Esther said, “You’re crazy, Walter, that isn’t the man. He looks something like it, but it isn’t the man.”
He looked at her in astonished surprise. “Why, it is too. You can’t mistake him. He’s—”
“He has the same build,” Esther said, “and about the same complexion, but the man who came in the hotel was a little broader, a little heavier, and I think a year or two older.”
The clerk hesitated dubiously, staring at me.
The detective said, “Be your age, guy. She’s been playing around with him and is trying to protect him.”
The clerk’s face went white as a sheet. He said, “That’s not so! Esther, you know that isn’t so! Tell him it’s a lie.”
“It’s a lie,” Esther said.
“Of course it’s a lie. Esther’s running a cigar counter, and she kids them all along, but when it comes to—”
“Bunk,” the detective said. “She’s stringing you along. Why don’t you take a tumble to yourself, sucker? This is the guy that’s beating your time. How the hell do you suppose
she
got
here?
She was riding down in the elevator with him. They were headed for her apartment when we picked them up.”
The clerk stared from the detective to Esther, then to me. I saw hatred come in his eyes. He shrilled, “That’s not true about Esther, but this is the man. I’ll swear it’s the man.”
The detective grinned at me. “How about it, buddy? You the guy?”
“No,” I said.
“Well, now, ain’t that too bad? Must be a case of mistaken identity. Do you want to help the officers clear it up?”
“Of course.”
“Then we’ll go over to the hotel and look around.”
I said, “No we won’t. We’ll talk things over right here, or else we’ll go see the D.A.”
“Oh, no, buddy. You’re going to the hotel.”
“What do you expect to find there?”
“Oh, we can sort of look around. We’d like to try the blade of your knife and see whether it fits into that little hole in the door.”
I shook my head. “If you’re going to try and pin anything on me, I’m going to see a lawyer.”
“Now listen, buddy, if you’re guilty, that’s all right. You just go ahead and sit tight. Don’t say anything and get a lawyer, but if you’re innocent and don’t want to have this thing pinned on you, you’d better help us clear it up.”
“I’m willing to help you clear it up, but I’m not going to be dragged around the streets.”
“Where do you want to go?”
“Out to Ashbury’s house,” I said.
“Why?”
“I have some work to do out there. That’s where my clothes are.”
I saw a crafty look on the detective’s face. “That’s fine,” he said. “We’ll get a taxi and go out to Ashbury’s.”
“How about the car you came in?” I asked.
“Well,” he said, “that’ll be sort of crowded.”
He walked back to Esther Clarde and said, “All right, sister, you’re at the parting of the ways. Either identify this guy or get hooked as an accessory. Which do you want to do?”
“He isn’t the one.”
“We
know
he’s the man. You’re standing right at the forks of the road. Pick your bed, because you’re going to have to lie in it.”
Bertha Cool, who had walked toward the elevators and paused to listen in on the conversation, said, “Isn’t that intimidating a witness?”
The detective looked up at her, an angry flush coming to his face. “Move on,” he said. “This is police business.” He flipped back the lapel of his coat to show her his star.
Bertha Cool said, “Phooey. That piece of tin doesn’t mean a damn thing to me. If I understand what I’ve heard correctly, you’re telling this girl that if she commits perjury, nothing will happen to her, that if she tells the truth, you’re going to hook her for being an accessory after the fact.”
“Go jump in the lake,” the detective said irritably.
“Find one big enough and I will,” Bertha cooed. Esther Clarde remained quietly positive. “He isn’t the man.”
Markham, the night clerk, said, “You know he’s the man, Esther. What are you trying to do? Why should you protect him? What’s he to you?”
“A total stranger,” she said. “I never saw him before in my life, and neither did you.”
The detective who had charge of me said, “Bill, take them out to Ashbury’s place. We’ll go in a cab. I want to keep this girl and Lam apart, and you’d better keep her from talking to that night clerk.”
“Let her talk her head off,” the other detective said, “She’s just building up a case against herself.”
Esther said to the night clerk, “If you’d had a good look at him, Walter, you’d know he isn’t the same one. You didn’t see him as well as I did. You—”
“You heard what I said,” the detective remarked. “Well, what the hell am I going to do? Am I—”
The detective who had me grabbed Markham by the arm. “You come along with us,” he said.
Markham came walking along, his pants flapping around his ankles where the cuffs had been rolled up.
