Brush Back (18 page)

“If she has enough money to bribe a Cook County judge, why is she still in South Chicago?” Sal asked.

“There’s that,” I agreed. “The money is a big question mark in the middle of this. Stella kept up payments on the house while she was in Logan. Frank told me she used his dad’s insurance to cover the mortgage—Mateo Guzzo’s pension disappeared when the mill went bankrupt. Mandel or McClelland, or Rory Scanlon, are the folks who would have known how to bribe a judge.”

“Maybe Annie had more than two thousand in her bra drawer,” Sal suggested. Her mind was on the room: the pre-theater crowd was starting to build, people who can’t get through the first act without a double something. “I don’t really see what it has to do with you, girlfriend.”

She swept off, her long feather earrings bobbing in rhythm with her stride. I put the rest of my second drink back on the bar—I’d breathalyze myself if I had any more whisky, as tired as I was.

Jake said something similar when I got home, not about the whisky, but the investigation: even if Betty had murdered Annie and blackmailed or bullied Stella into taking the rap, why was it my business? We were on my back porch with a bottle of Torgiano, watching Mr. Contreras and the dogs down in the garden.

“But this is good news,” Bernie objected. She’d come home from her first day of work so filled with caffeine that I’d sent her out for a run with the dogs. When she brought them back forty minutes later, she still had energy to burn. “I thought you were doing nothing, but I see you are working hard. Now this man, this Uncle Jerry, he is so scared of you he goes running to his priest.”

After another minute of energetic speculating on what Stella would do next and how we could retaliate, Bernie ran down the back stairs to rejoin Mr. Contreras and the dogs.

“You scare me, too, V.I.,” Jake grumbled. “If I thought running to a priest would do me any good I’d be on my way to church right now. I wish you’d give up on these Guzzos. You’re not getting paid, and when these people get into your dreams, I’m the one who gets punched.”

“I’ll put Mitch into bed between us,” I offered. “He’s tough enough to wrassle with me.”

Mitch seemed to know I was talking about him—he lifted his great black head and grinned up the stairs at me.

“Do that, Warshawski, and you will be startled by how fast I can wrap a bass string around your neck.”

“Those strings set you back six hundred dollars,” I said. “You sure you can afford to strangle me?”

“Yep, you’re right, best use my hands.”

We put the matter behind us and went out to catch a show with a friend of his who played oboe. One thing led to another and we ended up dancing at Hot Rococo until after midnight.

The Guzzos got into my sleep, not enough that I started punching Jake, but enough that I woke around six the next morning. When I realized I wasn’t going back to sleep I stared enviously at Jake. He was beautiful in sleep, his black hair falling over his forehead, his long fingers curled around the corner of his pillow. I stroked his shoulder and his muscles rippled, but he didn’t wake up.

I gave it up and went next door into my own place, where Bernie, of course, was heavily asleep in the living room. She also didn’t stir, not even when I rummaged noisily in my bag for my laptop.

While my espresso machine heated, I looked up Stella’s trial again. The street kids had interrupted me yesterday and I’d forgotten to go back to look for the judge’s name. It had been a guy named Elgin Grigsby, not one I’d ever encountered, but there are some five hundred judges in Cook County.

Grigsby had survived the Greylord scandal and had taken an honorable retirement from the bench four years ago. He was “of counsel” at the downtown firm where he’d started his career before joining the bench. Grigsby wintered in Arizona, but had returned to his Chicago condo a few weeks ago. I did a double take when I saw the address: the judge was living in the Pulteney building on Wabash where I used to have my office.

When I rented at the Pulteney, the elevator worked about half the time, the wiring was so old that you needed special battery interfaces to run a computer, and I could have retired if I’d been able to charge union scale for repairing the women’s toilet.

After the owners forced out me and the other hardy renters—by cutting off utilities while still holding on to our rent money—they’d gutted the place and turned it into high-end condos.

It was Saturday, not a day for business cold calls. I put work behind me for the weekend, but Monday morning, I took the L to the Loop. Maybe because of the iron girders down the middle of the block, this stretch of Wabash still looked tawdry. Arnie’s Steak Joynt was still flashing its neon on one corner, and the bar that used to make me think I was catching some bad disease was still in business across the street from it.

