Catching Hell: A Hot Contemporary Romance (18 page)

That did it. Tyler bulled his way into the middle of the group and announced, “JT Moran is the best right fielder to play for Texas in a decade.”

For a heartbeat, all three guys just stared. They recognized him; it’d be hard not to, with the shitty “career retrospective” the reporters had aired between the third and fourth innings. Lawyer Guy held up his hands, palms out, as he said, “Hey, man. It’s just a game. We have the right to express our opinions.”

Tyler set his mug on the bar, only the precision of the move giving the slightest hint that he was four beers down for the night. “Your opinions are wrong,” he said, directing his words to Tennis Dude. No reason to screw with the other guys. Might as well go for the leader.

That was the first lesson Tyler had ever learned in schoolyard fights, and it translated pretty well to bars. Take down the leader, and the rest of the guys’ll back off, run away like screaming little girls.
 

It wasn’t like Tyler
wanted
to fight. He would have just ignored the dipshits, if they’d been ragging on anyone else. But not JT Not the guy who’d had his back for the five years he’d spent in the majors.

And that wasn’t just the beer talking. Tyler was going to be lost in Raleigh without JT, without the only teammate who knew the truth about Tyler but had never told a living soul. Not since that first day, when they’d both stood in the locker room, staring at a notice on the team bulletin board. Tyler had known it was important, with bold letters and a headline in red. But he couldn’t pin down the words, couldn’t get the text to stop jumping all over the goddamn page.

JT had waited for Tyler to say something. Waited for him to react to whatever was posted there, plain as day. And when Tyler hadn’t said boo, JT grumbled, “Team meeting’s moved to seven. Last one there is volunteered to sit in the team’s booth at the State Fair all day Sunday.”

Tyler had snorted. And hustled off to the meeting with JT. But he’d seen the look in the other player’s eyes. JT knew his secret. JT knew Tyler couldn’t read.
 

Not that the guy ever made a big deal out of it. He let Tyler figure things out the way he always had—watching the guys to see what gate they all walked to at the airport, flipping through official forms like he was too busy to study them, just signing wherever someone pointed out a giant X. Tyler wasn’t an idiot, after all. He’d figured out how to sign his own name back in grade school. Numbers hardly ever gave him trouble.

But when he was lost, when there wasn’t any hint about what he was supposed to do, where he was supposed to go? Somehow, JT always managed to be there. He’d make a joke out of it, turn everything into a story. He’d make it sound all casual-like, as he told Tyler exactly what was going on.

And JT wasn’t going to be in Raleigh.

Tyler would be on his own, for the first time in five years.

So maybe he was just ready to beat the shit out of three over-privileged college dudes who thought JT Moran should have taken the base on balls, should have walked to first.

And Tennis Dude wasn’t exactly
trying
to keep the peace. “Shit, man,” the guy said. “If your
boyfriend
just lost us the game, that isn’t your fault. You’re not even on the team any more.”

Rage.

Instant, heart-stopping rage, painting Tyler’s vision crimson, folding his hands into fists. This wasn’t the hotheaded push-and-shove of a fight on the baseball diamond, the type of bench-clearing brawl that added up to a lot of hot words and a few sharp jabs with the heel of a hand. This was the white-hot desire to
obliterate
someone, to make someone pay.
 

“What?” Tennis Dude said, laughing. “You’re going to
fight
me?”

Lawyer Guy tried to intervene, saying to Tyler: “Hey, man, come on. He didn’t mean anything by it.”

But Tennis Dude waved off his friend. “I meant every word I said.” He stepped away from the bar, squaring off in a way that told Tyler the guy wasn’t a stranger to throwing a punch. He probably worked out in some gym with his
personal trainer
, learned to go after the heavy bag as part of his
fitness regimen
. That was fine. Tyler wasn’t a stranger to a good fight, himself.

“Come on,” said Baseball Cap. “Jackson, leave him alone.”

Jackson
. Tennis Dude.
 

Tyler didn’t take his eyes off Jackson as he taunted, “What about it? Going to listen to your friend? Sit down and have another—what? A
cosmo
? A goddamn
appletini
?”

