For the First Time: Twenty-One Brand New Stories of First Love (49 page)

Ben’s cock was throbbing inside me and I continued to squirm on it while Scott moved to kneel behind us. His fingers lifted my cheek to the side, and cold liquid dripped down, gliding through my crevice.

There was a thump as the bottle fell to the bed, and the fingers of both of Scott’s strong hands fanned out on my ass, then curled, digging in. He urged me to ride faster, which I did. I gripped at Ben’s sweaty chest as I kept up the fast pace, and one of Scott’s hands began to move, creeping inward. Two fingers glided to my center and pressed firmly on my other entrance.

“Oh,” I cried when he gained access. It was shocking and dirty, and my eyes wanted to roll back into my head from how good it felt. Ben wrapped his hands on my biceps, bracing me.

“You look like you need another cock inside you.” God, Ben’s mouth turned me on. The muscles inside my pussy clenched on him and I watched his pupils dilate in reaction. His face had a faint sheen of sweat and lust.

“Yes,” I moaned, barely intelligible. It was indecent fucking one man while another possessed me this way, and it felt better than anything ever.

Scott’s other hand went to my shoulder, and the fingers in my ass retreated. Seconds later, the tip of his cock was right there. He squeezed his hold, fingers brushing my jaw, and I looked over my shoulder at him, filled with anxiety.

The lights cast a glow around him, but I could see well enough. He looked fucking gorgeous, but his expression was serious. “Deep breath and don’t move.”

Beneath me, Ben went rigid. Scott’s hand on my shoulder coursed down over my trembling back, following the line of my spine, until it moved to settle on a hip. He seemed to be waiting for something.

I filled my lungs with air, and only then did he start to press into me.

“Oh, oh, oh . . .” Oh my God! It was a burning, stretching sensation—one I wasn’t entirely sure I liked. I felt overwhelmed. Full beyond reason. Scott’s gaze never left mine as he pushed deeper into my ass. I was sure he was expecting any second for me to tell him to make me come.

“Jesus,” Ben groaned. Even without movement, he seemed to be enjoying it. His fingers bit into my arms, distracting me from my discomfort. Fuck, Scott’s cock was huge. My body was shuddering violently, but—

“Fuck.” I spat it out, unable to find any other word, because Scott began to move, and sensations shifted. Displeasure turned on its side and tumbled into enjoyment.

My curse word was a starting pistol on the men. Scott’s hands clamped on my waist and he withdrew, only to sink back into me. The fiery body beneath me stretched up, pushing inside with slow, shallow strokes.

“Yes,” I cried.

Scott moved a little faster, a little deeper, finding a tempo. He lifted his foot and placed it flat on the mattress to give him a better stance.

“Yes, yes, yes . . .” I chanted it, speeding my rhythm as Scott did his.

“It’s so fucking tight.” Ben’s eyes slammed shut and his mouth rounded as he exhaled loudly. “Oh, fuck.”

I’d never felt so dominated. These men using my body simultaneously for their pleasure, but also mine . . . I fucking loved it. My moans built in a crescendo until they bordered on screams, but I’d lost all control. I hovered right at the edge as Ben’s body rubbed my clit, filled my pussy, and Scott fucked my ass, sending my nerves into overdrive.

An inferno of need and heat smothered me, and my fingers clawed at the sheets, gripping them furiously. Scott’s hands clamped on my waist and clenched so hard it was at the edge of pain, but his movement held the same effect his tongue had given me earlier. Only one thought, one need in my mind.

Come, come, come . . .

That was when the orgasm took me. My heart stopped, my breath stuck in my lungs, and for a moment, I couldn’t vocalize how good it felt. My ability to do anything was obliterated.

A final thrust from Scott restarted me, and I screamed in ecstasy. The shattering, falling-apart sensation stormed through my bloodstream, and bliss thundered behind it, wiping everything out.

I collapsed forward, burying my face into the side of Ben’s neck, breathing him in. He smelled faintly of pine, and sweat, and sex. Both men continued to drive into my spent body, only the muscles beneath me were tense. Ben’s hand lay gently around my throat. His signal that he was close.

Scott jerked me, pitching me to the right, flinging me on my back. He loomed above, stroking himself furiously and the thick muscle of his arm flexed as he pumped. It was quite the view.

