Because once their beliefs were accepted to be true, they had won.
*****
Daniel was watching something that he had never dreamed of seeing once in his entire life, and still questioned whether he was hallucinating at that very moment from what his eyes were showing him. As he sat on the bed in which he, Triska, Alyssa, Specca, and Squeak had all not only slept in together during the night but also engaged in carnal acts of lust and love with each other all throughout the midnight hours, he could only watch as he was rendered speechless at seeing those same four girls standing in front of the bed as they were slowly getting dressed for the day. Everything seemed to be like a surreal dream for Daniel as he watched all the naked girls talking and giggling with one another as they apparently wanted this to be the outcome of their feud over his heart all along.
His eyes watched, along with a quickly beating heart, as Triska slowly put her panties back on, the girl slowly tracing her hands up her legs to her hips in almost a teasing manner before she picked up her bra just stared at it reluctantly. After a moment to think about it she tossed the lingerie aside with a laugh before the girls all started laughing together.
“Guess I won’t need that anymore, no sense being the odd girl out,” Triska mused playfully with a shrug before looking to Specca with a smirk. The nixie slowly slipped on her petal skirt and adjusted it around her waist, her slender tail slowly swaying behind her as she glanced to Triska with an amused smile.
“I’m still the only one here not wearing panties, doesn’t that make
me
the odd girl out?” she asked in both jest and some slight concern. She then jumped with a surprised yelp as she felt a few fingers slide along between her thighs and against her pussy, the nixie then seeing Squeak winking at her with a squeak before she shrugged as the other girls laughed a bit at the sight.
“Squeak, not now,” Specca said bashfully as she blushed and looked down timidly.
“You like getting wet and you know it,” Alyssa giggled as she slipped back on her stockings, with Triska watching her blushing nixie friend with a curious smile and Squeak casually playing with her fingers as she had some juices on them from Specca. Alyssa then started to pull her panties up before she glanced to Triska with an amused smile.
“Yep yep, I think we all learned what each of us likes to get turned on with, isn’t that right,
Triska
?” she pointed out knowingly. Triska blushed slightly as she put her pants back on and buckled her belt again.
“We all have our fetishes, not going to lie about that. Like how you seemed to have an orgasm every time Daniel does you in the ass,” she said before turning to Alyssa with an accusing smile, with Daniel blushing even more from hearing that. Specca and Squeak smiled amusedly at the two girls as Alyssa put her skirt back on then set her hands at her hips.
“There’s nothing wrong with that, it feels simply amazing to feel him all the way inside of me. I’ve always known my butt is just too cute to resist. Besides, I’m not the one who likes to be punished like a bad girl, like
somebody
I know,” she quipped, with Triska blushing more and looking away while holding her arms around herself. Specca giggled then gently held Triska from behind while watching Alyssa with a knowing smile.
“Now now, Alyssa, you were quite the naughty girl last night too, and you certainly begged for some discipline of your own,” she mentioned, causing Alyssa to blush more and look down while Triska glanced to her with a small smile. Specca smirked and eyed Triska while leaning in closer to her ear.
“Did you at least learn your lesson last night?” she whispered playfully. Triska closed her eyes and quickly pulled away from her before grabbing her shirt and putting it on, with Specca watching her curiously as the teen adjusted her breasts under it before crossing her arms and looking to the nixie with a precocious smile.
“Nope,” she said before glancing away with a smug grin.
“I had a feeling neither of you would have,” Specca reasoned with an amused smile before she put her shirt back on and started tying her tie. Squeak began squeaking something as she got dressed with her panties and then her tunic, the ant girl going on and on about something while she put her gloves on and then her boots. The other girls watched her curiously as the ant girl once again failed to realize that her long speech about something, which with her hand signals going every which way wasn’t helping to clarify what she was talking about, was going right over everyone’s heads. After Squeak finished talking about whatever it was she was trying to talk about she looked at the other girls with a curious smile, gently patting down her tunic as everyone just stared at her in silence.
