Impulse (3 page)

“Al was right; he got me so mad I was ready to kill him. Instead I boned up on Freddy, read everything we had in the library, then went to see Mr. Pithoe. He didn’t want to talk at first. Sullen and blank-faced. It took me ten minutes just to get five words out of him. Tomorrow I’ll try my little-sister approach. That might make him respond better. I sure hope so. I can’t count on more than two visits to him.”

“I still don’t like you dealing with the dregs of humanity.”

She poured herself some coffee. It brought patience. “We’re both reporters. We deal with all kinds of dregs, including the newsroom coffee. You deal with politicians—can you get more dicey than that?”

“At least they can all read and write.”

“Which makes them all the more dangerous.”

“What did the man say?”

Aha, he wanted all the dirt, the hypocrite. “I’m keeping it under wraps right now. I have to, even with you. It’s the way Al wants it.”

Rafaella could tell that Gene was put off by her tonight. She wanted to laugh. He’d winced when she said “damn” earlier. She also realized at that moment that she usually tended to censor herself when she was with him. She looked at him now, saw the expression of dissatisfaction that marred his mouth. She was beginning to think she’d been wrong about him. He wasn’t an intellectual, just a bore and a chauvinist.

Thank goodness she hadn’t gone to bed with him. He probably would have been mortified in the morning and accused her of having compromised him. That
made her smile, and she thought of the message taped on the wall in the
Trib
’s women’s room:
BE THE VIRGIN OF THE MONTH. STAY HEALTHY
.

She was still smiling as she said, “You’re right, Gene. Tomorrow’s an early day.” She rose and walked to the front closet, hoping he’d follow. He did. She helped him on with his fur-lined Burberry and stepped back. He looked at her for a moment, then said good night and left.

No good-night kiss for her. This was probably the end of the line with Gene Mallory. No big loss when you got right down to it, for either of them.

Rafaella methodically locked the door, slid home the dead bolt, and fastened the two chain locks. It was very likely unnecessary having all this paraphernalia in Brammerton, Massachusetts, but she was a single woman living alone. She walked into her living room, furnished with an eclectic collection of Nouveau Goodwill, as her mother fondly referred to her trappings, and went to the large bay window. It was quiet outside; snow covered the street and glistened under the streetlamps.

It was always quiet here in Brammerton. A small town some twenty miles southeast of Boston, near Braintree, Brammerton used to be wildly blue collar. Now it was next to nothing, the paper mill having closed its doors in the late eighties and moved elsewhere. There weren’t even companionable drunks out singing at the tops of their lungs on Saturday nights. It wasn’t a bit like Boston. There wasn’t a single university within Brammerton’s city limits, nor had there ever been one. It was a town filling up with retired people and social-security checks.

Rafaella shut off all the lights and went to bed. It was her favorite thinking time, those fifteen or so minutes before falling asleep. If she had a problem, she’d set it up before she went to sleep, fully expecting a
solution to appear the following morning. Solutions frequently did appear.

She didn’t spare any more time for Gene Mallory.

All her thoughts focused on Freddy Pithoe and what he hadn’t said to her that morning. It could be that Al’s nose was right again, because now her gut was twisting in that weird way when things weren’t actually as they were thought to be. She’d carefully read the police report and the three shrinks’ reports. She’d also forced herself to go through the coroner’s report and the crime-lab pictures taken of the three dead family members. She thought of those now. Of the information in them, and more important, of the information not in them.

And again and again she found herself coming back to one thing: Why had Freddy axed his family? Rage? Come on, everybody got enraged once in a while. Just working with Al Holbein got her enraged, but it had never occurred to her to take an ax to him. There had to be a reason. Another thing: Where was Joey Pithoe, Freddy’s little brother? There had been speculation that the boy had seen the carnage and fled for his life. He would turn up, the police thought, soon enough. Poor kid. What chance would he have? They were trying to find the boy, but they weren’t really trying all that hard.

They had their psychopathic killer. Who cared about a kid?

Rafaella did. Because there was more to it than just Freddy buying that ax and doing in his family. Why such mutilation on the mother and the uncle? Sure enough, the near decapitation of the father was gruesome, but it was only one blow. Not multiple cuts like the other two. Rafaella fell asleep at last. Her dreams were quite pleasant but there was a recurrent theme of a boy, lost and frightened and—something else, something vague, something churning in her gut.

