Renee's High School Reunion (6 page)

Jesse nudged AJ awake, and they slid down, opening Renee’s legs and kissing her inner thighs. She shivered and glanced down at them. Jesse licked her pussy slowly, enjoying that they’d caught her off guard. Renee arched her back and tilted her hips. AJ took a turn tasting her and sliding two fingers into her pussy.

Her moans and juices started.

“Like it?” Jesse asked.

“I had dreams like this in high school. Two guys I trust making me happy. No one else could do this.” Her eyes closed.

Jesse nodded to AJ. She trusted them more than any of her flings. It was different. Jesse licked her inner folds until she rocked for more. Nipping at her clit got Jesse a groan from his woman.

“Fuck me,” she insisted.

“Not this time.” AJ slid up to give her breasts the proper attention.

Jesse agreed. They wanted to watch her come and make sure she knew they could do this for her again and again. Her body was tense with need and yet open to them. Jesse kissed her ankle and tickled the bottom of her foot. Renee smiled and tugged for him to get back to her slit.

Jesse wanted this every morning. Eating her seriously, licking and sucking her cunt, Jesse smiled when she began to shake. Renee screamed their names as her juices flowed and her hips froze in climax. Her face was beautifully content.

After a little more play, Renee left to get ready for the main event. The reunion would be the standard dinner and dancing and catching up. The sex part had kept AJ and Jesse occupied, but Jesse still felt AJ’s tension.

“You okay?” Jesse grabbed some clean underwear from the drawer as AJ pulled their suits from the closet.

“Sure.” AJ went into the bathroom and started the water for a shower.

When he returned, still quiet, Jesse had to say something. “Renee pulled a wild stunt. If you don’t want to go tonight, we can check out and go home. Order in and forget it all.” He kissed AJ’s shoulder.

AJ turned to face Jesse and shook his head. “I’m not running. Jesse, I’ve been out for ten years. It’s not like it’s new.”

“No, but high school isn’t real life. It’s a weird time where your world is small and crazy.

Reunions trigger those old feelings and habits. I saw it at lunch. People fall back into their old patterns, and it can be dangerous. Renee thought she was making a point by opening the door naked, but I think she may have kicked the drama up a notch.”

“It’s Renee, and that’s why we love her. She was wild in high school. Not as a stunt. It’s just her. She let you take the nude pictures of her for your senior project. She was very sexually adventurous then. I’m not running from the reality.” AJ headed in to the bathroom and stepped into the shower.

Jesse joined him, hugging and kissing AJ with a pride and love that after ten years still inspired him. “Thanks.”

“It’s not for you,” AJ said. “It’s for me. I didn’t know in high school. Not until that night.

Maybe I suspected, maybe the bisexual thing made it easy to play it safe and go for girls.”

“Maybe Renee just got to you first.” Jesse rubbed the bar of soap along AJ’s hard abs.

“Maybe.” AJ nodded. “I don’t want Steve and all those guys to think I’m ashamed. What about you? Renee just made your story more confusing.”

“Nah. I was out of the closet in high school. Even if I went bi for you and her, they wouldn’t care. It’s not interesting like the jock who goes for guys now.” He moved the bar of soap lower, lathering AJ’s cock and balls.

“You’re starting something now?” AJ groaned.

“Not a big something. A little relief to help us survive until afterward. I’m going to be in a sharp suit, looking hot, and Renee will be in some slinky number. Remember her prom dress with the tame front and plunging back?”

AJ moaned. “And that thigh-high slit.”

“Some of the other girls looked slutty, but she made it look elegant and tempting.” Jesse rubbed his erection against AJ’s soapy one.

“I don’t know if we can pull this off. She thinks it’s just a weekend of sex. What if she…” AJ trailed off as his hips thrust to Jesse.

“Doesn’t want to settle down?” Jesse filled in. “I get the feeling she’s attached to us. It’s complicated. We didn’t decide overnight.”

AJ’s head thudded against the shower wall. “This is crazy. I’m happy. We’re happy.” All the year they’d been together, Jesse had known that. They trusted each other and had an amazing connection others envied. This was new and different. Both things were scary to a long-term relationship. “It’s okay. If it weren’t Renee, it’d be weird. But she’s got a hold on us both. It’s right, and we’ll be happier with her.”

“Big time,” AJ agreed.