We went in a taxi. The others followed in the police car, clearing the way for the cab with the siren. I never did know how Bertha got there, but she managed to keep right along with the procession. When we pulled up in front of Ashbury’s house and got out, the detective looked at her, and said, “You again. Where do you think you’re getting in on this party? Beat it.”
Bertha said, “It happens this young man is working for me, and I’ve telephoned a lawyer who’ll be here in about ten minutes. Mr. Ashbury wants to see me, and if you try to keep me out of this house, you’ll have a damage suit on your hands.”
“We don’t want any lawyers,” the detective said. “All we need is to get things straightened out. Lam can make a frank statement, and that’s all there’ll be to it.”
Bertha snorted.
The detectives held a whispered conference, then we all went in.
“Is Miss Ashbury home?” one of the detectives asked the butler.
“Yes, sir.”
“Get hold of her. Get her here right away.”
“Yes, sir. Who shall I say is calling?”
The detective pulled back his coat. “The law,” he said. The butler took it on the double quick.
I heard Alta’s feet on the stairs—quick, light steps.
Alta paused on about the fourth step where she could see into the room. No one needed to blueprint the situation for her. She stood there staring with eyes that were a little wider and a little rounder than usual, then she came forward with her chin up. “Why, Donald, what is this?”
“A personally escorted tour,” I said.
The detective who seemed to be in charge pushed forward and said, “You’re Alta Ashbury?”
“Yes.”
“You hired this man to get some letters for you, didn’t you?”
“I did nothing of the sort.”
“What’s he doing here?”
“Giving my father physical culture lessons.”
“Bunk.”
She drew herself up, and there was something about her that put the detectives on the defensive. “This is my father’s house,” she said. “I don’t think he’s invited you to call, and I’m certain
I
haven’t.”
Bill said, “How about taking his fingerprints, sergeant?”
“Good idea.”
They grabbed my hands. I resisted as best I could, but they held my wrists and took fingerprints.
Bill said, “Come on, Lam. What’s the use beating around the bush. Your fingerprints check with the ones we found there in the hotel.”
“Then someone planted them.”
“Yes, I know. You loaned someone your hands for the evening.”
I said, “Show me where they check.”
The detectives huddled together, began comparing my prints with some photographs they had. I heard the sound of heavy steps in the upper corridor, and Mrs. Ashbury and Bernard Carter came walking down the stairs. He was tenderly solicitous. She was prepared either to make a scene or put on an act, as the occasion might require.
There was something in the ponderous dignity of her appearance that impressed the officers more than Alta Ashbury’s clean-cut patrician manner. The officers became deferential.
“What’s going on here?” Mrs. Ashbury asked.
“We’ve caught the murderer,” one of the detectives said, and motioned toward me.
“Donald!” she exclaimed in surprise.
He nodded.
I heard quick, pounding steps, and Bob, running up from the billiard room, came to stand in the doorway.
Alta Ashbury moved over to my side and said, “Dad’s on his way out here.”
He came in while the officers were still in a huddle over the fingerprints. I saw things weren’t going to suit them. They shifted photographs around and stared in scowling concentration at the prints they’d taken of my fingers. I was glad I’d remembered to wear gloves there in that hotel room.
Ashbury came over to stand near me.
The sergeant of detectives moved over to talk with Markham, the night clerk. Markham was more and more positive. He kept nodding his head emphatically. They moved over and had a whispered conference with Esther Clarde, and she continued to shake her head.
Ashbury said, “What’s it all about, Donald?” Bertha Cool took his arm, pulled him off to one side, and started to whisper.
I said to the sergeant, “It’s too bad those fingerprints don’t check. You wanted to crack the case, didn’t you?”
“All right, wise guy,” he said, “go ahead and shoot off your mouth. You’ll sing a different tune before we’re done with you.”
I motioned toward Bernard Carter.
“Why don’t you try
his
fingers?” I asked. “See if they match.”
“Nuts. The man we’re looking for is a man of your build, your complexion— In short, we’re looking for
you!”
“All right,” I said, “if you don’t try his fingerprints, you have yourselves to thank for passing up a chance of advancement.”
At that, I don’t think they’d have done it if it hadn’t been for the look on Carter’s face.
The office’ moved over toward him. “Just a routine checkup,” he said.
Carter shot his hands behind his back. “What the hell do you fellows think this is? Who do you think you’re pushing around? I’ll have you busted wide open.”
