Heidi (I Dare You Book 1) (4 page)

“Fuck yes!” he hissed, flexing his hips out of habit. “Like that, Heidi. Oh shit, yeah…” He couldn’t stop himself from watching her as he began to take over, fucking her mouth. So close to completion, yet trying his hardest to hold back, she felt so damn good around him.

This isn’t the way he’d planned on starting them off. He had imagined a slow seduction, while he teased, tasted, and worshiped her body for hours. It had been a while for her, after all, and it was nothing short of what she deserved. But when she’d pushed him against the wall showing an aggressive side, he’d been so turned on that nothing mattered other than her pursuit on his dick. One thing was for sure: she knew her way around a blowjob, which was a definite plus for the both of them.

Nathan moaned again as she worked his balls, massaging them. His hips began to pump faster, while his fingers tangled in her hair, and he finally got his voice back. “That’s right, baby, take my cock and love it. Your mouth feels so fucking good. I’m going to come, Heidi. I’m going to come, and if you want me to eat and fuck that pussy, you’re going to suck every last drop of it from me. Milk me, baby.”

Nathan watched her expression and groaned again when he saw the lust displayed there. Her eyes sparkled and she moaned back while he talked dirty to her. The vibration of it took him over as his orgasm rushed through him, and she did what she was told by taking every last drop without hesitation when it hit the back of her throat.

****

Heidi licked her lips clean and smiled up at him. “Damn, Nathan, I love it when you talk dirty to me. That was so much fun.”

“Fun,” he growled, and helped her to stand. She stood in front of him now, smiling widely. “Oh, honey, the fun has only just started. It’s your turn now.”

Heidi watched as he slowly and seductively began to rid her of her clothing. Her shirt was the first to go, before he pulled her close and planted a kiss on her like he was a starving man hell-bent on maintaining sustenance. He unhooked her bra and discarded the lacy scrap. She writhed when he lowered his head to taste her achingly erect nipples and gasped the moment he bent down to cup her knees so she’d wrap her legs around his waist. He carried her as far as the kitchen table because it happened to be closest and laid her on top of it.

“You’ve served me many delicious things at this table, and I can’t wait to taste what you have to offer me tonight.” His eyes sparkled as he leaned down and placed his hands on either side of her head.

His mouth hovered just above hers, and she couldn’t wait any longer. She nipped at his bottom lip and thrust her hips toward his semi-erect cock with need. “Nathan, please,” she whispered.

“You’re beautiful when you’re aroused,” he said. “I wonder what you’d look like when you’re screaming out in ecstasy. When I saw you the other night, it was dark.” His tongue swirled around her lips and trailed over to her earlobe. “I intend to find out, my beautiful Heidi, if you taste as good as you look.”

“Shut up and do it already!” She tugged on his hair to bring him back to her for a kiss, and it made him chuckle.

“And, she’s an impatient one I see.”

“No, I just never knew you were such a tease. I’ll remember that the next time.” She returned his chuckle with a wicked smile of her own and closed her eyes when he began to touch her again.

“Oh, I intend to follow through, sweetheart. I just want to prolong your pleasure as much as I can.” He stood to discard her thong underwear and smiled when he saw how soaked they were.

She laughed at herself before spreading wider. She knew how soaked her pussy was and could only imagine what her glistening lips looked like displayed before him, shiny and achingly in need of him to finish her off. “I bet.”

Nathan dropped to his knees, and her breath hitched when his fingers finally slid inside of her. They moaned at the same time. “Damn, Heidi, you have such a nice pussy.” His tongue circled her clit, and she arched so high she almost fell off the table.

“Shit, Nathan, you feel so fucking good. Don’t stop. Please don’t stop.” She bit her lip to keep from crying out as her hot, wet pussy met cool air when he chuckled again.

Nathan took his time sliding through her folds with his tongue. He savored her before stroking his tongue in and out as he fucked her with his mouth. She moaned again and then huffed as she reached out for him. Threading her fingers through his thick dark hair, she gave it a little tug to guide him where she needed him most. His tongue felt so much better than her fingers; he was sinfully delicious in every way. He obliged her silent demand, and the tip of his tongue worked with confident strokes to give her just what she needed to come for him. Heidi rocked her hips and cried out. Her release was so powerful it ended up all over his face and a part of the floor.

She cupped her breasts and tweaked her nipples, only opening her eyes again as the rush subsided to meet his lust-filled gaze as he watched her play with herself yet again.