“Don’t sweat it. She’s not married so we’re not doing anything wrong.” Jesse changed the angle of his thrusts and watched AJ’s eyes roll back in his head.

“Fucking a girl isn’t so bad,” AJ joked.

Jesse picked up the pace. “I told you I screwed a girl in high school. I knew I’d like it now. I just wanted the male experience more back then. You have to figure out who you are.

That’s why a three-way relationship wouldn’t have worked then. Now, we’re all adults and have had plenty of reality. Renee will hopefully figure out no one is better for her than us. We just need to keep proving it.”

“You didn’t want me back then.” AJ wrapped his powerful arms around Jesse’s neck and pulled him in for a kiss.

The hell he hadn’t! Jesse had had plenty of football guys in the fantasy bank. Seeing those hard bodies bending over in tight pants. That was good. AJ had always been at the top of the list. Maybe because he’d had Renee and had to be nice to Jesse as the gay guy friend.

Jesse kissed him hard as they ground against each other like high school guys afraid to go all the way. When Jesse felt AJ come, the spasms and jerks sent him over.

Pressing himself fully to AJ’s form, Jesse screamed his lover’s name. Panting, he chuckled. “You know we could stay in bed and make out all night. Let them think of all the dirty things we’re doing up here.”

“No, we’re going. Tonight, you’re going to confess which girl you slept with if I have to guess every girl in our class.” AJ shifted away so they could rinse off.

“What if she’s not in our class?” Jesse didn’t know why AJ was so curious, but Jesse’d avoided the subject for good reason. Maybe tonight was the time. But Jesse didn’t want to blurt it out; he’d find the right time eventually.

Chapter Six

Renee walked around the ballroom decorated for the reunion. She was early, but she needed a little time to think about things. It was so easy with Jesse and AJ. So comfortable and hot. She didn’t want it to end, and it’d only been a one day. Maybe she needed more in her life than she’d thought…she never wanted to be like the women in her family. Divorced or putting up with a bad husband. But with these two guys it didn’t feel as if she were stuck or dependent.

She had to get this out of her head for a little bit. Grabbing a drink, she found Linda.

“You look so great!” Linda hugged her. “Most people went black or red, but that purple and green pattern looks like a watercolor painting with shimmer.” Renee spun happily. Since prom night had gone to hell, it was nice to feel special and know that AJ and Jesse would get along tonight. “I have to wear a uniform for work. When I dress up, I got all the way. So what’s new?”

“Apparently, people are talking. Some thought you’d show up here naked.” Linda smiled.

“Steve, that football player, is saying you answered the door…”

“I did.” Renee stood a little straighter.

“And there were two men in the bed?” Linda’s voice went higher to nearly a squeak.

“AJ and Jesse. They’ve made this reunion memorable.” Renee never doubted that the rumor mill would work as quickly high school gossip had—even faster, now that there was texting. She wasn’t ashamed, in fact it felt oddly right. Maybe it took two men to handle her?

Renee had never been content with what others seemed to want. Unconventional appealed her.

“You really? With two men?”

“Two.”

“And they’re a couple? AJ is gay?” She frowned. “I don’t get that.”

“Well, he’s bisexual. Both of them are. You know about me and Jesse.” Renee had confided in a few friends. Jesse was her first love but needed to explore men. High school heartbreak hadn’t totally missed her, but she understood.

Linda nodded. “Your first time. Experimentation happens, but he clearly went toward men after that, at least in high school. Those two did talk, fight and leave together after prom. I figured coach made AJ shake hands and be nice for the team’s image. Sounds like Jesse was more persuasive.”

“Well no hard feelings. They have a solid foundation and amazing relationship. I think I’m just a guest star in the fantasy of some hot high school flashbacks. So, don’t let the rumors go crazy. Not that I care, but AJ has to deal with the outing crap.” Linda gripped her glass of champagne. “Poor AJ. The football team won’t make it easy.

People fall right back into bad habits some times.”

“Exactly. So, spread good stuff.” Renee took in the standard decorations and ignored the fire building in her. She wanted to protect AJ and Jesse, to make it better somehow, but she’d done enough with the door stunt. They hadn’t exactly made any comments about getting serious with her. Renee couldn’t get her hopes up. “Let’s talk about more interesting things. Any hot new professors at UNLV?”

Linda shrugged. “I’m not like you, Renee. It’s not like me to look or act sexy and aggressive. My nickname in high school was bookworm.”