I lit a cigarette.
The officers looked at each other, and then converged on Carter.
He put up quite a fight, first with a lot of threats, and then by trying to break away. They got his fingerprints. It took only one look at the fingerprints and the photograph, a quick consultation, and one of the officers pulled out a pair of handcuffs.
Mrs. Ashbury said, “Bernard, what’s the meaning of this? What are they trying to do?”
“It’s a frame-up,” he yelled. “I’ll be damned if I stand for it.” He broke loose, and started for the door.
“That’s far enough, buddy,” the sergeant in charge said.
Carter shot through the door and started to run through the corridor. The officer pulled out a gun. Mrs. Ashbury screamed.
The officer yelled, “I’ll shoot! By God, I will!”
We heard Carter’s running feet come to a stop. The officer walked toward him.
I said to Ashbury, “That’ll just about wind it up,” and turned to encounter Alta’s eyes.
CHAPTER SIXTEEN
B
ERTHA
C
OOL FOUND US
in the solarium. She looked at me and said, “Donald, lover, I’m damned if I know how you do it, but you certainly reached in the grab bag and came out with first prize.”
“Has he confessed?” I asked.
“No, but those fingerprints tally. They found a gun on him that the officers think is the murder gun. They’ve rushed it to the ballistics department.”
Alta patted my hand.
Bertha stood looking down at us. “All right, Donald,” she said, “break it up. The rest of it’s up to the police. We’re going back.”
“Back where?” Alta asked.
“Back to work.”
“But he’s working.”
“Not on this case. It’s all washed up.”
She walked calmly out of the solarium.
“Want to try something?” I asked Alta.
“What?”
I said, “Those letters. There’s one place they
might
be.” She looked around in quick apprehension to make certain that no one was listening. “Where?” she asked.
“Got your car out here?” I asked.
“Uh huh.”
We sneaked out the back way, got in it, and drove out of the yard. Police cars were arriving, a steady procession of sirens.
“Donald, tell me how did you figure that out?”
“I was dumb,” I said.
“You,
dumb!”
“Uh huh.”
She laughed.
I said, “That’s the way it figures. It looked like an inside job to me. It had to be. Esther Clarde knew about the switch on letters—everything that was going on here. When the officers took me up to her apartment, she was going to let them in. Then she saw me, and decided to talk in the corridor. I figured someone was in there I knew. It just about had to be Bob. I pegged Bob for the whole business, but it didn’t exactly fit. I overlooked the most logical bet.”
“What do you mean? You surely don’t mean that Carter got in my room and—”
“No,” I said. “Your stepmother. Don’t you get the picture? You were really the one who made a home for your father. When you went away, and he was left to shift for himself, he got desperately lonely. He wouldn’t say anything to you because he thought you had your own life to live, that you’d sooner or later get married and leave him anyway. So he decided to carry on and try to make another home for himself. When you came back, he realized how he’d made a fool of himself. Mrs. Ashbury saw the picture in its true light. Little things you did gave her her clue.”
“You mean she got the letters?”
“Yes ”
“Why?”
“To involve you in that wife murder and get you thoroughly discredited. She thought it would give her the whip hand.”
“And what did she do with them?”
“Gave them to Carter to turn over to the district attorney. Carter turned them over to Jed Ringold because he needed an outside point of contact. Ringold saw a chance to collect twenty grand, and still have enough letters for the D.A. Then he lost his dough gambling and decided to go the rest of the way on the letters.
“Your dad found out you were paying out money. Mrs. Ashbury found it out from him. Carter found out Ringold was double-crossing your stepmother.
She
wanted the D.A. to get those letters. He wanted the D.A. to get some of them. They were prepared for a little delay while Ringold was rigging a plant, but Ringold made the mistake of carrying things too far.”
“I still don’t see,” she said.
“Crumweather, of course, knew about the letters because Lasster told him. When a man gets in jail on a murder rap, he tells his lawyer everything. Crumweather wanted to make certain those letters were destroyed. He supposed, of course, that you’d burned them, but he wanted to make certain.
“Crumweather knew Carter, had business dealings with him, and knew Carter had an entree to your house, so he suggested to Carter that it would be a good plan to make certain the letters were destroyed.
“Then Carter must have passed the word on to Mrs. Ashbury, and she saw a chance to double-cross Crumweather, get you involved in a scandal, and make things so hot for you you’d want to leave the country and never show your face in it again.
