to me, until I can feel her cold breath against my ear. “She was rumored to have a
power
—the power to summon the elements with her hands. She could create fire and water and make flowers grow … with nothing but her touch.”

I freeze. This isn’t real. I have to be dreaming this conversation; it can’t be happening.

“That’s just a … a stupid old myth,” I say, my quavering voice giving me away. “Lucia might have believed in it, but I don’t. Lady Beatrice was just some duchess who died ages ago.”

Maisie continues as if she hasn’t heard me. “Lady Beatrice’s husband, the fifth Duke of Wickersham, accused her of sorcery, and she was put to death by hanging. When she was on the gallows, she threatened to return one day … through a descendant.”

I wipe my sweaty palms against my dress.

“This is a very creepy story and all, but I don’t see what—”

“I told you, didn’t I, that Lucia couldn’t keep anything from me?” Maisie stares at me, her eyes unflinching. “She told me about you, Imogen, about what she saw you
do.
”

I feel the ground beneath me sinking. And I’m falling, falling.

“She didn’t know what she was saying,” I whisper.

“If I were you, I would talk to Sebastian Stanhope and find out exactly what he and Lucia discovered about Lady Beatrice at Oxford,” Maisie says. “He might be able to help you in a way that I can’t.” She turns toward the door, then glances back at me. “Will that be all? My mother is waiting for me to help her downstairs.”

How can she stand there so calmly, as if she hasn’t just disrupted my entire world and confirmed the dark suspicions I never wanted to address?

“Why didn’t you just
tell
me all this instead of ruining my dinner with the Stanhopes?” I ask angrily.

Maisie raises her eyes to the ceiling.

“I didn’t have a choice,” she says softly. “I owed her.”

“Owed who?” When she doesn’t respond, I add incredulously, “Lucia?”

Maisie gives the slightest of nods.

“Um, excuse me? Lucia is
dead
.” My voice catches on the word.

Maisie’s face inches closer to mine, her expression suddenly frightened.

“Ghosts never really leave, though, do they?” she whispers. “You feel her here too, don’t you? There may be more to why you came back, Imogen. Never forget that.”

I shudder, both at her words and her overly familiar tone.

“No!” I back away from her. “I have no idea what you’re talking about. Just—just go!”

As soon as Maisie is gone, I lock the door and fling myself onto the bed. My legs are trembling violently, my mind racing with thoughts of ghosts, of what might happen if people find out what I can do.
Am I really just like Lady Beatrice?
Maisie has to be wrong; there can’t be more to my return here. I came back to fulfill my title—wasn’t that supposed to be it?

I can leave tomorrow,
I think, remembering my promise to go home to the Marinos if anything is amiss. But would it even be possible to find peace at home, with this frightening question mark hanging over my head? As much as I dread it, I know I have no choice but to finish what I’ve started.