Authors: Mois Benarroch
E
very time I get on a plane I catch a cold, before even getting on the plane. It starts an hour before even getting to the a
irport. A dry cough, then a sneeze or two, and then it comes out endlessly. I'm not afraid of planes, I've never been afraid of planes. Maybe it is my subcon
scious, maybe the air conditioning in air
ports, I don't know. My father struck the stone and had another child, one that I knew nothing about. Papá, Papá! You didn't even tell me! Nor your favorite daughter, or even Ruth? Maybe you wanted to forget, and maybe you forgot until the day you wrote your w
ill.
You had so many secrets in Switzerland...and a secret son in Morocco. Maybe those two things go together. I remember flying to Madrid in 1977, two years after Franco died, and to Uncle Alfonso's place, and everything was so weird, in three years we were already so different, those who went to Spain and those who went to Israel.
On the one hand we were more sur
e of ourselves, as if the past had been erased, the humiliations, the feeling of living under the governments of others, everything was erased and everything remained.
On the other hand, they seemed more satisfied with their lives, with their country club and po
ol, tennis matches and modern cinema, Madrid was the modern city and Jerusalem the village, but they still had that same fear of
goyim
, that ancient Jewish fear that cannot be erased.
Maybe we also brought this fear and tran
sferred it to others, the
ashkenazim,
when we treated them like idiots and believed we could trick them. Remember, Papa, when they wanted you to invest your money in a
Histadrut
factory? At least you were sm
art enough to tell them that after buyin
g your house you had no money left. Very smart. I didn't understand why, but you said that there were fore
ign investors but that they wanted a private manufacturer, then you gave in, like so many times before, and now, where is your socialism? Israel has turned into a savage capitalist, those leading the
histadrut
uni
ons have turned into bank directors and crush the former oppressors, An Israeli invention: communist capitalism. Soon they'll export the idea to Russia and to other communist countries.
It is comical to me that after marrying Raymond, my dear Raymond, and going to live in Paris on rue Victor Hu
go, nothing more and nothing less, I was soon a Jew again. We didn't tell anyone that we were Jews, althoug
h our surname is very Jewish, but not every
one can recognize Jewish names. We told our children to behave like everyone else, not to call attention, not to say that their mother is from Israel, but it was incredible. French democracy is a delicate and sophisticated form of Christianity in which everyone wants everyone to be alike. Before they wanted everyone to be Christian, now they want everyone to be French. A citizen like everyone else. There are two religi
ons that aspire to be universal, Christianity and Islam, and now when they throw stones at the Jewish school I'm afraid to send my children there, exactly how we were afraid of the rocks that the Moroccan children threw at us when we came out of the
Alliance Fran
çaise
.
Maybe in Spain it would be different, but in Paris things were getting worse every day, and what happened is that like always, we Jews looked for justifications: the Palestinians, the Moroccans that came to France, the new Intifada, but no, it will pass, and in the end we went with a suitcase and four suits, this is what happens, well, better to stop thinking about it.
"Want some whisky?" asked Alb
erto from behind me.
"Yes."
"This family never says no to whiskey."
"Maybe it will help cure this cold. Or more likely give me a headache. We'll see."
I thought that we were coming for the month, and going back immed
iately, but here we are are, on a flight to Mad
id, as our grandmother said, journeys are when you
ketbea
. We are looking for Yosef Elbaz, brother, half-brother, almost thirty years old, about twenty-seven, maybe, even this isn't clear. We only know who his mother is, and now my children will have to wait a few days for me. My little girl cried on the phone, but will have to wait, this will la
st a few days, maybe a week. Maybe Mrs. Elbaz, our Fátima, will be waiting for us in the same house where we grew up. I bought it, she’ll say, from the money that your father sent. She will tell us how her son was raised and how intelligent he is, and that he went to Belgium, or no, she would tell us he got involved with drug trafficking and is now in jail, no, she would never tell us that, if he is in jail she'll say he went to the Netherlands and she doesn't know where he lives, he telephones once in a while. Yes, of course, he calls me and sends me money through Western Union. How would she pronounce that? In a Spanish mixed with Arabic, we would tell her why we came. Or keep it secret, I'm not sure.
"Who wanted a brother anyway?" my brother asks me.
"Yes. This is what we are all wondering, if an
y of us need another brother now. We're not really interested. We're traveling because our inheritance depends on this. Right? Maybe some curiosity, and maybe the opportunity to go to Morocco together, a special occas
ion that will never happen again, but above all it is mone
y, and Papa always said not to trust anyone when it comes to money.”
"What does that have to do with anything?”
"I don't know, but here's the food. Now we have something to do."
"Yes, this is why we have food, to
entertain us."
But not even a plate full of airplane food is enough to stop the thoughts, not even the cold. I ask for more tissues from the flight attendant. I would rather see my little brother, the one who died in the war. Not a new one. This is the only way to become a real Israeli. A Moroccan who dies in the war becomes a real Israeli. Until that moment he is half-Israeli. It must be because the dead cannot threaten anyone. Die and become one of us. I don't want to think about that.
My little brother would b
e thirty-three today, or thirty four, married, with one or two children, a wonderful age, he would be thirty-three, but he isn't here and no one talks about him. We all think about him but not out loud, the topic is sealed, the other three hundred soldiers that exploded alongside him, he is the one I want to see, and not Yosef, who I don't kn
ow, what good can this bring. We are going to see him but what we are looking for is money.