Rafaella was at the jail the following morning. Sergeant
Haggerty, a hard-nosed old cop who had been on the force for nearly thirty years, just gave her a bored smile and said she could spend the rest of her life talking to the crazy scum, he didn’t care. But, yeah, he wouldn’t say a word to nobody. She knew he did care, but Lieutenant Masterson had been good to his word—but for just this visit and that would be it.

Rafaella was sitting in the interview room on the other side of the wire cooping. It was not a dirty room, just depressing, with the peeling light green paint and the institutional chairs. There wasn’t a phone system here, just the wire screen separating prisoners from their visitors. Freddy Pithoe was gently shoved into the room by a blank-faced young guard who’d already seen too much and wanted to protect himself from seeing any more.

She studied Freddy as she had before. He was the most pathetic young man she’d ever seen in her life. He wasn’t scum; he was frightened and nearly over the edge with what was happening to him.

And in ten minutes she got him to talk, at least a bit.

He’d bought the ax at his father’s request, he told her. This was familiar ground to him.

“But, Mr. Pithoe, didn’t you tell the police that?” she asked, trying to keep her voice calm and pitched low; her eyes never wavering from his face.

“Yes, ma’am, but they said I was a fucking liar and crazy. I told ’em again and again, but it didn’t matter. They said I was a crazy fucking liar.”

“Did your father tell you why he wanted you to buy the ax?”

Freddy just looked at her, his brow puckering, nearly drawing his thick dark eyebrows together over the bridge of his nose. “I don’t know, ma’am. He just told me to buy it. That’s all, I swear.” Then Freddy Pithoe said something Rafaella hadn’t expected in a
million years. “He said he’d beat my fucking head in if I didn’t buy the ax.”

Rafaella felt a tingling along her backbone, and her gut was playing the marimba. She had to tread carefully now. “You know, Mr. Pithoe—do you mind if I call you Freddy?—you can call me Rafaella—you need to see a doctor. Your left eye is red and kind of weepy. Did he ever actually beat you?”

“Who?”

Easy now, Rafe, easy. “Your father. Did he beat you?”

Freddy nodded, his expression stolid. “Since I was a little kid. It weren’t just me, though. It was Mama and my little brother. Pa called Joey a bastard and said he was gonna beat the shit out of him. He did, all the time.”

“You should have told this to the police.”

Freddy gave her a puzzled look. “Why would they want to know about that? Everybody beats everybody. They wouldn’t care.”

“What about your lawyer, Mr. Dexter?”

“Mr. Dexter just said I was to keep my mouth shut and don’t worry because I was crazy—for about ten minutes I was crazy, he said—something like that.”

Freddy Pithoe, twenty-three years old, didn’t look particularly intelligent with his small dark eyes and the coarse dark hair. Nor did he look particularly crazy. His complexion was unnaturally pale, his shoulders slumped, making him appear much shorter than his six feet. He’d tried to grow a beard to cover his receding chin. It just made it look worse because it was so splotchy. He was a mess, no doubt about that. An abused mess. And he was telling her the truth. He did need to see a doctor about that eye.

“Did you ever go to a doctor, Mr. Pithoe—?”

“You can call me Freddy.”

“Thank you. Did you ever see a doctor after your father beat you?”

“Oh, no, ma’am. He said I weren’t worth it. Once when Uncle Kipper let me have it, he broke my arm, but Pa just bound it up and told me to shut up. It was just Mama who had to go and—”

“Do you remember which hospital, Freddy? How long ago was it?”

“Yes, ma’am. It were that general place, the emergency room.”

Mass General. Excellent. Why had none of this come out before?
Because everyone thinks he’s a fucking liar, that’s why.

“Didn’t the psychologists ask you about this, Freddy?”

“Yes, ma’am, but I didn’t tell ’em that Pa beat any of us.”

“But why not?”

“It was just one of their questions on this long sheet of paper. They wanted to know what it really felt like to sink that ax in my pa’s neck, and if my mom pleaded with me not to kill her.”

Rafaella gagged.

“I didn’t like any of ’em. One reminded me of Uncle Kipper.”

