Authors: Iris Murdoch
I stared at her dim white face in the gathering darkness. I could not see her eyes, but I knew from the convulsive trembling of her body that she was crying. âSo soon,' I said. âWell, surely that is it, the final bond between us. You
can't
leave me now. Are you sure?' I was however instinctively appalled.
âYes. But Hilary, you haven't understood â '
âWhat â you mean â '
âYes. It's not your child, it's Gunnar's.'
A flood of icy coldness filled my heart and my veins. I kept my voice hard and steady. âYou mean it might be?'
âNo. It is. Because of the time. There isn't any doubt. I thought perhaps â but I kept wanting not to know. I only found out just now for certain â I thought it just couldn't be â and I really meant earlier to leave you â I meant to leave you as soon as Gunnar found out, I thought I'd have to â so I just â let things drift â and kept hoping it wasn't â and didn't go to the doctor â oh I've been so wicked, so stupid â '
âI see,' I said. âYou intended to leave me as soon as Gunnar found out. You never told me so.'
âI didn't intend anything. What could I do? I couldn't see what I would do. I'm caught. I love Gunnar. I love Tristram. It's my doom that I love you too. You don't know, even you don't know at all, what I've had to suffer in these last months â '
âYou sound quite resentful,' I said, keeping the cool hard tone.
âI suppose I am in a way. I was so happy â before you came along.'
âToo bad. I was so happy before you came along too.'
âThen it's plain â isn't it â we must part â oh God â we must both try to be â as we were before â it's such agony â I'm sorry, my darling, I'm very very very sorry â Please will you drive me home? Oh my God, I do love you, I do love you â But it's just hopeless â ' She was shuddering and wailing.
I said, âDoes Gunnar know?'
âAbout the baby? Yes.'
If only she had lied at that point. If only she had not told me that as well.
âSo he thinks you're tied to him â because of the bloody baby?'
âI am tied.'
âNo,' I said. âI'm afraid you aren't. You're wrong there. You're coming with me, baby and all. Wherever we're going now we're going together, my darling.' Fearful rage and misery possessed my body, making it violent, mechanical, precise. I started the car again and drove on.
âHilary, please take me home, please, please, please â '
I said nothing. We came onto the motorway.
âHilary, please don't drive so fast, do you want to kill us both â Hilary don't drive so fast â Hilary,
Hilary â
oh please please take me home â oh stop, stop, stop, don't drive so fast â '
The car crossed the central reservation at about a hundred miles an hour. It was a matter of chance which car on the other side we hit. We hit a Bentley driven by a stockbroker and travelling almost equally fast. Both cars were completely smashed and six other cars were severely damaged. The stockbroker escaped with two broken legs. No one else was badly hurt except me and Anne. I had multiple injuries. Anne died in hospital on the following day.
I never doubted that I had behaved wickedly. That knowledge I carried away with me into the years to come. But the thing itself as we lived it was such a complex of contradictions and misunderstandings and mistakes and little makeshifts and sheer blind muddled waiting and hoping. How could we know that it was wending its way to that end? I was dreadfully in love with the sort of black certain metaphysical love that cuts deeper than anything and thus seems its own absolute justification.
On n'aime qu'une fois, la première.
I think this is true of the one and only Eros. Though also perhaps the one and only Eros is not the greatest of all the gods. Anne was dreadfully in love too, but her love was crazed, crazed with the hopelessness of it all, which perhaps she saw and I did not. She loved her husband; and I could
remember,
even at the times of blackest glory, how happy she had been when I first met her; and I could see too how destroyed she was later, destroyed by me and by my terrible love.
I thought later on, as the years passed in almost uninterrupted meditation upon the events of that summer, that I had perhaps overestimated the force of her passion. It may have been so. Even if she had not discovered that she was pregnant would she ever really have decided to leave Gunnar and come to me? What went on between them after Gunnar found out? This I did not know or want to know. On the other hand, if I had not become mad with rage at what she told me, if I had simply driven her away with me on that night, was it conceivable that she would have stayed with me, would not her tears have forced me finally to take her home to Gunnar and Tristram? Of course she loved me, that could not be doubted. Perhaps she was impressed by the force of my love; being thus impressed is as good a cause of real love as another. If only she had not come back to me after that first kiss. If only she had not told me that Gunnar knew she was pregnant. That revelation had some sort of terrible importance at that moment. If she had not told me it would all have seemed a problem, an obstacle, something to be dealt with by me, I would not have been precipitated straight into fury and despair. There are those who hold that the world is well lost for love. I did not think this. I loved Anne with a concentration of my whole being which could only happen once. But I wished forever that I had not. I wished I had never met her. For the world was lost indeed, and I had lost it not only for myself but for Crystal.
