A Bright and Guilty Place: Murder, Corruption, and L.A.'s Scandalous Coming of Age
Read A Bright and Guilty Place: Murder, Corruption, and L.A.'s Scandalous Coming of Age Online
Authors: Richard Rayner
Tags: #History, #United States, #General, #20th Century, #True Crime
Also by Richard Rayner
Los Angeles Without a Map
The Elephant
The Blue Suit
Murder Book
The Cloud Sketcher
Drake’s Fortune
The Devil’s Wind
The Associates
For Paivi
and
Harry and Charlie
“Los Angeles—a bright and guilty place.”
—Orson Welles
Cast of Characters
Leslie White: An eager and bespectacled young photographer turned investigator whose experiences in Los Angeles later inspire his career as a pulp-fiction writer.
Dave Clark: A suave war hero and crusading prosecutor, drawn into the darkness of the rackets.
Nancy Clark: A petite blonde, daughter of a famed New York judge and Dave Clark’s volatile yet adoring wife.
Albert Marco, aka Marco Albori: A plug-ugly gangster brought down by Clark.
Gene Coughlin: A top reporter for many L.A. papers, notably the tabloid
Illustrated Daily News
, who comes to know Clark only too well.
Buron Fitts: A decorated WWI marine and longtime District Attorney for Los Angeles, he becomes an immensely controversial and influential figure in the city’s history.
Asa “Ace” Keyes: Fitts’s predecessor as D.A., indicted for bribery.
Lucien Wheeler: A graduate of Notre Dame, secret service bodyguard to presidents, FBI bureau chief, and private eye—a man of power and subtlety, carving a high-profile career in law enforcement.
Blayney Matthews: An investigator for Buron Fitts and another former FBI man, he was also White’s colleague and pal.
C. C. Julian: A breezy oil speculator and Ponzi-scheme operator whose company, Julian Petroleum (the Julian Pete), seizes the imagination of L.A.—and much of the city’s cash.
Jake Berman, aka Jack Bennett: A slick and handsome con artist, milking millions from the house of cards that Julian built.
E. L. Doheny: An aging oil magnate—the richest man in L.A. in the 1920s, and one of the richest in America—embroiled in the nationwide scandal known as “Teapot Dome.”
Ned Doheny, Jr.: His only son, found dead with a bullet in his brain one night in 1929.
Hugh Plunkett: Ned’s personal secretary, chauffeur, friend, and possibly more; he is also found shot through the head.
Charlie Crawford, aka The Gray Wolf: A onetime saloon keeper who runs the Los Angeles “System,” the discreet yet all-powerful and money-spinning network of graft and racketeering; he meets his end with a slug from a Colt pistol.
Kent Parrot: A USC football hero, law school graduate, and political force; he is also Crawford’s enabler who has the mayor in his pocket.
Morris Lavine: A famed newsman for the
Los Angeles Examiner
with a finger in too many corrupt pies; he later becomes a top attorney.
Erle Stanley Gardner: An attorney in Ventura County who works at his law firm all day and writes 4,000 words of fiction every night; he becomes a close friend of Leslie White’s.
Raymond Chandler: The future noir laureate of L.A., who worked through the 1920s as an oil executive; he sees and remembers it all.
Dashiell Hammett: The former Pinkerton detective and leading light of hardboiled writing; he plays an unwitting part in the demise of a Hollywood star.
The Reverend Robert “Fighting Bob” Shuler: A radio evangelist whose down-home appeal and attacks on Hollywood depravity make him a political player.
The Reverend Gustav Briegleb: Shuler’s onetime lieutenant and later his rival; friend to Charlie Crawford.
Motley Flint: A banker to Hollywood and brother to a U.S. senator; gunned down in court.
Clara Bow: The biggest movie star of her era, a reckless redheaded bombshell who beds Gary Cooper, John Gilbert, John Wayne, et al.,
et al.
Daisy DeVoe: Clara Bow’s tough and smart-mouthed assistant, herself no slouch in the vixen department.