Ben scrambled onto his knees beside me, jerking himself, angling his cock at my tits. He only lasted a few seconds before he gasped, and his hand slowed.

“Here it fucking comes.”

Ribbon after ribbon struck me, thick and hot. His long moans filled the set, and I watched, mesmerized. Seeing someone else come was erotic and fascinating. His hand clutched tight and he sat back on his heels, almost as if admiring his work.

My gaze naturally went to the other man who was still pumping. I lifted up on my elbows to watch better. Should I touch him? Would he let me?

No. Tension pinched Scott’s shoulders together and his back bowed. His breath left him in a sharp burst as his freehand curl into a fist. His cum shot out in spurts, flicking onto my belly, wave after warm wave.

He slowed to a stop and he threw himself forward, planting his hands on the mattress on either side of my head. He lowered down so his lips were a breath away. He’d brought himself ninety-five percent of the way, it was up to me to do the rest.

So I reached up behind his head, clenched a fistful of hair, and drew him down into my kiss. Time came to a halt when his mouth was on mine. His tongue slipped past my lips, sliding over mine as if savoring my taste.

I was vaguely aware when Ben took my hand in his and laced our fingers together. It was an intimate gesture, made more so when he lifted our joined hands and kissed the back of my palm.

It was quiet and peaceful.

“Wow,” a female voice said. “That was fabulous, you guys.”

Scott straightened back from me, his expression pleased. Was it from Kimberly’s comment, or that I had kissed him? I wanted it to be the latter.

“Whenever you’re ready,” she continued, “I’ll have your checks at my desk. Bathroom’s right through the door to the left.”

She went. The overhead set lights clicked off and faded to dark, leaving the room only lit by the lamps on the end table. It made everything feel real and . . . oh, God. I was sticky, and what the fuck had I just done?

It was like Scott could sense the panic rising in me. He stood swiftly from the bed, and heavy footsteps carried him away. A faucet ran, sounds of hands being washed came from the next room, and I turned my blank stare to Ben. He was sitting up, still clasping my hand. His thumb brushed back and forth in a comforting gesture.

“You did awesome,” he said. “I was so nervous.”

“You were?” I blinked. “I couldn’t tell.”

Scott reappeared, holding a damp washcloth, and he approached the bed.

“That’s cold!” I cried as he began to rub it on me.

“Sorry.” But he continued to wipe the wet terrycloth against my skin, cleaning the evidence of what we’d done. Yet another unexpected gesture from him. Wasn’t he supposed to bolt now that we’d finished?

The bed shifted when Ben climbed off. He padded into the bathroom and shut the door, leaving Scott and me alone. I felt more vulnerable now with him, which was fucking ridiculous. He set the washcloth beside me on the bed as I sat up, and his expression changed to one that looked . . . odd. The confident, professional porn star appeared off-balance.

“Kimberly should have told you.”

I shrugged, unsure what to say or how to feel. “I had a great time.”

“Good. That’s . . . good.”

Was he nervous? He combed a hand through his hair, and when it came down, it fell to rest comfortably on my thigh. I stared at him, puzzled. His palm against my skin felt nice, but also confusing. There weren’t cameras to perform for. Was Scott . . . was he
into
me?

“Nina.”

My name in his voice wasn’t playing fair. The room was suffocating and hot under his intense stare. I wanted to melt into him, but at that second the bathroom door swung open, breaking the spell of the moment. Ben strolled to his clothes and began to get dressed.

“Seriously, guys,” he said, tugging a leg into his cargo shorts. “You both were great. I’d love to work with either one of you again.”

“Yeah.” Scott broke my gaze and went to my wad of clothes. “Same here.” By the time I was standing, he was beside me, dropped my dress in my hands, and urged me toward the bathroom.

Behind the closed door, I cleaned up quickly and tried to assemble my thoughts, but also didn’t want to waste time. Curiosity about Scott ate at me. I needed to catch him before he left because I wasn’t ready for my time with him to be over.

I blew out a quiet sigh of relief when I spotted him standing by Kimberly’s desk. It looked like Ben had already gone, but Scott lingered, chitchatting with her.

“Your check,” she said, thrusting the paper at me. “You better believe you’ll be hearing from me again. You two were on fire.”