Rafaella had the vagrant thought that if she vomited in this holding room, no one could tell, it would all blend in. She looked closely at Freddy. Such a mess.

“When did your ma go to the hospital, Freddy?”

He looked blank for about a minute, then said very carefully, “Fourteen months ago, ma’am. She was hurting real bad. Pa told ’em her name was Milly Mooth. He thought that was real funny.”

“Did you ax your father to death?”

“Yeah, sure I did, and the others too.”

Rafaella leaned close to him. “I think you’re a fucking liar now, Freddy.”

He stared at her, drawing back. “I ain’t no fucking liar, ma’am, I ain’t!”

She’d just said the words, not really thinking about
them. They’d just come out, and now there was this look in his eyes. She said more firmly, “Yes you are. Tell me the truth, Freddy. All of it.”

He refused to say anything else. He screamed for the guard, nearly tumbling off his chair. And he was rubbing frantically at his eye. Oh, damn. Had she blown it?

“I’ll see you tomorrow, Freddy,” she called after him. “I’ll tell them you need a doctor for that eye.”

The words had doubtless come straight from her marimba-rhythm gut. Of course he’d axed his family. Hadn’t he? She found herself shaking her head. Rafaella rose quickly, wanting only to get out of this miserable room. Gut was one thing; investigation proved it or disproved it, and grunt work. Lots and lots of grunt work. And she’d have to see Freddy again. How to get Lieutenant Masterson to approve one more visit? She’d have to. She had no choice now.

Her next stop was Mass General Hospital, the records room. The trick about getting to patients’ records was to wear a white coat, hang a stethoscope around your neck, and act as confident as the chief of staff. She’d done it before, twice, and it had worked both times. The clerks were overworked, didn’t think to question someone who looked like he belonged. Rafaella waited until the two records clerks on duty were dealing with at least half a dozen demands before she walked in and made her own demand. No problem.

There was only one page of doctor’s notes. What was attached was a Polaroid picture of Mrs. Pithoe, aka Milly Mooth, looking like a prisoner of war. She looked old and bent and so weary her obvious pain wasn’t all that obvious. Rafaella quickly read the notes.
Mrs. Mooth accepted treatment but refused admittance. Was discharged AMA.
Against medical advice. No apparent internal injuries. Two broken ribs, one broken arm, multiple contusions, face swollen with bruises, and cuts requiring twenty-one stitches.

Why had Freddy axed her? And so viciously? She was every bit as much a victim as her son.

Something was missing. A whole lot of something.

Was she wrong? Was she putting too much faith in her gut? No, it was Freddy’s reaction, his eyes, that tipped her off.

She’d know soon enough. She didn’t need to see Freddy’s lawyer. That poor guy didn’t know a damned thing, for the simple reason that Freddy hadn’t talked to him.

She needed to interview neighbors. Something the police had already done, but they hadn’t gotten everything. She was sure of it.

Which brought up another question. Al Holbein never gave an assignment like this unless he had a very good reason—or had heard something that made him wonder—or had been told something no one else knew.

He had something. And he hadn’t told her what it was.

Rafaella went home and dressed carefully for her trip to the North End. The name Pithoe wasn’t remotely Italian, and she wondered why they lived there. An hour later she was walking past Paul Revere’s house. She walked three blocks down Hanover Street, wishing she could take time to buy fresh fruit and vegetables sold in the outdoor stalls. Even in February, the food looked more appetizing than her supermarket. She passed the Caffè Pompeii, one of her favorite Italian restaurants. Up another block was Nathan Street. The Pithoe neighborhood was another block west. It was blue-collar, clean, but with that slightly ragged appearance, like a frayed collar on a once nice shirt.

She looked like a bouncy college kid—the Boston University look—in not-too-tight jeans and a blue turtleneck under a western shirt. She wore a down vest and low-heeled black boots. Imp boots, Al called
them. She’d perfected her approach on three neighbors by the time she reached 379 Prosper Street, a narrow brownstone with a small square front yard buried in at least a foot of dirty snow. Its backyard backed up to the Pithoes’. The fences between the two backyards was wood and rotting.

And it was from Mrs. Roselli, a tiny wrinkled grandmother who’d been born in Milano and spent most of her time in her second-floor bedroom looking out her window toward the Pithoes’, that Rafaella learned some very interesting things.