“She was the one who got into your room and stole the letters. She gave them to Carter and told him not to let Crumweather have them, but to be certain they got into the hands of the district attorney.
“Carter was willing to double-cross Crumweather if Mrs. Ashbury told him to, but Carter saw a chance to make a little dough out of it. He turned the letters over to Ringold and gave Ringold a nice little fairy story to pass on to you that would account for the letters being offered you in three installments. The plan was that you were to buy two packages of the letters and then the third package was to be turned over to the district attorney. That would give Ringold and Carter a chance to split twenty thousand bucks and still give Mrs. Ashbury everything she wanted, because the letters that reached the district attorney’s hands would be the gems of the collection.
“But Ringold decided to double-cross everybody. He couldn’t see any reason for turning over that last bunch of letters to the D.A. and getting nothing in return except the thanks of the prosecutor’s office which he didn’t like anyway.
“Then he realized that Carter would know there’d been a double cross, and Ringold was in a quandary. Finally he hit on a bullet-proof scheme. He’d hocus-pocus you into thinking you had the last bunch of letters. He’d cash your check, and then turn over the rest of the letters to the D.A.
“But Carter didn’t trust Ringold, and Mrs. Ashbury couldn’t understand the delay. The conversation you overheard between her and Carter was when she was telling Carter to go ahead and show some speed and get you dragged into the case.”
“How was the murder committed?” she asked.
“Carter didn’t intend to kill anyone,” I said, “but he knew you were going to see Ringold. He thought perhaps there was going to be a double cross. He got a room in another part of the hotel, found four-twenty-one vacant, picked the lock with a skeleton key, watched his chance to slip through the communicating door, and hid in the bathroom. He found out all he wanted to know, and wanted to sneak out, but, in the meantime, I’d checked into that room and locked the communicating door. He couldn’t get back. Ringold caught him in the bathroom. Carter smoked his way out.
“As a matter of fact, Carter gave himself away. He was so anxious to get you on the defensive by telling you that he’d seen you near the scene of the murder at the time the murder was committed, he entirely overlooked the fact that this constituted an admission he was there himself— Otherwise he couldn’t have seen you.”
“He hasn’t admitted anything. My stepmother’s going to get a lawyer for him, and they’ll put up a fight,” she said thoughtfully.
“Swell,” I said. “Let them.”
“But won’t those letters enter into it?”
“Not unless the D.A. can get hold of them.”
“Well, where are they?”
I said, “Look at it this way. Carter doesn’t know where they are. Esther Clarde, who was handling the payoff, doesn’t know where they are, and Crumweather doesn’t know where they are. They’ve searched the room in the hotel—And I mean
searched
it. Jed Ringold had those letters when he went to the hotel. He didn’t leave the hotel, and apparently the letters didn’t either.”
“Donald, what
are
you getting at? You mean they’re concealed in some other room?”
“Perhaps,” I said, “but as I size up Ringold’s character, I don’t think he was that big a sucker.”
“What did he do with them, then?”
I said, “We’ll find out.”
I drove to the post office, walked in to the window which had
Q to Z
over the wicket, and said, “Jack Waterbury, please.”
A bored clerk with a rubber finger stall thumbed through a pile of envelopes and handed me one addressed to
Jack Waterbury, General Delivery.
I handed it to Alta as soon as I got in the car. “Take a look at this,” I said, “and see if it’s what you want.”
She ripped open a corner of the envelope and looked inside. Her face told me, the answer.
“Donald, how did you know?”
“There was only one place he could have put those letters. Down the mail chute. He had them with him when he was in the room with you. A few minutes later, when he was shot, he didn’t have them. The murderer didn’t get them. Crumweather didn’t get them. Esther Clarde doesn’t know where they are— There was only one place for them to go—down the mail chute.
“The man certainly hadn’t acted the part of a gentleman while you were in the room. Yet when you got up to leave, he fell all over himself getting out to the hall to ring the elevator for you. The reason he did that was because the mail chute was right by the elevator. He wanted to drop that letter down the mail chute the minute you had left him.”
She said, “I don’t understand just how Crumweather fits into it.”
“He had me fooled at first,” I said. “As Lasster’s lawyer, he naturally asked his client about women. Lasster told him about you and about the letters. Crumweather wanted to get them. He approached Carter. Carter told your stepmother, and she promised to get them. She did all right, but she couldn’t see any reason why she should let you out of the trap— Well, you know the rest.