Herbert Spencer: Another reporter working all the angles; also killed by a bullet.
Guy McAfee: Nicknamed “Slats” and “Beanpole” due to his height; onetime LAPD vice cop turned racketeer; plotting to seize control of The System.
June Taylor: Albert Marco’s trusted confidante and a knockout brothel keeper; instrumental in Clark’s downfall.
W. I. Gilbert: A canny defense attorney and friend to the stars, celebrated for his courtroom stunts.
Joseph Ford: A veteran prosecutor and founder of the law school at Loyola Marymount University.
Lincoln Steffens: Author of
The Shame of the Cities
, classic muckraking account of urban American graft, and a mentor to Leslie White.
With supporting appearances from:
William Mulholland, Roscoe “Fatty” Arbuckle, Earl Rogers, F. Scott Fitzgerald, Edmund Wilson, Louis Adamic, Carey McWilliams, Al Capone, Budd Schulberg, B. P. Schulberg, Alexander Pantages, Jerry Giesler, David O. Selznick, Charlie Chaplin, Albert Einstein, Myron Brinnig, John Fante, Horace McCoy, James M. Cain … and others.
1
The Mystery Is Announced
C
HARLIE CRAWFORD AND EDITOR SLAIN!” screamed the headline in the
Los Angeles Illustrated Daily News
. The date was Thursday, March 20, 1931. At about 4:30 P.M. the previous afternoon the fifty-four-year-old Crawford, nicknamed “The Gray Wolf” because of the silvery-gray hair that waved and curled across his head, had been gunned down in his office on Sunset Boulevard. Also killed was Herbert Spencer, a veteran journalist who’d been with Crawford in the room. “EX-BOSS FALLS TO LONG-FEARED GUNMAN BULLET,” the
News
went on. “Crawford, kingpin politician, lived until 8:32 P.M. last night, a little more than four hours after the shooting. He died without revealing the identity of his assailant, according to detectives …”
Crawford had been, and many believed he still was, a “boss,” a key player in what was known as “The System,” a low-profile but all-powerful syndicate that ran the gambling, prostitution, and bootlegging rackets in Los Angeles. “He was the most feared and dictatorial power in the city, its behind-the-scenes czar,” wrote Beverly Davis, who ran an upscale brothel for Crawford. “You could get away with murder under his wing.” This was L.A.’s brand of gangsterism: Crawford used officers of the Los Angeles Police Department to collect the take from the underworld captains. He worked behind the scenes with Kent Kane Parrot, a fixer who’d had George Cryer, the mayor of Los Angeles from 1921–29, pretty much in his pocket. It was a discreet yet effective arrangement that had been in place since Crawford and Parrot contrived to get Cryer elected. As far as the rackets were concerned, L.A. had been a closed town ever since, locked down by Crawford and The System. “It was the most lucrative, the most efficient, and the best-entrenched graft operation in the country,”
News
city editor Matt Weinstock wrote later. Now somebody was monkeying with that operation, trying to destroy it perhaps, or take it over.
“Racketeer bullets declared open warfare in the Los Angeles underworld yesterday,” said the
L.A. Examiner
. “MAN HUNT ON!” An announcement went out over the newly perfected LAPD radio system: “Wanted for murder—an American, about six feet tall, weighing between 150 and 175 pounds, and between 35 and 40 years of age. Hair, brown. A small black moustache. Dressed in neat blue suit and wearing sailor straw hat.”
Was this the killer? It seemed so.
“The political structure rocked precariously while everybody tried to imagine who could have fired the fatal shots,” wrote Leslie White, a young detective working in the investigative unit of the District Attorney’s office. For White, the case had a particular significance, a poignancy almost. He’d met Charlie Crawford several times and had liked him. “Despite the unanimous opinion that the murder of Crawford was a piece of civic betterment, I felt a pang,” White wrote. “Would his death improve the city in any way? I doubted it. A new boss might be less efficiently corrupt. The King was dead—but who would seek the throne?”
