Authors: Johanna Nicholls
âDon't ask
me
to forgive her!' Clytie said.
Finch nodded. âWe'll leave her to the mercy of the One True Judge.'
He knocked again. âLook, Clytie, try not to appear surprised â no matter what happens inside. Perhaps it would be best if I go around to the back to Adelaide's quarters and see how the land lies before you come in. I have a hunch things could get really messy.'
âWorse than being accused of murder? How much worse can they get? Nothing doing, Finch. I'll meet whatever it is head on. They're both my friends. Nothing can change that. They've put their lives on the line to get my baby back.'
Clytie knocked again. The brass doorknocker depicted a snake twined around a pole, the symbol signifying a physician.
âOh my God! Finch, look, Doc has taken it down!'
She pointed to the holes made by screws in the wall. The brass nameplate was gone.
âWell, that's certainly a statement of intent,' Finch said.
Crouched on his haunches, Shadow gave a series of growls.
âWhat's up with him?' Finch snapped. âCan't you keep him quiet? I wish Rom was here. It's his damned dog.'
âShadow is highly sensitive to mood. He can smell trouble a mile off.'
âClever dog,' Finch muttered.
âNo call for sarcasm. That Kelpie is smarter than most men.'
âAnd all women?' Finch retorted. âSorry, I had no call to say that. Look, we're wasting our time. It's obvious Doc isn't here â or doesn't want to answer.'
âYou can piss off if you want. I'm not budging,' Clytie snapped. âIf I can survive today's shockwaves, I can survive anything.'
Just then the music stopped. Clytie hurried down the path towards Adelaide's quarters, with Finch and Shadow close at her heels.
The side door was ajar. She cleared her throat. âAnyone home? It's Clytie and Finch. We were worried about you. Is everything all right?'
âCome in, come in.' The weary voice sounded suspiciously slurred, as if from drink.
Adelaide's quarters were shrouded in darkness except for the far corner where a kerosene lamp had been turned down, just low enough to cast a golden glow in a circle around a small table. The smell of whisky competed with the customary perfume of flowers. The winged chair was positioned with its back to them, so that the seated figure was totally obscure except for one hand resting on the velvet arm of the chair.
âI was half expecting you. I'm glad you came to say goodbye. Saves me writing a long, painful explanation.'
âNeither of you are leaving! We won't allow it!' Clytie tried to sound confident as she clutched hold of Finch in the dim light.
âNo choice, my dear. It doesn't matter now. My work here is finished. The game is up. Come in, come in and join me in a farewell drink.'
Clytie and Finch exchanged a look of surprise.
Doc is teetotal.
Finch gestured to her to precede him in the darkness but wasted no time in coming to the point.
âSonny Jantzen put it in a nutshell, Doc. It was a witch hunt â but Twyman
failed.
The whole town values you. We're here to help you weather the storm.'
âThank you. But Adelaide and I cannot wade through a hurricane, my friends. We shall depart at dawn â destination unknown â once more to up stakes and begin life again in some remote place where no one knows us.'
Finch stumbled against a table of bric-a-brac and searched for chairs as their eyes gradually adjusted to the dim light.
âShare the love seat,' Doc ordered amiably. âIsn't it high time you two stopped fighting Nature?'
âOh, we're not a couple, Doc. Just friends,' Finch said quickly.
â
Some
of the time,' Clytie corrected with equal speed.
âThe Lady doth protest too much, methinks,' Doc quoted as he poured out three glasses of whisky.
âYes, for once I'll join you. I've fallen off the wagon,' he said cheerfully.
Clytie took her seat and the figure in the chair grew clearer. Her breath caught sharply in her throat. Finch shared her shocked response. He sat beside her and took hold of her hand. For once she did not pull away from him.
The figure in the chair had Doc's familiar voice and even in the darkness the profile and unkempt sandy hair were unquestionably his. But he looked different. Defeated. He sat slumped in the chair wearing a shabby striped dressing-robe, whisky tumbler in his hand.
Clytie was chilled by the bleak expression in his red-rimmed eyes and the traces of tears staining his cheeks.
