Authors: Brian Stableford
Tags: #luck, #probability, #gambling, #sci-fi, #science fiction
Alice stared at him, uncomprehendingly. “I didn't go to your father's funeral to pay my respects,” she said, distantly. “All I wanted was to get you on our side so we could move back.”
“Well,
that
certainly wasn't what got Martin killed,” Canny said. “I don't mind. What do you think she should do, P.C. Willis?”
“I think she should stay with her mother for a few days,” the policewoman said, promptly. “It's better than having her mother stay here. You won't be able to keep the reporters and TV cameras from pestering you here. You might not even in Cockayne, but at least your mother's house isn't thirty meters away from a murder scene.”
“We can make sure that the reporters keep a respectful distance in Cockayne,” Canny said, without specifying how. “It's not running away, Alice. It's just the sensible thing to do.”
Alice threw up her hands. “Well, if the lord of the bloody manor says so,” she muttered, in a martyred tone. “I'll go pack.”
CHAPTER TWENTY-ONE
“She doesn't mean it,” Mrs. Proffitt said, when Alice had left the room. “She's upset.”
“Understandably,” Canny said. “Any progress?” he asked P.C. Willis.
“I can't...,” the policewoman began, before Mrs. Proffitt cut her off.
“If you mean have they caught the little bastards, no,” she said. “They will, though. They've got descriptions. They were off their own patch, you see. This isn't Chapeltownâeverybody round here hates Chapeltowners. There'll be witnesses who'll stand up in court. They'll get caughtâthough what the courts will do I shudder to think. Slap on the wrist, I dare say. Probably sue Alice because they got blood on their crowbar.”
Another thing that P.C. Willis couldn't do was rise to that sort of bait, so Canny said: “It doesn't really matter how long they go to jail for, Mrs. Proffitt. It won't bring Martin back.”
“Drug addicts,” Mrs. Proffitt said, as if she were spitting acid. “Murdering little bastards. Ought to be hanged.”
“I understand how you feel,” Canny said, and left it at that. He didn't, though. His own feelings were far less straightforward. He had had not the slightest inkling that the tragedy was about to occur, but that wouldn't have been surprising even if his gift had been at its fullest strength. Even so, he couldn't help wondering whether Martin Ellison's death had had something to do with himâif it had been spun off somehow from the climactic flash of disruption that had accompanied his roulette win. There wasn't the slightest reason for thinking that there could be any connection, however tortuous its logic might be, but that didn't prevent him from wondering. As he had pointed out to Alice, even ordinary people tended to feel guilty when bad things happened around them; people who were supposed to be masters of their own destiny were bound to have an even more exaggerated sense of their own agency. Even if the event had not been connected in any way with the unfolding consequences of that moment in Monte Carlo, there remained the question of whether Canny could have prevented the murder, if only he had cared enough to receive a presentiment of its possibility.
When Alice reappeared clutching an overnight bag P.C. Willis asked Canny where he was parked, and volunteered to walk them to the car.
“It's good of you to do this, sir,” the policewoman murmured, as they moved out into the street and stood to one side while Alice locked up behind them.
“It's no trouble,” Canny said. “I've known the family for a long timeâI grew up with the three sisters. Do you want to come with us?”
“No,” the policewoman said. “I'll come out as soon as we have some newsâI know where Cockayne is. I've been through it.” She repeated this to Alice as Alice was getting into the Citroen's front passenger seat. Canny held the door while Mrs. Proffitt clambered into the back.
As they set off, Alice said: “Ellen put you up to this, didn't she? She asked you to come and get meâjust to show off that she could.”
“Ellen just told me what had happened,” Canny assured her. “She doesn't even know I'm here. She didn't think to ask, and she didn't have to. I told you the truth back there. I do know something of what you must be feeling.”
“Why should you feel guilty about your Dad dying?” she retorted. “He had cancer.”
“I shouldn't,” Canny agreed. “I shouldn't feel guilty about Martin's death, eitherâbut I even feel guilty about that.”
“Why?”