This made the rehabbed lobby of the Pulteney all the more striking when I went inside. I’d always wondered what lay under the decades of grime that crusted the mosaic floor. Pharaohs, elongated cats, boats on the Nile. The Pulteney apparently went up in the 1920s, at the height of the Egyptian craze that followed the discovery of King Tut’s tomb.

In addition to legal odd jobs, Judge Grigsby worked as a docent for the Chicago Architecture Foundation; his shift started at ten, his wife had told me when I’d called earlier. He could give me forty-five minutes before strolling over to Michigan Avenue to start his tour.

The doorman, in white gloves so as not to smudge the Art Deco figurines when he held the brass elevator doors open for me, phoned upstairs to confirm the appointment. White gloves, polished brass, even an indie coffee bar in the lobby, while management had sucked up my rent money for fifteen years without bringing the electrics up to code. I rode to the seventeenth floor, trying not to let sour grapes make me sour-faced.

I had done as much research on Grigsby as I could without talking to anyone. I didn’t want him to know I was asking questions, since even a retired judge in Cook County has a lot of people owing him favors. Grigsby had been elected—over and over—with a “Qualified” rating from the Illinois Bar Association. Sort of like being a reliable C or B student. He and his wife, Marjorie, had been married forty-seven years next month; they had five children and seven grandchildren. Besides his judge’s pension, he had a nice little portfolio that brought in almost four hundred thousand a year, letting him maintain condos in Scottsdale and Chicago.

I’d found photos of Grigsby online at all sorts of regular Democratic Party functions. He’d been at fund-raisers with Illinois House Speaker Spike Hurlihey, with ward committeemen, the head of Streets & San—crucial for getting out the vote, even in these supposedly post-patronage years—and various senators, representatives, corporate leaders. Even Darraugh Graham, my own most important client, had been in one shot. I was pretty sure Darraugh voted Republican, but in Cook County, anyone trying to do business shows up at Democratic political functions.

Grigsby’s apartment was in the southeast corner of the building. The judge, in an open-necked shirt and soft sports jacket, had the door open and called to me to come to the front room. He was looking out across the Art Institute at the fringe of trees along Lake Michigan. The south view showed the L tracks that used to run past my office window—I’d been on the fourth floor, where I could look into commuters’ faces as the trains rattled by.

“Ms. Warshawski? A good Chicago name. I never get tired of watching the city from up here. I grew up in Back of the Yards and Gage Park and I never imagined back then that I would be living among the chardonnay drinkers downtown. How about you?”

“South Chicago,” I obliged. “And I still don’t live among the chardonnay drinkers.”

We picked our way through each other’s career highlights—me,
University of Chicago Law Review
, clerking for a judge in the Seventh Circuit, my time with the criminal public defender (“Step down for a
Law Review
student, wasn’t it?” the judge commented). Him, DePaul University law, assistant state’s attorney, partner at a big downtown firm, followed by thirty-three years on the bench. Prosecutors move up, defenders move down, law of the jungle.

I told Grigsby about the decade I’d spent in this building, and my envy of the space as it looked now. He threw back his head, laughing, as if delighted that he had something I couldn’t afford. It didn’t surprise me: growing up behind the old stockyards, you competed for every beam of sunlight that filtered through the haze of blood and smoke.

He was drinking coffee but didn’t offer me any. Power play, assertion of status, obliviousness, maybe all three.

“Judge, I know you’re busy, and this is a long shot, but an old South Chicago murder has been rattling cages lately. The case was tried in your court.”

He nodded over the rim of the cup. “Stella Guzzo. I looked her up when I saw the news—Boom-Boom War— Oh. Your family? Cousin? That explains why you’re nosing around the story.”

I eyed him thoughtfully. “I wonder who told you I was ‘nosing around’?”

“It’s not a secret. You’ve been talking to some of the lawyers that I’ve known for decades.”

“I haven’t been talking to Nina Quarles, because she’s in France. Sol Mandel is dead, his partner’s retired. Ira Previn come to you?”

“He didn’t come to me, but we eat breakfast at the same restaurant when he has an early court date. He’s worried you digging up old dirt might hurt his son.”

