Is Three A Crowd? (21 page)

“I say we give her an opportunity to get to know us both again. We always said the one she didn’t choose would walk away. I can’t stand not knowing where my future lies and if it’s with her or not. If she’s going to leave me, then I have to let her go and find some kind of new situation.”

“I know I censor every word, afraid I’ll say the wrong thing.” Nathan strode towards the kitchen and started to make coffee. He glanced up and saw Blake in the doorway. “What?”

“We’ve done it before, I could do it again. Long term, if it meant keeping Maris with us.”

“With us? Don’t you want her all to yourself?” Nathan finished spooning coffee into the filter and put the canister aside. “I mean, hell, I guess I have to admit some of her time is better than none. But I always assumed we’d have a conventional relationship.”

“We’re talking about Maris. She’s never been conventional. Hell, that was part of her appeal. She was a free spirit, willing to experiment, willing to be different among the masses. Quite honestly, I don’t want ordinary any longer. If I did, I’d have had relationships in the last years. Women I’ve met are just ordinary.”

“I agree. I never met any woman like her. Did you ever imagine before meeting her that you’d share a woman with another man?”
 

“Honestly,” Blake hesitated, “no. Especially with you after she first introduced us. Just the idea of you grated on my being, meeting you was like being taunted with my successor. But what were our options? We both knew years ago it took both of us to satisfy her.”

“We surely managed to do that, but unfortunately we couldn’t keep her safe.”

“If she’d told one of us of her plans that day, we might have.” Blake stretched to his full height in the doorway. “We can’t go back. I can’t stand the limbo. She’s starting to remember her history. I’m afraid if we wait too long, she’ll revert to the personality her mother instilled after the accident.”

“She’s just starting to smile like she used to. But,” Nathan paused, “none of us is the same person anymore.”

“Look, we’ve forged this truce because of her, our business is because of her. Hell, we even refurbished that old monstrosity of a house because we knew how much she loved it. I say it’s time to show her how we can love her.”

“You’re saying initiate a sexual situation and see who she chooses?”

“I’m saying I’d rather share her with you than wonder who would be next if we fuck this up.” Blake grinned.

“In the last days I’ve noticed how her speech has reverted. She’s much freer around us, as if she’s let her guard down.”

“Or as if she’s finally getting comfortable with the woman she became. We all know she won’t go back to the Maris we knew before, but I’d like to experience the woman she’s become, beyond her mother’s influence. And it’s apparent she wasn’t happy with that lifestyle. Why not let her know the possibilities. If she rejects us, we’ll take a step back. But…”

“But?” Nathan prompted.

“But if we don’t take a step, she may never find that piece of her personality that let her experience us, together or individually.”

“So do we plan some romantic night or what?”

“Hell, my cock is so hard right now, why not offer her an early morning encounter? She’ll be sleepy, maybe she won’t think, maybe she’ll just react. I say it’s worth a try.”

“I suppose it can’t be worse than the ache I’ve carried all these years. What do you have in mind?”

“Let’s just go present her with our morning erections and see how she reacts. If it’s badly, we’ll know.” Blake laughed, but it was a guarded laugh.

“I never thought I’d agree to both of us being in bed with her again. I so wanted her for myself.”

“But that may not happen now.” Blake’s statement was too true to refute.

“You’re right. I hate to admit it, but you are. All right, I’ll give it one shot and let her decide. Hell, I’m sick of jacking off every morning and night to her memory. Let’s just approach her and see what happens.”

“Fine, but with one caveat. If we do this, it might be permanent. If she decides she wants us both, can you live with that?” Blake stared at Nathan.

“If I have to share her, better with you than another man.” Nathan shook his head. “I can’t believe we’re contemplating doing this again. But I can’t see any other way.”

“Come on,” Blake said, “my cock is strangling in these jeans.”

“Just remember this was your idea.”

“Yes, Nathan. If it goes horribly wrong, I’ll take the blame.”

“If I’m beside you, I have to accept the blame, too.”

“Then let’s just go upstairs and see what happens?” Blake turned and walked away. Nathan stood for several seconds before following, his cock twitching in his pants, deciding for him.

Chapter Seventeen

Maris woke to find both her men standing beside her bed, naked. It was early morning, the sun just peeking through the trees and invading her room.

“Are you real or a memory?” she questioned, sitting forward and pushing her hair from her face.

“We’re real,” Nathan said, using his left hand to tug his already erect cock.

“Question is,” Blake said, reaching to the middle of the bed where she’d tossed the used toy, “Are you interested?” He took the toy to his lips and licked her dried juices from it. “Do you want us to leave?” His other hand stroked his cock, a drop of pre-cum at his tip.

“I’m not sure what I’m supposed to do, but I know what I want this very moment.” Maris leaned forward, letting the blanket fall from her body, and took the toy from Blake. She saw his questioning expression and pushed it gently into her pussy. She shook her hips until she found her spot and rolled onto her belly, reaching to both men. “Come where I can reach you,” she prompted. Each man took a step forward and she immediately grasped each erection.

“God help us all,” Nathan uttered as the tip of her tongue teased him.

“There’s enough people in the room,” she’d said while reaching to take Blake’s erection to her lips. She licked the droplet of pre-cum and took the whole head between her lips, teasing the underneath with her tongue. Back and forth, she went between them, relaxing into the act, enjoying the power she held over their releases. With all the memories that were fading back to her weary mind, this would be a new one to cherish. One side of her wanted to tell them to go away, that she didn’t do things like this. Hell, she didn’t even have sex with one man in the last few years. However, with them standing before her, erections in hand, nude bodies within reach, she didn’t ignore the stirring in her belly. Already she’d gone too far. The dildo inside her shifted each time she took the other man’s cock to her lips. There was no turning back. Her body wanted the release she knew they would bring her. And why not? They were all willing adults with the same needs.