I took the check and risked a glance at Scott. His expression was unreadable, but it made my heart race all the same.

“Don’t worry,” she added, looking up at him with a teasing smile. “I won’t tell Kendall about the kissing.” She winked at me. “Kendall’s his girlfriend.”

My blood turned to slush in my veins, and I couldn’t stop the accusing tone. “You have a girlfriend?”

He glared at Kimberly. “No. We broke up two months ago.”

Her face filled with shock, and then she had what looked like an epiphany. “You know, I wondered why you guys weren’t doing as many scenes together.” She shrugged, an ‘oh, well.’

“Can I walk you out?” he asked.

Oh, good lord. Weak knees and high heels were a terrible combination, and my car was a long way across the parking lot. Five whole spots. How the hell was I going to make it? I nodded slowly.

It was still warm, even though the sun was setting. My shoes clip-clopped on the broken pavement as I pointed out my piece-of-shit car. I’d spent so much of the day being nervous I no longer had a filter.

“You shot porn with your girlfriend?”

“Ex-girlfriend, but yeah, sometimes. Sometimes with other people.”

I couldn’t wrap my head around it. “She didn’t mind you sticking your dick in other women?”

“Not really. It didn’t bother me when she worked with other guys. I’m not the jealous type, and it’s acting.”

“Oh.” He probably had no idea, but his comment stung. I’d foolishly thought there’d been more than just acting between us.

When we reached my car, he stopped and put his hands on his hips, facing me. “Sex on screen with other people is okay. It’s just about money and getting off. But kissing someone else . . . that’s different.”

Kimberly’s teasing replayed in my mind. Kissing meant something to Scott. A connection possibly more intimate than sex. “You kissed me.”

A slow smile dawned on his lips. “Yeah. More than once.”

Butterflies and jelly knees. God, was I a teenager?

He closed the distance between us, setting one hand in the small of my back and the other on my cheek. “I’m going to kiss you again, and then you’re going to come home with me.”

I was thrilled, but I tried to play it cool. “That’s presumptuous.”

“It’s a fact,
Nina
.”

I shivered. “Oh, really?”

“Really. There’s an enormous puddle of coolant under this car. It’s not going anywhere.”

“Oh, no.” I glanced down and a puddle of purple-green fluid reflected back at me. Scott was absolutely right. My bottle of coolant in the backseat was almost empty—there was no way I’d make it back home.

I opened my mouth to say something, although I wasn’t sure what, but he cut me off. His lips sealed over mine, kissing me with complete abandon. I balled my fists into his shirt, greedy for the contact. It did feel far more intimate than anything else we’d done.

He took my hand in his and tugged me toward his car on the opposite side of the lot. “This works out better all around,” he said.

“How exactly does my POS car needing a new radiator work out better?” I muttered.

He unlocked his car and pulled open the passenger door for me. “I have a friend who just opened a new club, and I know he’d love to meet you. How do you feel about being tied up or blindfolded during sex?”

My brain stumbled over his question. “It’s . . . fine, I guess. I haven’t really done it.”

“You haven’t?” His tone was pleasantly surprised. “The girls at Joseph’s club make a ton of money. Triple that check in your purse.”

I froze. “Triple a week?”

“A night.”

Nina the office temp died from shock. “Scott, I need a favor.”

He gazed at me as if reading my thoughts. “You want me to blindfold you and tie you up, and see if you’re into it?” He laughed at my serious expression. “Oh, you will be, but don’t worry. We can do it anyway, just to be sure.”

I grinned and got into his car.

*     *     *

Thank you so much for reading!

I hope you enjoyed this prequel to my sweet and sexy Blindfold Club series. The first three full-length books are already available, with the fourth book releasing in January 2016. Make sure you have a fire extinguisher handy before reading!

Three Simple Rules

WEBSITE
 |
FACEBOOK
 |
TWITTER

Pam Godwin

P
rayer was one
way to cope with the end of the world. The lethal edge of my sword was another. Either might’ve saved me from the five-and-a-half-feet of temptation that slept in my bed. But I’d brought her here, invited her into my underground bunker to give her a safe place to hide, and now I never wanted her to leave. In a way, I’d already surrendered.