“Don’t let others define you,” Renee said.

“No, but it wasn’t wrong. It bothered me in high school, but it was true. I loved my books and history. The teasing could’ve been worse, like about how I developed so late. I was so skinny everyone thought I had an eating disorder. ” Linda adjusted her glasses. “I know you’re right. You can’t let others define you. I defined myself with the books and my afterschool job in the library. I wasn’t into fashion; my mom couldn’t afford it. If you hadn’t lent me that dress and gotten Jesse to take me as a friend, I’d never have gotten to prom. It was great just to go.”

“My pleasure. Jesse’s mom was on his case to go and gave him the cash for it. But, he didn’t have a boyfriend at the time. Everyone needs to have a prom night to remember.” Renee laughed.

“As friends, yes. I had fun. Poor you. AJ and Jesse fighting. You lost your boyfriend and your best friend in one night.” Linda shook her head. “I’m sorry. Why are we wallowing? I think reunions are like time machines, warp speed right back.”

“You’re right. But with AJ and Jesse, I only remembered the good times. Watching them fool around made it hard to think at all.”

“Wow. The stuff that happens to you. I wouldn’t have a clue what to do—panic and freeze up probably.” Linda waved off the idea. “Thankfully, it’ll never happen to me.”

“Don’t say that. You’re pretty and filled out. You just need to loosen up,” Renee encouraged.

“That’s not me.” Linda shifted in her heels. Her black and white dress went to the floor and her shoulders were covered with a wrap. The neckline revealed nothing.

“You could pass through an Amish community in that dress.”

“No, stop.” Linda let the wrap fall off her shoulders. The straps were thin, and the empire waist hinted at her figure.

“But you hold that wrap around you like a mummy, and no one can see what you’ve got.” Renee adjusted the wrap to highlight her long neck and sleek figure.

“Thanks, I’m not good at this stuff, but I’m getting out there. I signed up for a conference for the historical society.”

“Hold me back. You’re on the edge,” Renee deadpanned. “How about a singles cruise or a weekend in Reno?”

“The topic is the Marquis de Sade and his influence on modern society’s development,” Linda whispered.

Renee was impressed. “I knew you had a naughty side. Maybe, you’ll find a rough history buff to spank it loose.”

She turned bright red. “Renee!”

“Hey, it’s an educational experiment. Call it research.” Renee spotted the guys as they headed over. “I want a full report when you get back. Details!”

“Ladies,” Jesse said.

“Hi.” Linda waved.

“You found me.” Renee smiled.

“We’ve got a table. Let’s get you another drink.” AJ offered his arm. “Care to join us, Linda?”

“No, I’m good. I need to catch up with the literary group.” Linda headed off.

Crossing the room on the arms of two gorgeous men, Renee felt like a princess. She settled at the table with AJ and Jesse. “Everything okay?” she asked.

“Great. Rumors are flying. It’ll be fun.” AJ smiled weakly.

Renee put her hand on his knee. She knew it wouldn’t be easy. Jesse had come out on his own in high school, but that was tough. “It’ll be over tomorrow. You can handle it, and we’re right here for you.”

A few of the big names stepped up to the microphone, and Renee tensed when she saw Steve up there. As the crowd ate their salads, the awards were announced. Most successful. Most famous. Most kids. Who moved farthest. It went on and on.

Steve stepped up. “Most unchanged. This was hard. Most changed was harder until we all talked after lunch. Now, it’s a slam dunk.” Steve grinned at their table. “Most unchanged is the wild and passionate Renee Carlson”

“Oh hell,” Jesse said softly.

“Don’t go.” AJ grabbed her hand.

“Of course, I’m going. Don’t let them get to you.” She kissed Jesse and AJ before she headed to the stage, waving at Linda and other friends.

She took a small cheap statue from Steve. “Thank you. I’m a little changed. I’m a pilot so I travel a lot more. I live in Los Angeles now. But I’d like to think I’m as good as ever. No reason to change.”

“Mile high club!” someone shouted from the crowd.

“What a layover,” another person chimed in.

A flicker of annoyance tugged at her. They were jealous. She looked at AJ and Jesse and knew there was nothing wrong with what they were doing. It felt so right she never wanted it to end. Even if everyone found out. She smiled brightly at her men. “You don’t know the half of it.” Renee walked off the stage and rejoined her table. AJ held her hand under the table, and she gave it a squeeze.