“Leave me alone, asshole,” Jackson growled.

“Make me.”

Those two words dripped from Tyler’s lips, burning like gasoline.
Make me
. The order that had kicked off every playground fight in his childhood. The rebellious demand that had sparked a dozen battles with his brothers. The defiant claim that had kept him after school for countless detention sessions, until he’d finally figured out he’d rather go to baseball practice, to football practice, to
basketball
if that was the only sport in season, than to sit in a windowless classroom, staring at a clock, and waiting for the bell to ring so he’d finally be free.

His heart pounded. He forced himself to take a deep breath, to steady himself like he was staring down a 100-mile-an-hour fastball. He was all too aware of the alcohol pumping through his veins; he couldn’t move as fast, strike as accurately as if he were stone, cold sober. But things had gone too far for him to back down now. Way too far.

Jackson swung first.

Tyler ducked away, catching the worst of the blow on his biceps. The guy was stronger than he looked. Tyler swung a quick left hook, automatically folding his thumb over his knuckles instead of inside his fist, to keep from breaking it. The blow glanced off Jackson’s forearm.

Tyler heard a woman scream. Lawyer Guy started swearing. Someone shouted, “Call 911!”

Jackson threw another punch, connecting directly with Tyler’s jaw, hard enough to make him see stars. The blow unlocked something in Tyler’s brain. He forgot about being a professional baseball player. He forgot about drowning his sorrows, about drinking away his last night in Texas. He forgot about everything except beating the living shit out of the guy in front of him.

The bartender and the bouncer finally wrestled them apart. But not before Jackson’s nose was broken, gushing blood. Not before Tyler’s knuckles were bruised and bleeding.

And not before the wail of a siren silenced every last voice in the bar.

* * *

Emily Holt sat in her best friend’s office, wondering if she was making the biggest mistake of her life.

“Anna, the guy’s a
criminal
.”

Anna Benson shrugged. “He’s a ballplayer. They all get into trouble at some point. Besides, you’re a social worker. Isn’t it your mission to get troubled souls back on track?”

“It was my mission to help victims of abuse rebuild their lives, until the hospital laid me off!”

Anna’s face grew serious. “That’s why this is so perfect. You
need
to get back on the horse, get back to work. And Tyler needs this chance.
I
need this chance, Em.”

“But the guy was in a bar fight! He pleaded guilty to assault!” Emily couldn’t put into words how much the thought disgusted her. After spending a couple of years counseling women who’d been beaten by the men in their lives, she had no sympathy for a man who used his fists when he got angry. Angry and drunk.
 

Anna shook her head. “It’s not like that. The other guy threw the first punch. Brock only took the plea because he had to wrap things up in Texas. We need him here, to start playing tonight.” Anna softened her voice into the cajoling tones she’d used for the past seven years, whenever she needed something special from her best friend. “Come on, Em. They wouldn’t have let him off with community service if he was a threat to anyone.”

Say that to the guy he beat up!
That’s what Emily was going to say. But she didn’t get the words out of her mouth before there was a sharp double knock on the office door.

“Come in,” Anna called, casting an apologetic look at Emily.
 

Emily knew that look. It meant Anna had decided to act first and ask forgiveness later. Same thing she’d done countless times back at the University of Michigan—dragging Emily out on terrible double dates, securing off-campus housing where the pipes froze in the first winter cold snap, pushing Emily into study groups that just happened to include Anna’s crush-of-the-moment. The two women had met during Freshman Week at the University of Michigan—two North Carolina girls astonished at how far they were from home—and they’d immediately become fast friends.

So Emily wasn’t surprised when the office door opened and two men walked into the room. She even smiled and nodded at the first guy—Zach Ormond—although he only had eyes for Anna. Emily couldn’t help but glance at her friend’s hand, at the sensible, square-cut diamond that glinted on her ring finger. Anna and Zach had been engaged for less than a week, but it already seemed like they could read each other’s minds.