“You’re so fucking sexy.”

“So are you. Is it bad I want to taste you again?” She licked her lips. “And I love that you’re ready for me again so soon.”

“Oh no, sweetheart, it’s not bad at all.” He smirked and held out a condom so she could put it on him. “There will be plenty of time for that later. Right now, I want to fuck that pretty pussy hard and fast and make you come for the second time.”

“Please.” She nodded. “I want to feel you too, Nathan. Oh God, yes…”

His tip hit her opening, and he stilled momentarily to smile at her again before entering in one smooth stroke to the root.

“So much better than my fantasies,” she whispered.

Nathan groaned. “And so much better than mine, sweetheart. You’re tight and you feel like heaven, Heidi. I could fuck you silly and still not get enough.”

Nathan captured her mouth in a heated kiss as she met him thrust for thrust while he did exactly what he promised and then some.

It was a complete dream come true.

Chapter Two

“It’s been amazing. Sorry, Meagan.” Heidi laughed. She’d been on cloud nine since her first night with Nathan, and it got better and better every day.

“At least we know your pocketbook is safe.” Zoey pouted. “Why’d you make my dare so challenging? I have no idea how to go about hooking up with two people. I’m intrigued, mind you, but I’m still in this, dare incomplete.”

“So far, but it’ll happen.” Heidi tried to encourage her. “If you ask me, our little pact has been one of the best decisions we’ve ever made.

“Yeah, yeah.” Meagan snorted. “I’ll reserve judgment on that for later.” She took a sip of her drink. They were on their weekly girls’ night out for an update at this cute little pub two blocks from where Heidi lived, sharing appetizers.

“No success with Professor Hottie, then?” Zoey asked.

“Nope.” Meagan slouched. “I’m sure he’s interested, but I’m not used to making the first move.”

“Give me five, sista!” Zoey held up her hand and smiled. “We’re still in this together.”

Heidi shook her head at their high five and rolled her eyes at Zoey’s silliness. “There’s still plenty of time, you know.”

“I guess. So…” Zoey waggled her eyebrows. “Tell us more about your reformed man-whore.”

“Hey!” Meagan grimaced. “I don’t need to know my cousin’s sex life, and he wasn’t that bad, was he? The man-whoring, I mean, not anything else.”

“No, he wasn’t.” Heidi chuckled. “Nathan has had a good amount of sex in his lifetime, but I wouldn’t go that far. He has a hearty appetite for it, that’s all, and I’m basking in the benefits of all of that experience.”

“La, la, la!” Meagan sang as she covered her ears, and the other two laughed again. It was always a good time when they got together, but they obviously needed a subject change for now.

“Wanna dance for a bit and forget about it all?” Heidi asked.

“Oh, thank God.” Meagan cheered. “I thought you were going to keep going.” She held out her hands and tugged Heidi and Zoey with her to the dance floor.

****

They’d been fucking for weeks, and it hadn’t changed a thing in their relationship. Heidi was secretly relieved they could separate the sex from their friendship so as not to complicate things, or so she kept telling herself. She couldn’t bear the thought of losing Nathan. He was too important. They still did their own things at times, but she’d been beyond satisfied each night as Nathan seemed to be fucking only her lately. It was going so well despite their lack of conversation on exclusivity, and to thank him, she’d decided to up the playing field a little by bringing Rafe into the mix.

Rafe was the tall Greek Adonis from down the hall who had no trouble gaining attention. He’d moved into their building the previous year and flirted with both her and Nathan constantly, so when she had approached him the week before with a threesome offer, she was delighted when he’d eagerly accepted.

Nathan was due home from work at any moment, and Rafe, one half of his surprise, was tied to his bed with silk scarves. Heidi had planned everything out. She’d even gone to her favorite lingerie store to buy something sexy. Nathan had wanted her to spice it up initially, and she wanted to keep him happy. She envisioned him walking through the door, where she’d greet him with a kiss. She’d tell him about his surprise as she gave him a seductive striptease, revealing the sexy lingerie underneath her clothes, and work her way up to the blindfold before revealing a tempting naked Rafe for them to play with. So when she heard the door open, she started to dance for him and seductively swayed her hips to the music playing in the background. Only things hadn’t gone exactly as planned: the moment she began to unbutton her blouse, she was shocked to see the disinterest in his eyes.

He wasn’t alone.