W
rite, write, write. Everything in this world is meant to end up in
a book, to be written on a page, som
eone dies and it is a book, it is a poem, someone kills someone, we write about it, terrorist attack, a daytime lover, they are all words, we see the thoug
hts of my brothers, a book.
I am sitting here with my laptop in fr
ont of me, my brothers behind, and I write. I write about them, I write them, I write about me, I don't think, you don't think, I write. Logic comes later. The only logic is that everything has a word, everything that happens is one word and another. Isaque is coming to Madrid from New York, the words go on, word
s explain everything or nothing, what does it matter, what is important is to document.
My father is dead, fine, we hav
e a book, I will write a book ab
out my father, about my dead brother, about divorce, the second wife, who exists or doesn't exist, it doesn't matter, I can wr
ite about what exists as if it doesn't exist, about what has been and what will never be, pa
per can handle it all, the reader can handle very little, they don't read most of the books, they throw them in the trash, but the page, the page is a paradise for writers like me, we bombard the page, the
ashkenazim
piss me off, whatever the problem, I can write it, I can respond, my
aliyá
was a failure, again, it doesn't matter, like Bukowski said, the best thing in writing is that you can find your wife fucking your best friend, and instead of killing him you go and write this grand p
oem, and that same night you can sit together all three of you and dri
nk a beer, or at least you can wr
ite it, you write more, and here is Silvia, who turns around to ask:
"What are you writing about in such a hurry?"
"About everything, whiskey, the flight attendant, the passport inspection..."
"Hey - don't write too much about us. We can't say anything to you, it will all end up in your books."
"Don't worry, I don't have many readers."
"Then what are you writing about us for, wri
te stories about the moon, they'll sell better."
Yes, that. They all have ideas about what I should writ
e about. I really need that one hundred thousand doll
ars of inheritance. My worker's compensation for ten years of part-time work at the
Sojnut
have ended, that’s over. It was boring work, but at least I was able to write in peace for two years. That is what is important, to write.
I tell myself that but I don't believe it, it is what it is, an illness, an obsession, only wr
iting. I ruined my life to write, I ruined my family, my son perhaps, or maybe it is better that he grew up with his mother, if he had been with me I could have destroyed him more.
I ne
ed money, this is why I'm looking for this strange brother, my secret brother, my brother who may not even be alive, I don't know. On this page I can go and live in Paris, or Madrid, but my life is already in Jerusalem. For a while now, my life has been in Jerusalem and Jerusalem has melted into my life, a Jerusalemite poet, Jerusale
m writer. But not the kind that write like Agnon, not me, I don't write like Agnon, I'm above this, and behind everything, I write like Alberto Benzimra, only Alberto Benzimra writes like Alberto Benzimra, and no one understan
ds what he writes.
What can I do? I ask Isaque to give me a homeopathic re
medy, because if I asked Fortu for something like that he would laugh at me, but in homeopathy you can treat everything, treat the pain from my father's death.
He gave it to me over the phone. "Take Ignatia...Ignatia 7 CH". Not bad, right? You can even treat the pain from the dea
th of someone who died fifteen years ago. I don't ca
re if it helps or cures anything, the pills for throat pai
n don't help eighty percent of the time, and if we want to talk about cancer, all those demented treat
ments don't help anything, but at least the theories behind homeopathy are much more literary than the theories behind allopathy, which only wants to destroy disease. According to homeopathy there is a harmony between people and plants on the earth, there are persons that are Natr
um, with an affinity for salt. How wonderful, a person who is the personification of salt. Others have snake venom, Lachesis. Others bee venom, Apis. Every person develops certain characteristics accord
ing to these parallels and can change throughout their lives to become one plant or another.
And my father kept his secret until death, until thirty days after his death, but he didn't take it to the grave. What was he afraid of? That his young
est daughter would marry his secret Moroccan son? Could that happen? It is very improbable, impossible. It must be that he felt guilty for leaving his son there with his mother and disappearing, maybe he thought he could take care of his family and his illegitimate son. How is he illegitimate exactly? A son, with
Fátima
, Fatima Elbaz. Who could believe it? But maybe it wasn't such an uncommon thing, and happened many times, what do we know, maybe this happened to many parents, but only my father didn't want to forget his son, he thought about him, he missed the son he never met, or who he met when he was one year old. How do you keep a secret? Technically it see
ms easy, but inside, how do you live with that?
You see, I can write a whole novel about this, a father's suffering, it isn't such a bad idea. But right now I will w
rite about our trip to Madrid, from Madrid to Málaga, a travel book, a travel diary. I hate travel books, but this will be different. I have noticed that the majority of the books by Moroccans are travel bo
oks, or include travel, they all want to go back, go back to what does not exist, the past, the Jewish community that does not exist anymore.
I remember that they ask
ed me if we would go back to Tétouan, and I said that it wasn't even a question. Tétouan without its Jewish community isn't Tétouan, it isn't a matter of views, mountains, oceans, it is nothing about that, it is a community that lives in parallel with the Christian and Muslim communities, that was Tétouan. The same with Fez or Casablanca, communities that were already autonomous, the relationship was an everyd
ay reality, but all culture exists independently of other communities, they are there. They pen
etrated us deeply, and only here in Israel do we disc
over how Moroccan we are, and not just Jew
s.
The same happens in Madrid, or in Paris, or in New York, we discover our Moroccan-ness, but when we return to Morocco, whe
n we travel to Morocco, we are again so far from the Muslims. We are Je
ws again. Where did you go, we ask. Wh
ere are you? What have you become without Jews?