I resigned my fellowship of course. Gunnar also resigned. He went into politics for a short time, contested a Labour seat, then entered the Civil Service and began to become a successful and famous man. I was (I think this describes it) ill for years. Not really mentally ill. I never thought I would go mad. But I was simply crushed, unmanned. I had lost my moral self-respect and with it my ability to control my life. Sin and despair are mixed and only repentance can change sin into pure pain. I could not clean the resentment out of my misery. Did I repent? That question troubled me as the years went by. Can something half crushed and bleeding repent? Can that fearfully complex theological concept stoop down into the real horrors of human nature? Can it, without God, do so? I doubt it. Can sheer suffering redeem? It did not redeem me, it just weakened me further. I, who had so long cried out for justice, would have been willing to pay, only I had nothing to pay with and there was no one to receive the payment. I knew I had killed Anne (and her unborn child) almost as surely as if I had hit her with an axe. The business was brilliantly hushed up by Gunnar. (No wonder he succeeded later in high level diplomacy.) He put it around that I was kindly giving Anne a lift to London. Later my name was dropped from the story altogether. I disappeared from Oxford as if I had never existed. Much later I heard someone say that Gunnar Jopling's first wife had died by crashing her car. I imagined that I would carry the placard
Murderer
around my neck forever. But people have their own troubles and tend to forget. One is not all that interesting. Even Hitler is being forgotten at last.
Crystal of course was perfect. It was for a little while unclear whether I would live. I lived and completely recovered. Crystal sat by me for weeks and months. I did not tell her everything at once, but in the end I did tell her everything. She knew we were both done for. She was perfect. I could not work for a year, not because of my bodily health but because I was in despair. I suffered an agony of remorse about Anne which bit me physically, doubling me up for whole parts of the day. I had a problem about responsibility for the past which became a problem of identity. I mourned and mourned about the destruction of my hopes. The loss of Oxford, of learning and scholarship and improvement, the loss of Crystal's metamorphosis and Crystal's happiness. I went back to the north and lived for a year with Crystal in one room in the town where I was born. People who had known me and envied me came to survey with satisfaction the wreckage of clever ambitious fortunate Hilary Burde. (A pity Aunt Bill missed that. She would have loved it.) Mr Osmand had already left the town. I hoped he never heard. I wept over Crystal. She wept over me. She supported me by returning to work in the chocolate factory. To this day the smell of chocolate brings back the horror of that time.
It would of course have been possible to recover and to set out once more on the quest of all the things I wanted and had so largely got when I met Anne. Oxford would be impossible of course, but there were other universities where I could have set myself up, where I could have educated Crystal and lived something like the sort of life which I had coveted. It would have been possible to do this in the sense that someone else in similar circumstances might have been able to do it. I was not able. At any rate I did not do it. Paradoxically, I might have survived better alone. It was the thought of Crystal's suffering, her loss, her disappointment that was my chief millstone; and grief itself sapped the will to find any remedy. I just wanted to die, at least that was my mood. I could not loll myself because of Crystal. I wanted to hide. After the year in the north I went to London, as criminals and destroyed people do, because it is the best place to hide. And I hid. And Crystal came and hid with me. I got a job as a clerk in a car hire firm. I lost the job when I was required to do some driving. I had been banned from driving for life after the accident. I got a little job with an estate agent, then a little job in a local government office. At last I gravitated into the civil service, at the humble level at which I had remained ever since until I almost began to think of myself as an old man.