White worked downtown, in the Hall of Justice, a new building opposite the even newer white tower of City Hall. On that morning after the shootings, White was in his small cubbyhole of an office, talking with colleagues, trying to figure out who could have pulled the trigger when his boss, Blayney Matthews, the burly and genial head of the D.A.’s investigative unit, came in with the news.
“We’re looking for Dave Clark,” Matthews said.
Leslie White blinked—unable, for a moment, to believe his ears.
“Our
Dave Clark,” he said.
“That’s right,” Matthews said, and White rocked back in his chair.
Dave Clark—known to the press as “Debonair Dave” or “Handsome Dave”—was a crusading litigator and former assistant district attorney who was now running for judge. He was a war hero with matinee-idol looks. He was, moreover, Leslie White’s friend.
“Had the chief suddenly accused
me
of the crime, I couldn’t have been more astounded,” White wrote.
Sorry to see Dave Clark’s name in any way connected with this sensational crime, White hoped for the best, believing that at any moment Clark would arrive at the Hall of Justice and clear his name. But hours went by and nothing happened, and White himself became involved in the unavailing search for the suspect. Dave Clark had vanished, nowhere to be found.
A great crime saga had been set in motion, with toothsome details that Raymond Chandler—who, at the time, was an executive in L.A.’s oil business—would soon feed directly into one of his very first works of fiction, the short story “Spanish Blood.” Chandler, when he turned to writing, wrote what he knew, and he knew Los Angeles—not just its map and climates, but its history of corruption and violence. Like James M. Cain, Horace McCoy, and others who wrote in and about L.A. during the years of the Great Depression, Chandler drew material from the headlines and bullet-prose of the tabloids. True crime tells the story of how L.A. got hardboiled and noir.
Flash back to 1910, when the population of Los Angeles was 310,000 or thereabouts, many of them Spanish-speaking. “There were more cows than people,” says the writer and historian D. J. Waldie, and he might not have been joking. Ten years later, in 1920, the population was 576,000. By 1930 the figure would rise to 1,250,000, and L.A. County—which gathers together various unincorporated cities, including Santa Monica, Beverly Hills, Venice, and Culver City, as well as the city of L.A. itself—would be home to almost 2.5 million souls.
Throughout this astonishing period, L.A. was the fastest-growing city in the world. In America only San Francisco had ever grown so fast, during the years of the Gold Rush following 1849. But by the 1920s, San Francisco’s boom was long done. New York, Boston, and even Chicago had never known an explosion like the one that was happening in L.A. Every working day throughout the 1920s, builders started more than fifty new homes. Each week a new hotel went up. The year 1923 alone saw the construction of 800 office buildings, 400 industrial buildings, 150 schools, 130 warehouses, 700 apartment buildings, and more than 25,000 single dwellings. Property prices doubled, tripled, quadrupled, eventually rising sixfold through the decade. The city began to spread, amoeba-like, in search of its suburbs, although in those days L.A. still meant downtown, thriving with business and residences. In 1923 a
Saturday Evening Post
article about the boom ran a photo showing the district, chockablock with office buildings, all about twelve to fifteen stories tall, as high as the earthquake regulations would then allow. “Most of these buildings are less than a year old,” said the caption.
L.A. was “a civilization that will not need to hang its head when the Athens of Pericles is mentioned,” wrote the
New Republic
in 1927—when L.A. seemed like a strapping youth, foolish and violent at times, bursting out of its skin with exuberance. Within a few years the
New Republic’s
pronouncement would seem bizarre and deluded. By 1931 the depression gripped California. Capitalism was in crisis and people no longer spoke of L.A. as a utopia with the added luxury of a voluptuous climate. Rather, for a while the whole social fabric was stretched and tattered and in danger of being torn in two. L.A. still had the sunshine, but it could be a lonely and hellish place—rife with crime, riddled by corruption, and drained of civic and moral purpose. Banks failed, thousands of businesses went to the wall, foreclosures hit epidemic proportions, and empty lots awaited the rush of investment that had until recently seemed so certain. People blew their brains out, gassed themselves, hanged themselves, took pills and poison, slit their wrists, or walked into the ocean. Southern California became America’s suicide capital, an amazing phenomenon on which Edmund Wilson would report for the
New Republic
, driven to revise its previous optimism. In 1931 alone there were over 750 suicides in L.A.; so many threw themselves from the handsome Colorado Street Bridge crossing the Arroyo Seco Canyon in Pasadena that the city first appointed a special police detail to guard the bridge and, when that didn’t work, erected high fences of barbed wire to stop people from jumping which remain to this day.