“Because I was mugged a few days ago myself. The mugger surprised me in my hotel room. He had a gun. I just stood there, helpless. There was nothing I could do. He took my money, and he left. He could have shot me, but he didn't. He probably would have, if I'd moved, and he might have anyway, because he was nervous. It was just my good luck that he didn't. I could have been killed, but I wasn't. Martin was. It wasn't his faultâon another day, he'd have blocked the first blow and taken the crowbar off the kid. He didn't do anything wrong. It was just bad luck. It could easily have been the other way aroundâI could have been shot, and he could have grabbed the crowbar and chased the kids away. I feel guilty because I was lucky and he wasn't, and I know just as well as you do how ridiculous that isâbut it's no more ridiculous than you feeling guilty because he's dead and you're alive, and that's what I mean when I say that I understand.”
“You patronizing bastard,” Alice said, contemptuouslyâalthough Canny felt that he'd been more insensitive than patronizing.
“Alice!” Madge Proffitt complained.
Canny paid no heed to the interruption at all. “You see,” he went on, “I can't help thinkingâor feeling, at any rateâthat there might be some kind of weird cosmic balance in which every bit of good luck I have is balanced out by somebody else's bad luckâin this case, Martin's. I'm a lucky Kilcannon, after all. I
expect
to have good luckâand if the universe can do me favors, it seems to stand to reason that it can do other people bad turns, and probably does, by way of compensation. It makes no sense at all, in terms of the calculus of probability, but psychological probability is a very different ball gameâas Martin knew very well.”
“Very clever,” Alice said, bitterly. “You're telling me that Martin would understand how I feel better than I do, just like you do. Well, maybe he wouldâand maybe you do too, having lost your Dad so recently. Doesn't alter anything, does it? At least there's no possibility that the little savage who smashed his head in was his long-lost son, so you don't have to start lecturing me about the fucking Oedipus Effect, do you?”
“Alice!” Mrs. Proffitt complained again, her voice more agonized than before.
Canny drove north through Roundhay instead of picking up the A64, intending to go through Scholes and Barwick-in-Elmet rather than taking the main road. It seemed more fitting, somehow, to take the quieter route.
“I'm not lecturing you, Alice,” he said, feeling that he ought to try to keep the conversation going in spite of the difficulties. “I'm telling you the simple truth. I've always felt guilty about the Kilcannon luck. You grew up in Cockayne, so you know all the stories, the whole rich stock of local legends. You can't tell me you that never heard anyone say that our good luck must be someone else's badâwith an exemplary tale to back up the claim. Don't tell me you never heard anyone say that the family have a pact with the devil.”
“I never believed it,” Alice said, contemptuously.
“Always told the kids that sort of stuff was rubbish,” Madge Proffitt chipped in. “Never tolerated that sort of talk in our house, me or Jem. Ellen won't have it neither.”
“I don't doubt it, Mrs Proffitt,” Canny said. “The point I'm trying to make is that people say those things to express their feelings about the unfair way that good luck and bad luck are distributed within the world. The fact that they aren't true doesn't stop them affecting the way I feelâthe way I've always felt, since I was a kid. Ellen understood that, I thinkâa little. You were telling the truth, weren't you, Alice, when you said she'd never say a word against me, and always defended me if someone else did?”
“Aye,” said Alice. “Just like you were telling the truth when you said she showed you her knickers when you were at the primary.”
It was Canny's turn to murmur “Alice!” as there was an audible intake of breath in the back seat.
“Oh, sorry Mum,” Alice said. After a moment's pause, she added: “You too, Canny. Got carried away. Stupid.”
“It's okay,” Canny said. “My fault.”
“No, it's not,” Alice said, after a slight pause. “It was good of you to come, Canny, even if Ellen did send you. She'd have come herself, if Jack hadn't been playing cricket and she was down to make the teas. If it had been Sunday and all she'd have had to miss was church there'd have been no stopping herâbut
Jack's cricket
is a different matter. Lucky you didn't say yes when he offered you a game, or you'd have been stuck there too. Take a braver man than you to cry off after he'd picked you ahead of someone who can actually play.”
“It's Jack we're talking about,” Canny reminded her. “He'd have been only too pleased to call up the twelfth man in my place. He only invited me out of respect for tradition. Anyway, I was never that bad. My batting average was in the twenties. I was the best snicker in the village. Ask your Ellen.”
The sheer bizarrerie of the last remark teased a wry smile out of Alice's repentant expression.