Gunnar had vanished from my life, as I imagined forever. As he became more important and successful I began to hear of him, to read about him in the newspapers, but though these reminders jabbed like daggers it was news of a stranger. Gunnar was a big international man, someone existing in Brussels, in Geneva, in Washington, in New York, never to cross my path again. I only saw him once after the accident. He came to see me in the hospital as soon as I was able to talk. (My jaw was smashed and speech was impossible for some time.) He was cold and civil and asked me, as if he were a police officer investigating some minor offence, to tell him about the accident. I told him; at least I told him the mechanical details, the speed of the car, the way it somersaulted. The crash had deprived me of consciousness and I did not see Anne after the moment of impact. He asked nothing more. He went away without any show of emotion, without any remark or look which could establish a connection between us. And at his cue I was equally cold. Later I went over and over this last meeting in my mind thinking of things I might have said. âI'm sorry. Forgive me.' Yet how could I, without help from him, have said that? If only he had shown a flicker of emotion I could have burst out to him. But there was no emotion and no outburst. I thought later of writing to him, but I never wrote. Tristram committed suicide at the age of sixteen.
I
T WAS Saturday morning. It was a cold day with a lot of low scurrying brown clouds and a bitterly cold wind and a few flashes of watery sun which simply showed up how wet and muddy London was. I had had bad dreams, most of which I had forgotten, the atmosphere of horror only remaining. Would that our sins had built-in qualities of oblivescence such as our dreams have. One dream I remembered. I was in a quiet awful place beside some water where some huge crime either had been committed in the past or would be committed in the future. Not knowing which was part of the dreadfulness of the dream.
This morning I heartily regretted having told Arthur. At the time I had felt relieved to tell. There had been an almost orgiastic satisfaction in doing so. I had sent Arthur out to get some wine, and I had drunk a great deal. This morning I felt terrible, sick and giddy and disgusted with myself. I ate three aspirins and drank a great deal of water. It was not that I doubted Arthur's discretion or that I minded his knowing. This knowledge, which would have been intolerable inside almost anyone else's head, was harmless in Arthur's. It just now seemed a terrible mistake to have relived it all. All that immodest spewing talk, all those eloquent emotional drunken words, had made the whole thing hideously more vivid. Even my dull stripped flat gave back the dreadful resonance. I had stripped the flat as I had stripped my life in a vain attempt to remove from it anything which could remind me of Anne. Today, opening my Polish dictionary, I found a pressed flower, a white violet, which she had espied in her garden and given me during that charmed and innocent time when I loved her and she did not yet know it.
The day began with a letter from Tommy.
Dear heart, I am sorry I was so useless last night and please forgive what I said about Laura Impiatt, I know that was just stupid. You know I love you and I want to marry you, but I want most of all to take pain away from you and I'm sure if you would only share your woes with me you would feel better. I can't believe that you ever did anything really bad, but even if you did I feel that you ought to forgive yourself. Guilt does no good to anyone, does it? Anyway I forgive you, on behalf of God. Won't you take that from me as a Christmas present? I feel I love you so much that I am able (and so on and so on)
I thought it was rather touching of Tommy to offer me God's forgiveness for Christmas, especially as she did not know what I had done, and I realized that I was lucky to be loved by a girl as intelligent and nice as Tommy, but she was simply no use to me at all and I wished her at the devil.
The electricity was still off. The flat was extremely cold. I was wearing a jersey and an overcoat and felt awkward and bulky and still frozen. I burnt myself lighting a spirit stove to boil a kettle. Mr Pellow knocked on the door, asking if we could spare him a candle. I told him we could not. Later I caught Christopher sneaking out with a candle for Mr Pellow. I confiscated it. Christopher told me that Mick Ladderslow had been arrested in connection with the Steal for Chairman Mao Campaign, and would I perhaps put up some money to bail him out of prison? I would not. Christopher went away and started practising his tabla. I told him to shut up. He came back into the kitchen and broke the spirit stove by turning the handle too hard. I told him I had had enough of him and he could clear out, but he took no notice as I often said this. Jimbo Davis arrived looking spiritual and carrying some evergreen branches. He took my hand in an (or did I imagine it?) especially sympathetic way, murmuring âyes, yes â ' He and Christopher retired into Christopher's room where they laughed a lot, doubtless at my expense.
Laura Impiatt arrived. I passionately did not want to see her, but had not the spirit to invent an immediate lie. (âOh what a shame, I am just this moment leaving for Hounslow.') Today, although it was not raining, she was wearing a huge yellow sou'wester tied under the chin, a quilted mackintosh coat and blue serge trousers pulled in above her ankles with bicycle clips. She did not take her coat off. We sat at the kitchen table, two bulky cold muffled up objects with red noses. She wanted coffee but there was now no way of boiling a kettle. We peered at each other in the gloom.