In its early days, L.A. attracted lower middle-class and middle-middle-class retirees from the American Midwest, people drawn to the life of relaxed ease promoted in the booster ads of L.A.’s Chamber of Commerce. A further growth spurt came with the development of an industrial base in the 1920s. At the same time the recently arrived movie business began to attract a different sort of young person—attractive, ambitious, driven. One could argue that L.A. needed and invented Hollywood in order to provide itself with a different demographic and to achieve maturity. Then yet another element was thrown into the mix. After 1929 the character of immigration changed again as the roads into California filled with the armies of the indigent and the unemployed, riding in battered jalopies or hitchhiking. At the height of the Depression 1,500 arrived daily, many of them boys, said
The Nation
, “who beat their way out on freight trains and are in danger of becoming hopeless tramps or criminals.”
In this defeated atmosphere, the expressionless blue of the sky and the unchanging rhythm of perfect days that followed each other one after the other added to the melancholy. “Outside the bright gardens had a haunted look, as though wild eyes were watching me from behind the bushes, as though the sunshine itself had a mysterious something in the light,” wrote Raymond Chandler.
Cities have characters, pathologies that can make or destroy or infect you, states of mind that run through daily life as surely as a fault line. Chandler’s “mysterious something” was a mood of disenchantment, an intense spiritual malaise that identified itself with Los Angeles at a particular time, what we call noir. On the one hand noir is a narrow film genre, born in Hollywood in the late 1930s when a European visual style, the twisted perspectives and stark chiaroscuros of German Expressionism, met an American literary idiom. This fruitful comingling gave birth to movies like
Double Indemnity
, directed by Vienna-born Billy Wilder and scripted by Raymond Chandler from a James M. Cain novella. The themes—murderous sex and the cool, intricate amorality of money—rose directly from the psychic mulch of Southern California.
But L.A. is a city of big dreams and cruelly inevitable disappointments where noir is more than just a slice of cinema history; it’s a counter-tradition, the dark lens through which the booster myths came to be viewed, a disillusion that shadows even the best of times, an alienation that assails the senses like the harsh glitter of mica in the sidewalk on a pitiless Santa Ana day. Noir—in this sense a perspective on history and often a substitute for it—was born when the Roaring Twenties blew themselves out and hard times rushed in; it crystallized real-life events and the writhing collapse of the national economy before finding its interpreters in writers like Raymond Chandler.
In this book I evoke the time when Los Angeles came of age and found a defining tone. Many people—some famous, others not—will feature in an urban mosaic in which everything and everybody seems to be connected, and, in one way or another, is corrupt, is seeking corruption, or is trying to escape it. But, for me, the story belongs most prominently to two very different young men, both long dead and largely forgotten: Leslie T. White and David H. Clark. White, as we’ve seen, was for a while a D.A.’s investigator. In time he, like Raymond Chandler, would transform himself into a writer. For Clark, the veteran from WWI and high-flying attorney, the future would be very different. White, who was small and slight and peered at the world through horn-rimmed spectacles, proved himself undauntable. The tall and suave Clark, with his movie star looks and his huge promise, went wrong in a most spectacular way. These contrasting trajectories have much to say about Los Angeles, and maybe about America. The two men are symbols of light and dark, linked emblems in a city’s scandalous process of becoming.