“She’s trying to tell us something,” Alyssa said after a while, with Squeak sighing and looking down with a troubled frown as she once again failed to communicate with her friends. Specca smiled curiously as she slipped her sandals back on then reached over and scratched her nails along Squeak’s abdomen, the ant girl squeaking loudly as her body shuddered in response before she looked to Specca with a blush on her face.
“Maybe she was trying to say how much she likes having her abdomen being scratched,” Specca mused, with Squeak looking down with an embarrassed smile as the other girls giggled to that.
“Yeah, that’s right, she sure seemed to go crazy whenever we did that to her last night,” Triska mentioned.
“I think we know what she and Daniel did on her date night, that little cat scratching gesture she gave then makes much more sense now,” Alyssa said before the girls laughed a bit, with Squeak nodding and glancing to them with a timid expression. Specca gently ran her tail along Squeak’s abdomen with a curious smile before Triska reached over stroked her ear fin, the nixie yelping a bit before glancing to Triska with a blush forming on her face.
“Did Daniel use your little weak spot during your date night as well?” Triska asked curiously before Specca gently swatted her hand away and held a hand to her cheek.
“No, nothing like that, we just cuddled and read a book together, that was more than enough to make the night complete for me,” Specca defended.
“Seeing as how she couldn’t keep her voice down at all when we did that to her, it sounds like that little secret was a secret until last night,” Alyssa giggled, with Specca smiling bashfully and looking down.
“It
was
,” she agreed before looking to the others with a small shrug. The girls all smiled at each other then looked to Daniel, the boy just staring at them with a stunned expression, a blush on his cheeks, and a noticeable erection that all the girls instantly took notice of.
“Daniel,” Triska purred with a slick smile.
“Oh
my
,” Specca said holding a hand over her chest.
“Well then, looks like
you’re
up for the day,” Alyssa said coyly, with Daniel looking down to his body’s honest reaction before he quickly smiled nervously and pulled a sheet over his lap. The girls all laughed a bit while Daniel wasn’t sure what to say right now with everything he was hearing and seeing.
“So, Daniel, I think we need to talk about our sleeping arrangement, now that we’ve crossed this threshold of which there is no going back,” Triska mentioned as she slipped back on her boots, with Daniel looking to her with puzzlement before seeing the girls watching him with gentle smiles as they all had finished getting dressed.
“Yes, I believe she’s right. Since we’ve all expressed our true feelings for one another last night, we need to agree on how we’re going to be handling all of us sleeping together every night,” Specca pointed out as she adjusted her glasses before brushing down her shirt to make sure it was wrinkle free.
“I think our date nights are over. Since Daniel chose all of us, we’re all going to be sleeping with him every night now, right?” Alyssa reasoned while looking to the other girls, with Daniel jumping a bit as they all nodded in agreement.
“Wait, so then, what are you saying we do differently now?” Daniel asked. The girls looked to one another then to Daniel with gentle smiles.
“Just what we said, Daniel, you did choose us all, right?” Specca replied with a small shrug, getting only a few nods out of Daniel in response.
“So then you’re going to take responsibility for that and take care of us all,
equally
, right?” Triska asked with an accusing smile. Daniel jumped a bit then nodded quickly.
“That means you have to love us all, each night, and every day too, hee hee,” Alyssa giggled, with Daniel showing a nervous smile to that.
“Um, what do you mean… by that… exactly?” Daniel asked carefully.
Squeak started squeaking while gesturing around to all the other girls before she made small hops with high pitched squeaks, her breasts bouncing under her tunic as she showed a lustful expression while looking up with pleading eyes before watching Daniel with a knowing smile. Daniel blinked then looked at the other girls with a nervous expression as he had a good idea what they were expecting of him now.
“Um, what?” he asked slowly.
“You know what, Daniel,” Alyssa replied coyly. Daniel looked around at the girls as they all watched him with immoral smirks, something that stood out a bit with Triska and Specca, not so much with Squeak, and certainly not at all with Alyssa, then slowly nodded as he felt there was no playing dumb with this.
“Right, I get it. Um… so…” he said hesitantly.