Settling further onto the dildo, she let her mind clear, keeping only her men’s enjoyment forward. What happened later would happen, but for now she just wanted to feel. Continuing to lavish each cock with affection, she was relearning their body’s reactions, how Nathan’s cock would twitch between her lips when she used a bit of her teeth to tease him on an outward pull. How Blake’s cock surged when she teased the underneath of his rim with her tongue.

“Maris, I’ll come soon,” Blake told her, his voice hesitant.

“I don’t want this to end so quickly,” Nathan added.

“It doesn’t have to,” she said switching to the other man. “I can’t believe I’m doing this, sucking both of you and humping the mattress to move the dildo inside me.”

“I can fix that. Let me fuck you.” Blake said the words hesitantly. Nathan cleared his throat but didn’t interject with words.

“I’d rather you both come on my breasts and suck them clean. Can you make me come that way? Does either of you have a problem with that?”

Nathan shook his head no, and Blake only gave her his sexy smile. Maris rolled onto her back and centered herself on the bed. She tugged each man by their cocks, Nathan kneeled beside her chest while Blake climbed over her, pausing only for a second to rub his erection against her clit before taking the same position on her other side. With a hand on each man, she pumped their cocks until they came on her breasts. Nathan came first, spraying on her chest and belly. Blake came only moments later, adding his cum. Without prompting, both men moved to lie beside her, each taking a breast to their lips.

Maris figured she’d never have this opportunity again and decided she wouldn’t waste this time. She rocked her pelvis up and down to shift the toy while the men sucked her nipples and licked their cum off her. With a hand behind each man’s head, she drew first Nathan, than Blake to kiss her mouth.

“I’m so close,” she whispered. Nathan reached between her legs and lightly stroked her clit. That was the last instant she remembered before the pinpoint lights filled her closed eyelids, forming a kaleidoscope of colors and patterns. “Oh, my,” she managed, letting the orgasm linger as long as possible. Nathan still stroked her clit but paused to pull the toy from her. Tossing it aside, he slid first one, then a second finger in her wet pussy, prompting her to begin again. Not to be left out, Blake lowered his head and licked at her clit while Nathan fingered her. She took her breasts in her hands and pushed them together, pinching her nipples harder than the men had. In a moment of clarity, she paused and put her hand on the back of Blake’s neck, prompting him to continue.

“Both of you, lie down.” She squirmed out from them, hesitant to move Nathan’s fingers from her. She stood by the side of the bed while they followed her request. Lying naked side by side, she leaned over them and repeated her earlier loving. Sucking each man in turn between her lips until they were hard, she wanted to feel them inside her. Maris paused, realizing she didn’t have any protection. Her words tumbled out before she thought to stop them. “I’d fuck you both, but I don’t have any condoms.”

Maris looked down at the two men, both eager and ready to please her. Her nudity before them wasn’t a factor. Maybe she was finding her true self again. Hell, all she could remember after the accident was being staid and virtuous. She hated her yearly physical when her doctor would touch her intimately. Even with a nurse in the room, it still seemed lewd to her. Now she stood before two men and openly wanted them to touch her, wanted them to do all the sexual things she’d shut out of her life.

In unison, both men said, “I do,” which made her laugh. Breaking the moment of uncomfortable memories, she left them, going to the piles of clothing. One pile, Nathan’s she knew, was draped over the back of a chair by the fireplace. Blake’s clothes were in a heap in the middle of the room. Reaching his first, she found his pants and drew out his wallet. Flipping it open, she found two condoms and took them both, tossing the leather back to the floor with his clothing. Returning to the bed, she crawled in between the men, reaching a hand to each erection.

“Handle these,” she said, and each man grabbed his own cock. With little procedure, she sheathed each man and sat back on her heels. “I feel like I’ve been here before,” she mused, moving to straddle Nathan’s erection. Maris let herself slowly slide down over him, relishing the feel of him stretching her pussy to accommodate him. She fucked him only a few moments before moving off and straddling Blake. His cock was a bit smaller, but just as thick.

Maris used her weight to push her pussy over his cock, straining to the side to pump Nathan’s. When she moved back to his cock, she pumped Blake’s. Back and forth she went, stroking and fucking both men at her whim. While she fucked Nathan, Blake fisted his cock and sat forward to suck her tit. When she fucked Blake, Nathan reached over and kissed her mouth, sucking her tongue between his lips with the same rhythm she ground against Blake.

Maris knew she would come soon but didn’t want to stop. When she realized both men were straining to hold back, she moved between them, kneeling near their cocks.

“Come on my pussy and lick me clean,” she said, somewhat hesitant of her own words or wants.

“Lie down,” Nathan told her as he moved to kneel beside her. Blake wasted no time and did the same. Maris waited as each man tugged off the condoms. With a cock in each hand, she manipulated them until they came. Blake came first, his load landing on her lower belly and pussy. Nathan came with a few tugs, his cum spraying on her thighs and pussy. Maris dropped their cocks and relaxed back on the bed. Her men didn’t need prompting. They both maneuvered so their heads were near her crotch. They took turns licking her clean and teasing her clit. Again her own fingers tugged on her breasts, pinching her nipples to just the point of pain until she came. Nathan used his cum to moisten his fingers and slid one in her pussy. She lifted her hips and he slid a second one beside it. Blake reached to fondle her breast, his fingers lightly pinching her nipple. Back and forth the men went, in an unspoken arrangement. One would lick her for a few strokes, then the other would. It seemed to Maris they’d done this before, but she had no memory. She came while Nathan sucked her tit and fingered her pussy. Blake was sucking her clit between his teeth, tugging harder until the orgasm passed. When she lay limp between them, they finally stopped their movements.