She
thought the letters were going to the D.A. Carter and Ringold wanted to get twenty thousand dollars, and
then
turn the last third over to the D.A. Apparently, it never occurred to Crumweather he was being double-crossed until after the murder. Then Esther Clarde got in touch with him by telephone and told him what had happened. Naturally, he was frantic. He wanted to get that last batch of letters before the D.A. did.”
She said, “You’re a wizard when it comes to figuring things out.”
“Not me. I should be kicked for getting off on the wrong foot. I figured Crumweather was in on it all the time. I thought that he saw a chance to sell the letters to you for thirty thousand dollars, and let you burn them up—but evidently he wasn’t in on the play. Carter and Ringold were double-crossing him.”
“Then why should he agree to represent Carter?”
“Money,” I said.
She thought for a minute. “How did you know the name that would be on the envelope?”
“It was Ringold’s real name. I asked Esther Clarde what it was last night.”
“You mean you’d figured out about the mail chute then?”
“Yes.”
“And Carter didn’t know Ringold was going to sell me that last bunch of letters?”
“No. Ringold did that on his own. Carter was suspicious, that’s all. He didn’t dare fall down on the job of putting those letters in the district attorney’s hands. Your stepmother meant more to him than Crumweather.”
She thought for a minute. “Where are you taking me now?” she asked.
“To the Commons Building. I want to talk with Mr. Fischler’s secretary,” I said, grinning, “and instruct her to hold out for ten thousand dollars before she surrenders certain certificates of stock and options in a mining company.”
Alta said, “Donald, are you going to stick them for that much?”
“All the traffic will bear,” I promised.
We reached the Commons Building and went to the Fischler Sales Office. Elsie Brand hastily slammed a desk drawer shut on a magazine as I opened the door. “Oh,” she said, “it’s you.”
I introduced Alta Ashbury. I could see that Elsie was impressed.
“When that salesman comes in,” I said, “tell him that Mr. Fischler is in conference out of the office, that he’s going to call in in about fifteen minutes, that you can talk with him over the telephone, but he absolutely won’t take messages from anyone else, and he doesn’t expect to be in the office for two or three days.”
She jerked her shorthand notebook out of the drawer on the left-hand side of the desk and made rapid notes. “Anything else?” she asked.
“He’ll ask you to call me up and give me a message. Twenty minutes later you can call him back and tell him I’ll forget the whole business and surrender the options for ten thousand dollars, that I won’t take a cent less.” “Anything else?”
“That’s all. Tell him you want the ten thousand in cash, that you’ll have Mr. Fischler sign the necessary papers and have the escrow made at Bertha’s bank.”
Her pencil made a swift flying succession of pothooks. “That’s all?”
“That’s all,” I said to her, and to Alta, “Want to walk into my private office?”
She nodded.
We walked on into the private office. As I closed the door, I saw Elsie watching me speculatively. I said, “I don’t want to be disturbed.”
Alta sat down on the settee across from the desk, and I sat down beside her.
“Is this your office, Donald?”
“Uh huh.”
“What did you take it for? I mean what’s the idea?”
“Just a little flyer in mining stock.”
She looked at me thoughtfully. “You play them awfully close to your chest, don’t you?”
“Not particularly.”
“And I’m not to say anything about those letters?”
“Not to anyone. Let’s see the envelope.”
She handed me the envelope, and I burned the letters carefully one at a time, and ground out the ashes in a cuspidor.
I’d just finished with the last of the bunch when I heard a commotion in the outer office, the sound of heavy steps, and then Bertha Cool banged the door open. Henry Ashbury was just behind her.
Bertha said, “Donald, lover, why the hell didn’t you tell me where you were going when you left? After all, you’re supposed to be working for me, you know.”
“I was busy,” I said.
Alta jumped up and threw her arms around her father. “Oh, Dad,” she said, “I’m so happy!”
He held her off at arm’s length so he could look at her. “Everything cleaned up all right?”
“Perfectly,” she said, and left a smear of lipstick on his cheek.
Bertha looked me over suspiciously.
Ashbury swung his eyes to look across at me. “Well, young man?” he asked.
“What?” I inquired.
“What’s the answer?”
“There isn’t any. I did the job I was supposed to do. It’s all finished as far as
that
angle is concerned.”