“We'll probably have won the match by now,” Canny told her, glad to have found a topic that didn't annoy or hurt her. “The other lot weren't making much of a score. Frank Langsgill demolished their batting, although he blotted his scorebook later by dropping a sitter. They probably didn't get a hundredâand we certainly won't have needed to bat all the way down to number eleven to knock those off.”
It was at that point, incongruously enough, that Alice finally broke down and began weeping. Maybe, Canny thought, Jack Ormondroyd had offered Martin a game too. Maybe Martin had been a good player, and had been looking forward to joining the team if and when the Ellisons were able to move to Cockayneâor maybe he was as useless as Canny was, and had had to make his apologies. It seemed more likely, though, that Alice had simply run out of annoyance and resentment, and had nothing left with which to shield her pent-up grief. The car crossed the A64, heading into Scholes.
“I brought his book,” Alice said, eventually, between sobs. “It's in the bag.”
“What book?” Canny said.
“His new book. His book on superstition. I thought you might want to look at it, being interested and all. It's only a rough draft, mind, and not finished.”
“Ah,” Canny said. “That wasn't necessary, Alice. But thanks for the thought.”
“Oh, I didn't
think
,” she said. “I just did it. You wouldn't be here, though, if it weren't for the books, would you? You never gave Lydia's Ken a second glanceâbut as soon as you found out who Martin was, you were promising to get us a houseâand I thought how lucky we were. How absolutely fucking
lucky
.”
Madge Proffitt sighed audibly, but made no other protest regarding her daughter's bad language.
What Alice had said was true enough, Canny knew. If it had been Lydia's Ken who'd been murdered, he wouldn't have driven to Manchester. It
was
because Martin Ellison had been Martin Ellison that he had felt compelled to respond to the news of his death and his widow's distressâand Alice had packed Martin's latest, unfinished book in recognition of that fact, even without thinking.
“Martin was a wise man, Alice,” he said. “I found a lot to admire in his work. I'm sure that we would have been friends. It's a terrible waste of a fine mind. Is there anything more I can do, when we get back?” The car was heading for Aberford now, and the Roman Ridge. They would be within sight of Credesdale very soon.
“No,” said Alice. “I phoned his mother. She'll let his brother and sister know. They all live down southâGloucester and Somerset. Didn't see much of them after we moved to Canterbury, but I suppose they'll want to bury him down there. If we can bury him at all, with him being murdered. Holds thing up, I dare sayâespecially if they don't catch them right away. That policewoman seemed confident, though. Impulsive crime, you seeânot planned. They were seen. Just a matter of time. Nothing to do but wait.”
“Well if you need anything,” Canny said. “Mrs. Proffitt?”
“We'll let you know, Lord Credesdale,” Madge Proffitt said, mechanically. “Thanks.”
“Yes,” said Alice. “Thanks. Sorry about what I said before. Not you I was angry at, really. Stupid.”
“It's fine,” Canny said. “You can insult me any timeâit just bounces off. You must remember that, even though it's been a while.”
“I haven't forgotten,” she said. “Mistake, thoughâonly used to make me try harder.”
“Well, you'll have to try a lot harder now,” he assured her. “The skin's got even thicker over the years. Takes a lot to get under it nowadays. You need someone to take it out on, you know where I am. Better me, maybe, than Ellen or your Mum.”
“I'll remember that,” Alice said, although her voice was devoid of gratitude. “Very kind of you, I'm sure. You must be busy, though, having just inherited the Mill. Not as if you'd spent a lot of time there recently, so I hear.”
“There's a lot to catch up on,” Canny admitted. “Here and in London. But the offer stands. Shall I drop you at home or the chippy?”
“Seven Berridge Street,” Mrs. Proffitt was quick to say, although she must have known that Canny knew where she lived. “Thank you very much, Lord Credesdale.”
“But next time,” Alice said, as the car drew to a halt in Berridge Street and she opened the passenger door, “bring the Bentley, will you?”
“It's not a real Bentley,” Canny told her. “They've been fake ever since Rolls Royce took them over, and now that the Germans have taken over Rolls Royce....”
She didn't want to play, even though she'd started it. Her face had became haggard and drawn again, “Thanks for the lift, Canny,” she said, as mechanically as her mother, before she slammed the door.
“You're welcome,” Canny said, inaudibly, before backing up and driving home.