The sight of his unexpected company made her stop in her tracks. “Nathan?” Heidi took a step towards him. “What’s wrong?” she asked. Although concerned, she was mostly trying to conceal the hurt she’d felt by his look of rejection towards her. She hoped he had the same plans she did with the company he brought home. She could see herself having fun with a woman too, if that would make him happy. She was pretty much game for anything. He was in a bad mood, that was for sure, and it seemed to be directed towards her.
What the fuck?

“Wrong?” he repeated. “My boss is a fucking asshole from hell. He passed me by again and gave the promotion I wanted to fucking Clemens, so yeah, I’m in a bad mood.” He pointed to the busty blonde beside him. “So, you remember Missy, right?  I ran into her today, and I thought she’d be able to help me relieve some of this stress.” He arched a brow, daring her to say something about it.

Heidi rolled her eyes and extended a hand to Missy. There was no way in hell she was going to be the bitch Nathan expected her to be. He was being deliberately hurtful, and yes, it pissed her off and made her feel like garbage because of the way he spoke to her, but she’d also be damned if she was going to let him see how jealous she felt right then. “Hello, Missy.”

Her lack of reaction seemed to piss him off. “I’m starting to think maybe we should cool it for a while.” He walked by her to enter his room, leaving her there in shock, only to walk right back out again to ask, “What’s Rafe doing tied to my bed?”

And she finally lost it, because there was no way she’d allow him to treat her this way without getting the final word in. He wanted to be a douchebag—well, she’d damn well let him know that he was.

“You know what? Fuck you, Nathan Anthony De Costa. You’re such an asshole. I worked my ass off to try and please you, and what do I get but a big ‘fuck you’ in return.” She laughed humorlessly. “Rafe is in there as a part of my surprise you’ve just ruined, so go and enjoy. I’m tired of loving you and not getting what I need in return. I hope one day I make you eat your words, because despite the company and the constant sex, it’s a pretty lonely life you lead without the emotion. And when you do finally realize you missed out on a great thing, I just hope it’s not too late, because right now, I’m done.”

“Wait a minute! I love you!” He sounded shocked by her outburst—and his own.

Her heart cracked a little more with longing. She looked between Missy and Nathan after that confession, and Missy suddenly looked extremely uncomfortable, if not a little mad. “Yes, I guess you do in your own way, but differently from what I’m talking about.”

Nathan looked away while Heidi couldn’t contain her hurt feelings anymore, allowing her tears to fall.
Stupid, stupid, stupid!

His hands fisted at his sides when he spoke again. “You promised things wouldn’t change for us, Heidi. Don’t fucking back out on your word now.”

“Yeah, well, you were the one who started this, and I guess I lied.” She backed away towards the door. She had to leave to cool down. She couldn’t stand to let him see her hurt anymore. She needed a little dignity to cope with her rejection. So after buttoning up her shirt and grabbing her purse, she took one last look behind her before slamming the door shut behind her.

She’d planned one hell of a night all right. It was just too bad she wouldn’t get to enjoy it.

Fucking asshole!

****

Rafe grew soft hearing the argument outside the bedroom door. He was beginning to doubt he’d get his night of promised pleasure, since Nathan was being such a crab, and Heidi sounded like she’d left all together. The door slamming was a dead giveaway. There was no way he could relax now, and he secretly wished he hadn’t been tied to the bed at that moment, no matter how good it felt to be displayed for the taking.
Shit!
Now he had no choice but to listen to the other female and Nathan now. She wasn’t impressed, and rightfully so.

“So, you love her?”

“Yes.” Nathan sighed. “She’s my roommate and is supposed to be my best friend. If I haven’t screwed things up as bad as I think I have.
Fuck!
” The floor boards began to creak; Rafe assumed Nathan was pacing the hallway. “I had it all this morning. The potential for a great promotion, and a sexy woman who loves me. She’s open, honest, beautiful, and quite possibly one of the sweetest people I know. She would have done anything for me, and I went and fucked it all up. Why? Because I had a bad fucking day and she scares me.”

Missy gasped. “Nathan, in all of the years we’ve been together on and off, I don’t think I’ve ever seen you look at me, or anyone else, for that matter, the way you look at her. I can’t deny I’m a little upset, but you do love her, and you’re kidding yourself if you think otherwise. Stop fighting it, hon. The sex was astounding, and I’m going to miss it, but I’m going to do you a favor by walking away right now. I’d hate to contribute to this mess you’ve made here. Fix it, and hey, if it doesn’t work out, you know my number.”