“Daniel,” Specca said worriedly, with him seeing her watching him with a saddened smile as all the girls showed concern as well.
“Don’t you want us?” the nixie asked softly.
“This is what we want, isn’t it what you want too?” Triska asked with a troubled look.
“You can’t just use Squeak’s pheromones all the time to love us, you have to want to too,” Alyssa pouted with a frown.
Squeak nodded and squeaked something while holding her arms around herself with a saddened expression.
Daniel looked around at the girls then shook his head as he quickly stood up before them, with the girls glancing down to his penis as the sheet dropped down, since they just couldn’t help themselves, before looking back into his eyes as he showed a caring smile while holding his hands out at his sides.
“Of course this is what I want, I couldn’t bear to live without any of you, that’s the truth, I promise. I love you all, I really do, and I don’t need Squeak’s pheromones to show you that. I’ll make sure you feel loved and that you know just how much I care about all of you, equally, just like I said,” he reassured. The girls all smiled in relief as he rubbed the back of his neck with an embarrassed chuckle.
“Besides, after using Squeak’s pheromones I couldn’t really recall most of what happened last night. I remember some parts, but most of it was a blur to me. I don’t want to miss out on a thing with you girls, with everything we do and share with one another, so of course I would prefer not to use her pheromones again. The next time we do anything, to any extent, I want to remember every detail so that I can treasure every second I spend with you girls,” he promised assuredly. The girls all giggled a bit and nodded before Daniel looked down thoughtfully, his eyes darting around in thought as the girls watched him curiously.
“Daniel? What is it?” Triska asked. Daniel blinked then looked to the girls while showing a troubled expression.
“Um, maybe I just can’t recall from last night after being affected by Squeak’s pheromones, but did anyone hear anything from Charlotte or her helpers last night before they left?” he asked glancing around, noticing that Apoch, Astreal, and Charlotte’s cat were not there anymore. The girls all looked to each other then to him with concern while shaking their heads.
“No, I didn’t even notice them leaving last night, I don’t think they said anything to us,” Triska said with a shrug.
“Oh dear, I hope Daniel proved his point to Charlotte last night, I mean he actually did
all
of us, surely that had to have shown her that his beliefs are accurate, right?” Specca reasoned worriedly.
“Well, they didn’t slit my throat last night when Daniel was doing me, that’s a good sign,” Alyssa mentioned while holding a hand over her neck.
Squeak merely shrugged with a simple squeak, figuring that even if the witches had said anything to her last night she’d likely not be able to convey it properly now anyway.
Daniel thought about their options carefully, wondering if he had proved his belief to Charlotte and whether he would hear from her again, then showed a calm smile and looked to the four girls before him, feeling content knowing that either way he had at least taken hold of what really did mean the world to him.
Without another word he moved forward to pull Triska into a kiss, the girl jumping a bit at first from the gesture then closing her eyes as the other girls watched them curiously. Triska slowly held her hands to his bare chest as she felt her heart fluttering from his touch, the kiss alone quelling all fears she had about the alpha witch from last night.
‘Daniel… I love you so much.’
Daniel then let go of Triska, the girl blinking once before looking at him with wonder and a faint blush, and then gently pulled Specca into a kiss, the nixie sighing softly while closing her eyes as her tail slowly wrapped around his leg. He held her by the arms gently yet securely, making the timid nixie feel weak in the knees as she yearned to be held by him always.
‘He truly is my knight in shining armor, my Daniel.’
After her kiss was done, and he nonchalantly used one hand to loosen the nixie’s tail from around his leg as she was reluctant to let him go, Daniel then pulled Squeak over into a kiss, the ant girl holding onto his waist while closing her eyes in the embrace. Daniel felt the girl’s saliva hitting with a powerful effect right away, however he focused his mind more on the fact that he loved this ant girl and was happier about the fact that she was going to be his. As for Squeak, she too felt her love for this human very clearly, being evidenced by a small wiggle of her abdomen behind her and a quiet sigh of joy from the kiss, and knew that he was the only guy in Eden for her.