That sort of familiarity, that sort of
love
didn’t seem possible. At least not to Emily. She’d never felt anything close to it before. Sure, she’d had more than her share of boyfriends. She’d gone out on countless dates. She’d even had a couple of long-term relationships, if a month or two counted as long-term. But she’d never felt the absolute trust, the sheer certainty that shimmered off her best friend now.

Emily turned away, her throat thickening with unexpected emotion. And she found herself face to face with Tyler Brock, Criminal Mastermind.

Okay. Not a mastermind. A mastermind didn’t start a bar fight on his last night in town. A mastermind didn’t get slugged in that fight, leaving a pretty remarkable purple bruise along the left side of his jaw. A mastermind didn’t plead guilty in frantically short order, accepting the court’s full sentence, so he could resolve the matter before he moved halfway across the country to his new job. And a mastermind definitely did not scramble for the first community service job tossed his way, desperate to serve his time and erase his criminal record forever.

But suddenly, looking at Tyler, Emily found that not one bit of that mattered. Because the man who had followed Zach into Anna’s office stole her breath away, boiling off every protest left in her arsenal.
 

It wasn’t just those chocolate eyes, so dark that his pupils seemed to disappear. It wasn’t only the unruly black hair, the tousled waves that invited her fingers to tease them back into order. It wasn’t even the edges of the tattoo that peeked from beneath the sleeve of his tight black T-shirt, the tribal markings leaving sharp black points against his tawny skin.

It was the grin.
 

By rights, she reasoned, Tyler should have been nervous. He was meeting the woman—Anna—who was for all intents and purposes the owner of the Rockets baseball team. He’d arrived in Raleigh under a cloud, detained by the legal system for two full days when he should have been playing first base for his new club. The media had been howling since the deal was announced—first with glee, then with bitter condemnation. He’d been called a hothead, a bad boy, a head case just waiting to fall apart at the first sign of serious pressure on his new team.

But with that one grin, he made it clear that none of the media frenzy mattered. Nothing would get in the way of Tyler Brock being Tyler Brock. The painful-looking bruise along his jaw only heightened his devil-may-care appearance. As he shook Emily’s hand, Anna made a bemused introduction.
 

Emily told herself not to make anything of the contact that jolted her heart like a live wire. Her fingers
always
tingled when she met someone new. Her palm
always
felt like it was basking in the sun. Her heart
always
leaped in her chest, strangling her words, flooding her cheeks with a raging blush.
 

Emily lied to herself a lot. At least when it came to the men in her life.

“Pleased to meet you,” she said. Good. Her voice didn’t betray her.
 

Anna wasn’t nearly as affected by her new acquisition. She got right down to business. “Tyler, as you know, the court in Texas has transferred administration of your case to a judge here in Raleigh. Fortunately, the Rockets have some fans on the local bench. We can help you find appropriate community service, so you can complete your sentence and get this entire matter behind you.”

Tyler shoved his hands into his pockets. The action made his shoulders ripple—shoulders that were emphasized by the tight lines of his shirt. He had to realize what he was doing. He had to know he was making Emily’s belly swoop low, as if she’d just plunged down the slope of the world’s highest roller coaster.

Anna continued, as if she were impervious to the sinful waves of attraction washing off the ballplayer in front of her. Which, come to think of it, she probably was, with her own true love watching attentively at her side. “The team thinks it’s important, Tyler, for your community service to be highly visible. We need you helping the citizens of Raleigh, showing that you have the best interests of your new home in mind. I’ve asked Emily here because she has a project that meets all of our needs.”

Anna flashed her a broad smile, gesturing with one open hand as if to say, “The floor is yours.” Emily barely resisted the urge to wrinkle her nose, to roll her eyes, even to stick out her tongue. Wasn’t it just like Anna to put her on the spot like this?
 

But truth be told, Emily had played plenty of her own manipulative games in the past. Just a few weeks ago, she’d forced Anna and Zach into a conversation that neither of them had wanted to have—and look how things had turned out there! She might as well embrace the opportunity Anna was giving her.
 

Easier said than done. Her cheeks were on fire. She wanted to run her fingers through her hair, but she knew that would make her look like she was five years old—the curse of having shoulder-length blonde curls. She’d give anything for something to hold in her hands, something to keep her fingers busy.