Dear God, what is happening?
Is the poor man mentally unbalanced again? Or is something wrong with Adelaide?
âCare for a whisky?' Doc asked cheerfully, indicating the glasses. âBad habit to drink alone.'
âThanks, I reckon I need one,' Finch said.
The Doc gave a sharp, self-deprecating laugh. âI don't blame you, lad. I'm not a pretty sight. Here's the bottle. Please, help yourselves.'
Finch handed the first glass to Clytie with a frown that was unmistakably a silent command to drink it down. He dispatched his own drink with equal speed.
âCheers.' Doc clinked his glass to theirs. âYou're too polite to ask the obvious question, so I'll cut to the chase.'
He refilled his own glass and drained it.
âThere, an injection of Dutch courage.'
Clytie felt confused. âYou don't need to tell us anything you don't want to, Doc,' she said, despite her desperate curiosity.
âIt will be a relief to share it. You see, I've carried this secret all my life.'
Finch shrugged. âThere are worse secrets than yours, Doc. It's your business if you needed medical help. No one else's.'
âAh, if only that were true, lad. I was not incarcerated in Kew Asylum because I was insane but to avoid imprisonment.' Doc paused to weigh their reaction. âFor a crime involving Adelaide. As you know, it is a criminal offence for a woman to wear men's clothing â and vice versa.'
Clytie and Finch exchanged blank, covert glances. Clytie grasped desperately for a logical conclusion. âDo you mean that one of you was accused of masquerading in the other's clothes?'
Finch jumped in quickly. âGood God, Clytie, your imagination's run riot!'
Doc's hand made a rocking motion. âYou're
half
right, Clytie â but it's not
quite
as simple as that. Would you like me to explain?'
They both leant forward in their seats. âOf
course,
Doc.'
Doc refilled their glasses.
âBear with me. I need to begin at the very beginning. My father, a naval physician, married his first cousin â a tradition of intermarriage unwisely practised by our family in England for generations. When Adelaide and I were born only minutes apart, we were fortunate to have escaped the haemophilia that has cursed many Royal families, including our late Queen Victoria's descendants. But we were both born with an impediment. Adelaide had a club foot. My feet were perfect â the rest of me presented a problem. My parents and the doctors were unable to agree on how to register my birth. The scales of gender seemed evenly balanced between male and female. Shall I continue?'
Clytie and Finch answered with one voice. âOf course!'
âMy father wanted a son, my mother wanted daughters. As a result of this conflict of interests, when Father was in port I was dressed as a boy. When he was at sea for months on end, Mother dressed me as Adelaide's twin sister. Not surprisingly, this caused me to be mocked and bullied by local village children. Adelaide was my sole refuge. She totally accepted me for whatever I was on any given day.
âMy father registered me at birth as Robert A â a name that could easily be switched legally to Roberta if, in the process of growing up, nature swung the balance one way or another, perhaps at puberty.' He drained his glass. âThe problem is, in my case it never did. The scales remained evenly balanced between male and female. I am so sorry to shock you,' he apologised.
âSo Adelaide was your one true friend,' Finch prompted.
Clytie agreed. âWhat a blessing she is!'
âShe is my guiding light.'
Doc passed across for their inspection the gold locket that Adelaide had worn that day in court. It held a miniature portrait of a young
girl wearing a tailored Victorian gown. Her features, while similar to those of Doc's, were cast in a stronger mould, intelligent rather than conventionally pretty. Her expression combined challenge with vulnerability. In contrast to his sandy hair, her crowning glory was an auburn mane that flowed around her shoulders.
âMy twin sister Adelaide at age eighteen â when we were both desperate to study medicine. Father encouraged me, took me to sea with him to gain medical experience at first hand. But he forbade Adelaide on the basis of her gender â and
that.'
He gestured towards the boot with the built-up sole which lay discarded on the carpet.
âAdelaide always claimed she would make a better physician than me â no doubt she was right.'
Clytie's embarrassment gave her away. Adelaide had told her the same thing.