âHilary, will you be able to bear it if Crystal marries Arthur?'
âDon't be silly, Laura, just don't be silly, there's a dear.'
âI know how close you are to Crystal.'
âI want her to marry Arthur.'
âThen why were you almost mad with misery on Thursday?'
âI wasn't, I had toothache. Arthur is a splendid chap.'
âArthur is not exactly a catch.'
âBeggars can't be choosers. Crystal is not exactly an English Rose.'
âI'm surprised to hear you talk like that about Crystal.'
âI can see what's obvious, even about my sister. She's lucky to have a suitor at all.'
âI would have expected you to be more sort of fastidious.'
âWho am I to be sort of fastidious.'
âBut don't you
care
? And you can't be serious about marrying Tommy.'
âWho said I was marrying Tommy?'
âYou did, on Thursday.'
âI was just saying anything that came into my head to shut you up.'
âHow nice of you! You know, Hilary, you don't value yourself enough. There's so much of you and you make so little of it. It's as if you'd lost all your courage, just absolutely lost your nerve.'
âThat's right.'
âBut why? Hilary, you
must
tell me. It would do you good to tell it all to somebody. I know there's
something.
Hilary, let me help you. I love you, my dear, let me help. Don't just throw yourself away. I know you need a home, and you'll need it all the more if Crystal marries. Lean on me, use me. You know you have a home with us at Queen's Gate Terrace. It could be much more to you if only you'd open yourself a little. We are childless. Freddie's very fond of you â '
âLaura, I shall be sick.'
âOh, my dear, I know you so well. I do. Just relax, you're all tense, you're so physically tense, relax, see, your hands are all knotted up â '
âIt's so bloody cold.'
Laura had taken one of my hands and was kneading it enthusiastically between her own. Her hands in fact were so cold that the process, even if I had cared for it in general, would have brought little relief. I closed my eyes in an absolute gesture of despair. I wanted to scream at Laura, to terrify her. Anne's face appeared with a hallucinatory clarity in the domed darkness, as if cast by a magic lantern onto the London night sky. I must write my letter of resignation. I must do it this morning. I must be gone before he arrived. The âI'm sorry' which I could not say to him had been said often enough since, but it did no good, there was no one to listen.
At that moment the electricity suddenly came on and the kitchen leapt into bright light. The boys cheered. I removed my hand from Laura's cold clasp.
The front door bell rang. I went to the door. It was the telephone engineer. I stared at him stupidly.
âIt's the boss in person. Hello.'
âBut the telephone,' I said. âYou've done all that, haven't you? There's nothing more to do, is there? It's all gone away.'
âTelephone? What's that? I'm not on duty.'
âWhat?'
âThis is a social call, man. I'm here as Len, not for Her Majesty.'
âYou want Christopher.'
âThis is where we came in.'
âWhat?'
âYou just said “you want Christopher”. That's what you said to me the first time.'
âWell, do you?'
âI think it's an indelicate question.'
I called âChristopher!' and went back to the kitchen leaving the front door open. Christopher emerged. Laura said to me, âI must have a word with Christopher. Freddie wants him to write some music for
It is later than you think.
'
â
It is later than you think.
Yes, indeed.'
âWhy, hello, Len, how nice! Len and I are old friends!'
âAre you, Laura?'
Christopher and Len and Laura were filling the kitchen with chatter. Jimbo, still in Christopher's room, was arranging the green branches in a vase. Through the still open front door I saw Biscuit standing on the landing wearing a sari.
I went out to her slowly, pulling the door to behind me.
The sari was a plain bluish-purple with a wide golden border. She had been wearing a coat over it but had removed the coat. It was folded up neatly beside her on the floor. Her hair had been put up into an intricately woven glossy ball suspended somehow at the back of her head. This made her look older. And the sari gave her, in an odd way, a look of being in uniform, on duty. With the great erection of the hair the pale brown face looked thinner, the eyes huger, reflecting in their depths the bluish-purple tints of the gorgeous sari.
âHello, mystery girl.'