I watched the Dan Ryan L chug down Wabash, the Ravenswood passing it in the opposite direction. The double glazing shut out street noise; it was like watching toy trains in a paperweight.

“No questions of mine could give Joel more pain than he’s already feeling. People who knew him back then tell me that he was afraid, not of what would happen at the trial, but what would happen to him if he refused to defend Stella Guzzo. How did that play out in your courtroom?”

“Who told you Joel was afraid?” Grigsby asked.

“I’ve talked to a lot of people this week, Judge; it seems to be the consensus.”

“Ira never said anything about that.” Grigsby’s voice took on an edge.

“He may not have realized it. He worried more about the mistakes Joel was making in the trial. How bad did Joel look?”

“You’re asking me to remember details from a case more than two decades old.” Grigsby’s voice was sharp—objection sustained.

“That was your reputation on the bench.” I smiled winningly, using the soothing tone that had worked for me when I was a PD. Judges then hadn’t liked women attorneys who challenged their rulings. It had been an ongoing effort to curb my pit-dog instincts, but it often paid off. “When I was with the PD they used to call you ‘Wolf Trap Grigsby’ because facts stuck in your mind like a wolf in a trap.”

Grigsby looked startled, as well he might, since I’d made that up on the spot, but he preened a bit, asked if I’d ever appeared in front of him. Since he seemed well oiled, I repeated my question about Joel’s performance at Stella’s trial.

“She was a difficult client, unsympathetic. I knew dozens like her from growing up at Forty-seventh and Ashland—rock-hard women who had to fight for every piece of bread their children ate. My own mother, God rest her soul, was one of them. But Joel couldn’t make Guzzo look good to the jury, and he couldn’t control her in court. I had to reprimand him more than once. If he was afraid, it was of her—she’s probably haunted his nightmares ever since.”

“Why did Ira let Joel take that case? By all accounts Joel was in love, or at least infatuated with Annie Guzzo. For that matter, why did Mandel & McClelland want him to defend her killer? Mandel thought so highly of her he was funding her college education.”

Grigsby stiffened. “Funding her college education? What do you mean?”

“Hearsay, Judge, sorry. Her mother found thousands of dollars in Annie’s lingerie drawer—it was one of the things they fought about. Supposedly fought about. Annie told her mother that Sol Mandel gave her the money to help her get to college. Allegedly.”

“I hope you’re not suggesting any impropriety. Sol Mandel was a fine lawyer. We golfed together at Harborside many times. Many times.”

“No one has suggested anything out of line there, Judge. My mother gave Annie Guzzo piano lessons, and Sol Mandel probably saw the same qualities in her my mother did—ambitious, hardworking, wanting a chance to live a life away from South Chicago. The neighborhood gets a bad rap, like Back of the Yards used to, but there are plenty of decent people who want to help kids. Rory Scanlon, for instance. He made important connections for my cousin when Boom-Boom was starting out, and from what I hear, he’s still doing it for kids today.”

“Scanlon is still active?” The question was casual, but Grigsby eyed me closely, again using his coffee cup as cover.

“He’s apparently still working with kids and sports.”

“You’re an investigator, right?” Grigsby added. “Is someone paying you to poke around in this old case?”

Definitely a C student, if it had taken him this long to think up that question. I smiled again. “It’s such an odd case that people keep raising questions about it. During the trial, did Joel ever try to suggest Stella had been framed?”

“Every criminal defendant claims they’ve been framed. If you were with the County Criminal Defender’s office, you know that.”

I laughed, hoping he would think I was on his side. “Five million people in Cook County, but only three stories: ‘I wasn’t there,’ ‘I was set up,’ ‘It was a Vice Lord.’ But Stella is pointing a finger straight at Boom-Boom. I’m sure you’d remember if she suggested that at the trial. He was big news at the time.”

“She was convicted of a very heinous crime,” Grigsby said in his sternest courtroom voice. “She did her time. My best advice to you is to leave the trial alone. No good can come of scratching those old sores after all these years.”

“I don’t disagree, Judge, but, as I said, people keep coming to me with odd questions. Just yesterday, someone told me that Stella had been told she’d get an early release, despite the length of the sentence. Who would have made a promise like that?”