âMy dear, I see that Adelaide told you the truth. She was exceptionally clever. Thwarted in fulfilling her own dream, she threw her energies into coaching me. She honed up on my medical books and challenged me about medical theories â and my attitudes to healing and death. I doubt I would have passed my final exams without Adelaide's coaching.'
âA remarkably generous sister,' Finch said gently.
âIndeed. She was forced to stand in my shadow, watching me fulfil her dream â the only life she ever wanted, a career denied to her due to her gender and her club foot. Just as marriage was of course denied to me due to my unresolved gender . . . an illustration of “physician, heal thyself”. Who was it said that?'
Finch answered automatically. âJesus, in the gospel of Luke the Physician, I seem to remember.'
âGender,' Doc added, as if the word had a slightly bitter taste. âSuch an inadequate word for such a complex, God-given status. But please don't pity me, I only ever wanted one thing from life â whether as a man or a woman. To be a physician who cares for his community with the same devotion a father cares for his own family.'
âYou've proved that a thousand fold,' Finch said firmly. âEveryone loves and respects you, Doc.'
âBecause they never really
knew
me. Now that Twyman has
bluffed his way into offering proof that I was an enforced inmate of Kew Asylum the game is up.'
Finch was quick to deny it. âNo! Whatever the reason for your treatment â it's past history.'
Doc hesitated before he said with a sigh, âUntil the whole of Hoffnung discovers the truth. I was not incarcerated in Kew Asylum on the grounds of insanity, but to receive treatment â to avoid imprisonment. I was discovered in public wearing Adelaide's gown. Shamed and forced to abandon my Melbourne practice, Hoffnung offered us the chance to begin a new life.'
Finch tried to make the question sound off-handed. âDoes anyone else know of your . . . your habit?'
âSergeant Mangles stumbled on the truth some years back when he called me to the station where his beloved mare was dying, her foal trapped in her womb. I delivered her foal and saved them both. It was an emergency. I had no time to change from Adelaide's clothing.'
Clytie gave an involuntary gasp and covered her mouth with her hands.
âYou mean . . .?'
Doc nodded. âI suspect Mangles felt indebted to me. Whatever the reason, he turned a blind eye. Told me if I occasionally chose to wear Adelaide's dress to the Post Office to collect a remittance cheque, he couldn't see the harm in it, and it was no one else's business.'
âGood bloke, Mangles. There you are then!' Finch said triumphantly. âLife goes on.'
âSo it did for a while. The problem was Adelaide grew stronger. Fired by the Women's Suffrage cause. Then she took matters into her own hands â to force poor Sister Bracken to write her confession. The rest is history.'
He turned to them like a child, hoping to regain their approval.
âI promise you, there was never any attempt to attract the opposite sex, whatever that means. We could offer no man or woman anything but friendship but it was difficult to find a friend who could be trusted. I thought perhaps you, Clytie, being a child of the circus, would not look on us as freaks.'
Clytie reached across and clasped his hand. âThere's no such thing, Doc. Only people who are different, unusual.'
Finch grasped Doc's shoulder. âYou have more friends here than you know. You and Adelaide
must
remain in Hoffnung. You're needed here!'
âThank you, more than I can say. But the time has come for me to let Adelaide go.'
Clytie and Finch looked blankly at each other until Doc gestured to the sculpture of a woman's head on a shelf in the shadows. The blank unseeing face was framed by a beautifully groomed auburn wig.
âAdelaide's hair,' said Doc. âYou see, my sister died the year I gained my medical degree. She studied so long and devotedly with me she succumbed to consumption. She demanded I shave off her hair to try to reduce her fever. I could do nothing to save her.' His voice cracked. âAs a tribute to her memory I have tried to devote my life to my practice, fulfilling both our dreams by becoming a physician of whom she would be proud.'
The three of them sat immobile, listening to the chimes of the grandfather clock.
Clytie broke the silence in a voice that sounded unfamiliar. âCould I have a drink of water, please, Doc? My throat is as dry as chips.'
Doc was resigned, almost cheerful. âNo water. Tank's run dry. Whisky will do the trick.'
Their glasses filled, he sank back in his chair.