âHello, Hilary.'
âI'm Hilary today, am I? Why did you run away?'
I took her wrist lightly between my fingers. The bony feel of the wrist was already familiar. I moved my hand, caressing the wrist, taking her small hand, still lightly, in a full grasp. Her hand was moist and warm. It moved inside my hand like a snuggling animal.
âIt's full up in there,' I said, motioning over my shoulder at the flat.
âI'm sorry. Then will you come with me? Will you come with me to a café? I have got something to give you.' The way she said âto a café' sounded curiously foreign and the phrase had a ridiculously improper ring about it.
I looked down at her. Her hand had reminded me of Anne's hand. Or rather, her hand had reminded my hand. My hand did not know that Anne was dead and that twenty years had passed and that I was a murderer. Gunnar must have seen Anne in the hospital before she died. What had happened to her face? Did he hold her in his arms when she was dying?
âWill you come with me, please?'
âNo,' I said, âI'm busy. I've got to write an important letter. I can't play games of will you won't you with mystery girls. Just fuck off and leave me alone, will you? I've got enough trouble without being persecuted by bloody tarts.'
I went back into the flat and slammed the door. Laura and the boys were making some coffee.
I was with Crystal. She was holding my hand. It seemed to be my day for holding hands with women. I now regretted having sent Biscuit away. I would like to have gone to bed with her. Presumably that was what it was all about. It would have distracted my mind. I wondered if she would ever come back again. She had looked very beautiful in her sari. And at least she was a little separate piece of possible future. I was rather short of future at present.
The electricity, much reduced in power, had remained on all day, and was still on, although further cuts were threatened.
I had eaten a little supper and drunk a great deal of the litre bottle of Spanish burgundy. Supper had consisted of steak and kidney pudding, out of a tin, brussels sprouts and mince pies. The white lace tablecloth was on, and I had spilt wine on it again. Crystal washed it snow-white every week.
âDo you still want to see the Christ Child in Regent Street?'
âOh â dearest â have you sent that letter yet?'
âI haven't written it yet.'
âMust you leave the office?'
âOf course.'
âYou needn't see him.'
âHe'd be there. And he'd know I was there.' How awful for Gunnar, it occurred to me, to find me infesting the place as a low form of life, a sort of loathsome beetle. âThe least I can do is be gone before he comes, not remind him that I exist.'
Crystal's rather square podgy face was all wrinkled up with anxiety and grief and love. Her frizzy orangy hair was tangled as she had been twisting it between her fingers earlier in the evening. She was wearing her glasses, gazing across the room with her enlarged golden eyes, staring at the row of ebony elephants that marched upon the sideboard and holding my hand in both of hers. Laura had kneaded, Biscuit had nuzzled. Crystal held steady, firm, the way you might hold someone's hand if he were going to be shot.
âI'll soon get another job,' I said. âAnd if I can't, you and Arthur can support me! I won't starve.'
âIf it would help if I stopped going with Arthur â '
âOh don't be idiotic, Crystal! If I could only be sure you were happy and looked after I'd â '
âWhat?'
âOh not kill myself or anything. Not even emigrate. I might marry Tommy.'
âWe'll lose each other,' said Crystal. She released my hand and turned to face me. She took off her glasses and looked at me with her beautiful truthful defenceless myopic eyes.
âDon't say that, darling. You know we can't lose each other. We are one.'
âI feel so frightened. There were funny noises downstairs last night.'
âOh nonsense.' Crystal had never had these sort of fears before. Or more likely, she had had them but had never troubled me with them.
âEverything's suddenly so frightening. Oh if only it hadn't happened, if only he hadn't come back. I feel the past will destroy us, something terrible will come out of the past and eat us up.'
âStop it, Crystal. I shall just take a new job, nothing else will happen.'
âI feel you're in danger. I prayed for you last night. I wish I really believed in God.'
âYour prayers will invent God. He'll have to exist just to receive them. I'll take you to Regent Street and we'll see the Christ Child, and we'll have a dinner out, shall we, like we did once. Oh Crystal, I do wish you could be happy. If I thought you could be happy I could simply cease to exist with a sigh of joy.'
âHow can I be happy when I know you suffer all the time, all the time, because of
that,
and now it's come after us like a â like a sort of demon of revenge â '