It went silent before the wood flooring creaked and Rafe heard the sound of high heels walking away. The door softly closing outside of the room he was currently trapped in made Rafe wonder if he’d been left there alone.
Shit!

To his relief, Nathan stormed in determinedly just then and paced near the foot of the bed a few times, muttering obscenities under his breath.

“Um, Nathan—” Rafe began to tug at the silk binding his wrists and ankles. “A little help over here.”

“What?” Nathan huffed and looked as if he’d completely forgot the other man was lying there naked in his bed. His chest heaved as his breathing became more rapid, and Rafe wasn’t sure at that moment if it was out of anger or excitement. It might have been a little of both. There was a sparkle in Nathan’s eyes when he looked at Rafe, and then an unexpected smirk came across his face, which made Rafe unsure of what to expect.

“Look, I’m not that good at the whole mood-swing display you’ve got going on here, and I think maybe I should leave. Heidi obviously planned this at a bad time for you, so if you’ll untie me, I think I’ll be on my way. Maybe the three of us could do this some other time.”

“Fuck that!” Nathan laughed without humor. “Heidi planned this for me to enjoy, and I damn well plan to. I went and fucked things up with her, Missy left me, and I can’t say I blame her, and now that leaves me with you. So let’s have some fun. Come on, Rafe, what’s a little no-strings-attached pleasure between neighbors, huh? I can see your dick getting hard for me again.” Nathan smiled. “So now the question is, are you going to help make my mood any better? God knows I could sure use it. I’ve lost so much today and totally made an ass out of myself on top of it.”

Rafe moaned as he watched Nathan devour him with his eyes. Fuck yeah, he was getting aroused. He was promised a night of pleasure and knew damn well the invite would be delivered now. His mind kept telling him it would be best to go, that maybe the threesome could happen some other time, but his cock wanted the pleasure that was promised and rose to the occasion just from one heated look. He was screwed, and he knew it—or was about to be, anyway.

Nathan was a lot like him in many ways. They weren’t the settling-down type; they both took what they wanted, when they wanted, and knew how to please. As their neighbor, he’d observed things over the last year, and Nathan definitely had seen more action than Heidi had.

He wished Heidi was with them right now, but he would settle for a continuation at another time. She was a fiery little redhead with a really hot body, great personality, and a gorgeous face. He’d wanted to fuck her almost immediately after getting to know her. She was sweet as hell, and when he’d seen Nathan he had thought the same thing. He’d known then he couldn’t have one without the other, known they were in love with each other but fighting hard to deny it.

Rafe loved sex, there was no doubt about it. He always had, always would, and he couldn’t wait for the day he found “the one” he couldn’t live without. Until then, he was going to enjoy his fun and freedom.
Speaking of fun…

“Hell yeah, and if you untie me, I’ll show you just how much I can turn this night from bad to good.” He tugged on his silky restraints again while lifting his hips in impatience.

“I’m counting on that.” Nathan smiled and began to undress. He left Rafe still tied there until he was completely nude. After only untying his ankles, Nathan knelt on the edge of the bed and pushed Rafe’s feet toward him to get closer, and then he made him spread his legs wide. He lowered his head, and Rafe moaned as Nathan licked and sucked on his balls. But instead of moving up towards Rafe’s shaft, he instead surprised him when his mouth lowered to his ass to eat him there.

Rafe cursed and tried shifting so Nathan’s face pressed harder against him. He was so fucking hard, he ached, and Nathan’s tongue on his hole felt so fucking good, yet it made him feel incomplete. He needed more. Nathan’s attentions heightened as his tongue circled and then stroked in and out, making Rafe moan and writhe while Nathan chuckled at his response.

Suddenly, he stopped and replaced his tongue with his fingers. Nathan pumped in and out of his ass and moved his lips up to where he was needed most.

“You fucking tease!” Rafe was breathless. “Stop licking me and put my fucking cock in your mouth already.”

“What, you don’t like what I’m doing?” Nathan mocked a pout and then laughed.

“Uh-uh.” He shook his head.

“I thought you were supposed to be the one making me feel good. Oh, I plan to please you, all right, but I want your mouth on my cock while you stroke yourself for me first. Will you do that for me, Rafe? Will you taste my cock and make me feel good? I’ve had such a bad day.”